Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolutions - 1986.11.20 - 10930Miscellaneous Resolution # 86313 November 6, 1986 BY: PERSONNEL COMMITTEE - John J. McDonald, Chairperson IN RE: PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT - REQUESTED CHANGES TO EMPLOYEE BENEFIT PROGRAM TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Mr. Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen: WHEREAS the County continues to review and evaluate the overall benefit program provided to County employees with the goal of maintaining the quality of current benefits in the most cost effective manner and of improving benefits where warranted within existing benefit expenditures; and WHEREAS our present traditional health care coverage can be more closely monitored by the programs of PREVENT (PREcertification to VErify Necessary Treatment) and MSO (Mandatory Second Opinion) offered by our current traditional health care carrier while at the same time offering employees the option of paid second opinions for non-emergency surgical procedures beyond those second opinions required by the MSO program; and WHEREAS within existing benefit dollars it is possible to provide employees with a new vision care program and to increase the level of ortho- dontia benefits in the dental program when combined with an increase in the Master Medical deductible requirement and Drug Rider Co-Pay amount; and WHEREAS deductible and co-pay levels for these benefits have never been increased while salaries have increased significantly since these pro- grams were added to the employee benefit package; and WHEREAS implementation of all these changes will improve the overall - quality of benefit services while reducing the benefit costs to the County, and identical changes have been negotiated with the County's largest repre- sented employee groups; NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the following benefit changes be authorized for all non-represented active employees who are eligible for fringe benefits and for retired employees where applicable, effective on or as soon after December 31, 1986 as is practicable: 1. Add a vision care program for eligible active employees who have completed six months service, with benefit provisions as described on the attachment; , /7 2. Increase the current maximum level of orthodontia reimbursement for dependent children under age 19 from $500 to $750; 3. Add a Second Surgical Opinion Program as offered by the current traditional health care carrier; 4. Add a PREVENT (PREcertification to VErify Necessary Treatment) Program as offered by the current traditional health care carrier; 5. Change the present Master Medical Option 4 program to Master Medical Option 2 which will increase the deductible level from $50/person and $100/family per year to $100/person and $200/ family per year; 6. Change the present Drug Rider Co-Pay requirement from $2.00 per prescription to $3.00 per prescription. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Vision Care Program be provided at no expense to full time eligible employees and that the program be made available to part-time eligible employees who elect the coverage and agree to pay one-half the premium cost. Mr. Chairperson, on behalf of the Personnel Committee, I move the adoption of the foregoing resolution. PERSONNEL COMMITTEE RECOMMENDED 1987 FRINGE BENEFIT PACKAGE REVISIONS Overview of Recommendation The Personnel Department is recommending extending a number of health care related changes for 1987 to the non-represented employee group identical to those contained in the negotiated labor agreements with several represented employee groups. Certain of the changes are also being recommended to be extended to retirees. These changes were instituted in part in July 1986 with remaining changes scheduled for January 1987 for the two Sheriff Depart- ment ibargaining units. They are also scheduled for implementation in January with the OCEU and Public Health Nurses bargaining units. A tentative agree- ment has been reached in the area of fringe benefit changes only with the AFSC&ME group representing Children's Village, Camp Oakland and Probate Court employees. This tentative agreement contains identical benefit revisions to those negotiated with the other groups. Union groups agreeing to these changes, including the AFSC&ME group, cover 1,306 of the 1,351 represented positions in the County. The recommended changes briefly are as follows: 1. Add a vision care program for eligible employees who have completed six Months service; 2. Increase the current maximum level of orthodontia reimbursement for dependent children under age 19 from $500 to $750; 3. Add a Second Surgical Opinion Program as offered by the current traditional health care carrier; 4. Add a PREVENT (PREcertification to VErify Necessary Treatment) Pro- gram as offered by the current traditional health care carrier; 5. Change the present Master Medical Option 4 program to Master Medical Option 2 which will increase the deductible level from $50/person and $100/family per year to $100/person and $200/family per year; 6. Change the present Drug Rider Co-Pay requirement from $2.00 per prescription to $3.00 per prescription. It is recommended that the Vision Care Program be provided at no expense to full time eligible employees and that the program be made available to part-time eligible employees who elect the coverage and agree to pay one-half the premium cost. Recommended changes #2 - 6 would be placed into effect for retirees where applicable. Cost savings from the four hospitalization/medical changes represent a 6.1% reduction of the 1986 amount budgeted for hospitalization/medical coverage for active employees and a 9.0% reduction for retirees. Offsetting these savings with the two improvements for active employees, adding optical and increasing orthodontia benefits, still results in a 4.0% reduction of the total 1986 amount budgeted for hospitalization/medical and dental insur- ance coverages. Dollar savings from the four hospitalization/medical changes is projected at $524,164. Net savings after considering the areas of improve- ment are estimated to be $368,766. Financial impact sheets are included as Attachment A (pages 4 and 4a of this package). Brief Description of Benefit Changes 1. Vision Care Program Provides for vision testing examinations once every 24 months with a $5/member co-pay; testing is by optometrist or opthamologist at the providers choice with additional examination by an opthamologist if recommended by an optometrist. Provides for corrective lenses and frames once every 24 months with a $7.50/member co-pay; standard daily wear contact lenses generally are covered; standard lenses and frames are covered; dispensing fee and fees for selecting, fitting and adjusting of frames are covered. More detail is included as an attachment to the suggested Board Resolution (page 11 of this package). 2. Orthodontia Reimbursement Limit The present lifetime limit of $500 per eligible dependent would be increased to $750. This limit has not been increased since dental benefits were provided to County employees. 3. Second Surgical Opinion Program Employees must obtain an employer paid second opinion for 10 of the more common non-emergency surgeries; failure to obtain the opinion would generally require the employee to pay 20% of the approved physician payment; An employee may request an employer paid third opinion if the First two opinions disagree; the insurance carrier will make the full normal approved payment for surgery without regard to the second or third opinion if the employee has obtained the opinion(s) and elects to proceed with the surgery; For most non-emergency surgeries, other than the ten required, em- ployees may obtain an employer paid second opinion; Appointments for second or third opinions must be made from the list of physicians supplied through the carrier referral center. Members covered by an HMO and individuals covered by "Complementary" to Medicare coverage are not covered by this program; A copy of the carrier pamphlet describing the program is included as Attachment B (page 5 and 6 of this package). -2-- 4. PREVENT (PREcertification to VErify Necessary Treatment) Requires a doctor to request approval for all elective inpatient admissions to hospitals; maternity admissions do not require advance approval but the doctor must notify before the expected admission date; the doctor must notify the carrier within one working day of emergency admissions; Written notice is sent to the member, doctor and hospital; employees entering the hospital without having received written pre-approval where required or staying beyond the authorized number of days, once written notice has been received, may have to pay hospital and doctor costs for unapproved days. Members covered by an HMO and individuals covered by "Complementary" to Medicare coverage are not covered by this program; A copy of the carrier pamphlet describing the program is included as Attachment C (page 7 and 8 of this package). 5. Increase the Master Medical Deductible Self-explanatory; the current deductible to be increased from $50/ perSon and $100/family per year to S100/person and $200 per family; The deductible amount has not been raised since the Master Medical program was initially provided to employees. 6. Increase the Drug Rider Co-Pay Self-explanatory; the current co -pay amount required per prescription to be increased from $2 to $3; The co-pay amount has not been raised since the drug rider was initi- ally provided to employees. Summary The recommended changes have been reviewed with the Fringe Benefit Study Group comprised of the Directors of Personnel, Management & Budget and Central Services, the Chief Deputy Treasurer and Manager of Employee Relations. The Study Group supports the changes as presented in these documents. A suggested Board resolution prepared for the Personnel Committee is included as Attachment D (pages 9, 10 and 11 of this package). It should be noted that we are recommending extending the Vision Care coverage to the non-repre- sented and other represented employees through D.O.C. for 1987 under the earlier bidding process with a review during 1987 regarding re-bidding and/or alternate funding arrangements for 1988. -3- 369 497 688 608 819 1,133 2,560 TOTAL 1,006 1,554 ($53,841) ($83,159) ($136,999) ATTACHMENT A OAKLAND COUNTY, MICHIGAN PROPOSED FRINGE HENEEIT CHANGES 1987 FINANCIAL IMPACT FOR ACTIVE EMPLOYEES I. INCREASE ORTHODONTIC BENEFIT FROM $500 TO $750 NO. OF CONTRACTS CURRENT PROPOSED ANNUAL (COST(/SAVINGS ANNUAL ANNUAL REPRESENTED NON-REPRESENTED TOTAL RATE RATE REPRESENTED NON-REPRESENTED TOTAL 1 PERSON 239 369 608 $175.32 $176.16 ($201) 1$310) ($511) 2 PERSON 322 497 819 $274.32 $276.24 (618) (954) (1,572) FAMILY 445 688 1,133 $508.80 $523.20 (6,412) (9,903) (16,315) TOTAL 1,006 1,554 2,560 ($7,231) ($11,168) ($18,398) II, ADDITION OF OPTICAL INSURANCE 1 PERSON 2 PERSON FAMILY 0 $23.40 0 $42.00 0 $78.00 ($5,591) ($8,636) ($14,227) (13,518) (20.880) (34,398) (34,731) (53,643) (88,374) 239 322 445 III. INCREASE DRUG RIDER CO-PAY FROM $2.00 TO $3.00* 1 PERSON 278 430 708 $139.32 $121.68 $4,908 $7,581 $12,489 2 PERSON 344 532 876 $296.04 $259.92 12,435 19,206 31,641 I FAMILY 493 762 1,255 $296.04 $259.92 17,815 27,516 45,331 1 TOTAL 1,116 1,723 2,839 $35,158 $54,303 $89,461 IV. INCREASE MASTER MEDICAL DEDUOTABLE FROM $50/100 TO $100/200* 1 PERSON 278 430 708 $171.12 $117.36 $14,958 $23,104 $38,062 2 PERSON 344 532 876 $285.36 $195.48 30,943 47,792 78,735 FAMILY 493 762 1,255 $346.08 $237.60 53,504 82,638 136.142 TOTAL 1,116 1,723 2,839 $99,405 $153,534 $252,939 V. SECOND OPTION REQUIRED ON SURGERIES* TOTAL 1,116 1,723 2,839 0 ($4.22) $4,708 $7,272 $11.981 VI. PRE-AUTHORIZATION ON HOSPITAL ADMISSIONS* TOTAL 1,116 1,723 - 2,839 0 ($32.93) $36,741 $56,747 $93,488 TOTAL SAVINGS** $114,941 *The combined savings from these four modifications represents a 6.1% reduction of the 1986 amount budgeted for Hospitalization/Medical coverage. **The Total Savings represents a 3.5% reduction of the 1986 amount budgeted for Hospitalization/Medical and Dental Insurance coverage. PREPARED BY BUDGET DIVISION 10/21/86 $177,530 $292,471 ATTACHMENT A (Continued) OAKLAND COUNTY, MICHIGAN PROPOSED FRINGE BENEFIT CHANGES 1987 FINANCIAL IMPACT FOR RETIREES I. INCREASE DRUG RIDER CO-PAY FROM $2.00 TO $3.00 NUMBER CURRENT PROPOSED ANNUAL OF ANNUAL ANNUAL (COST)/ CONTRACTS RATE RATE SAVINGS 1 PERSON-REGULAR 70 $139.32 $121.68 $1,235 2 PERSON-REGULAR 83 $296.04 $259.92 2,998 FAMILY 16 $296.04 $259.92 578 1 COMPLEMENTARY 292 $283.20 $248.16 10,232 2 COMPLEMENTARY 139 $566.40 8496.32 9,741 1 COMPL, & 1 REG. 76 $422.52 $372.54 3,798 TOTAL 676 $28,582 II. INCREASE MASTER MEDICAL DEDUCTABLE FROM $50/100 TO $100/200 1 PERSON-REGULAR 70 $171.12 $117.36 $3,763 2 PERSON-REGULAR 83 $285.36 $195.48 7,460 , FAMILY 16 $346.08 8237.60 1,736 1 COMPLEMENTARY 292 $32.16 $32.16 0 2 COMPLEMENTARY 139 $64.20 $64.20 0 1 COMPL. & 1 REG. 76 $267.48 $213.72 4,086 TOTAL 676 $17,045 III. PRE-AUTHORIZATION ON HOSPITAL ADMISSIONS TOTAL-REGULAR 169 0 ($181.47) 30,668 IV. SECOND OPINION REQUIRED FOR SURGERIES TOTAL-REGULAR 169 0 N/A* N/A* TOTAL SAVINGS* $76,295 *Savings estimates were not available at the time of printing. **The Total Savings represents a '1.0% reduction of the 1986 amount budgeted for Hospitalization Insurance coverage for retirees. PREPARED BY BUDGET DIVISION 10/23/86 -4a- ATTACIIMENT BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD OF MICHIGAN WHAT IF I HAVE TO STAY IN THE HOSPITAL BEYOND THE NUMBER OF DAYS YOU INITIALLY APPROVED? The hospital and your doctor can request additional days for your admission. This must be done at least 48 hours before the end of the days initially approved. Again, we'll let you, your doctor,' and the hospital know if additional days will be covered. If we do not approve additional days beyond the initial number, you may have to pay for the hospital and doctor care received beyond the days we ap- prove. WHAT IF MY DOCTOR DOES NOT REQUEST APPROVAL BEFORE I'M ADMITTED? We will not pay for hospital or doctor care that has not received our advance approv- al.You may have to pay those costs. WHA iF MY DOCTOR DOESN'T AGREE WITH YOUR DECISION? Your doctor can appeal our decision. Our medical staff will review the appeal and make a decision that is final. -5- CF 3708 MAR 84 1. (PREcertification to VErify Necessary Treatment);, . • An innovative program to, help you and: yourphysician use your health benefits in a wise and • cost-effective way. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan is committed to developing programs to help hold down health care costs. In keeping with that commitment, we have designed a unique program that provides a cost-saving method for you, your doctor, and hospitals to better manage your health benefits. The program is called PREVENT (PREcertification to VErify Necessary Treatment). The main focus of the program is on containing costs by eliminating unnecessary and expensive inpatient hospital care and by establishing appropriate inpatient lengths of stay in advance of admission. PREVENT allows your employer to continue providing you the highest level of coverage possible by simply incorporating direct controls on how benefits are used. The following questions and answers will tell you more about how this program works. WHO IS COVERED BY PREVENT? Everyone on your contract except individu- als covered by ''Complementary" to Medi- care coverage or a Health Maintenance Organization (HMO). MOW WILL IT HELP TIE? PREVENT will assist in the effective use of your health care benefits. We will let you know, in writing, what is covered before your hospital admission. -6- HOW DOES PREVENT WORK? PREVENT requires your doctor to request approval for all elective (non-emergency) inpatient admissions to participating Michi- gan hospitals. Your doctor must send us a special form at least two weeks before the admission. WHAT IF A TWO-WEEK NOTICE IS NOT POSSIBLE? Your doctor can call us for an immediate review of the admission request. WHA; 3APPENS MIEN YOU GET MY DOCTOR'S ADMISSION REOLEST? First, we'll review the request and deter- mine whether or not your admission will be covered. If we approve your inpatient ad- mission, well also determine the number of days for which benefits will be paid. Within several days, we will send written notice of our decision to you, your doctor, and the hospital. WHAT tF THERE IS Ar 7.11ERGENCY r3MiSSION? Emergency admissions don't need advance approval. However, your doctor must notify us within one working day of your ad- mission. We will then determine the number of days which will be covered. We will notify you, your doctor, and the hospital of our decision in writing. WHAT ABOUT MATERNITY ADMISSIONS? Maternity admissions don't need advance approval. But your doctor must notify us before the expected admission date so that we can determine the number of days we'll cover. We will send written notice of our decision to you, your doctor, and the hospital. s',:;10SS riilV) Shield 0-Ngan CF 6728 AUG 83 4L consulting physician you select from the list. (The Referral Center telephone number is: (313) 225-- 0700. If you live outside of the Detroit Metropolitan area, you may call toll-free 1-800-832-6789). You may not arrange your own appointment under this Program. ARE THERE RESTRICTIONS ON THE CHOICE OF A CONSULTANT UNDER THE SECOND SURGICAL OPINION PROGRAM? Yes. You must choose a consulting physician from the names provided by the Referral Center. These consulting physicians have special professional qualifications required by the Second Surgical Opinion Program. The following examples show how the Program works: EXAMPLE A • Your physician recommends heart valve surgery. You arrange for a second opinion through the Referral Center. The consulting physician recommends not having the surgery. However, you schedule the surgery and it is performed as first recommended. • The Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan full, approved payment is made for the surgeon's services. You are not required to accept the recommendation of the consulting physician, but you are required to have a second opinion since this elective surgery is one of the ten (10) procedures for which a second opinion is re- quired under the Program. EXAMPLE B • Your physician recommends a tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy for your child. You schedule the surgery and have it performed without obtaining a second opinion, • The Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan full, approved payment for the surgery will be re- duced by 20% because you did not obtain a second opinion through the Referral Center for this surgery, which is one of the ten (10) for which a second opinion is required. If you did not sign the "Patient Notification of Second Opinion Requirement" form agreeing to pay 20% of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michi- gan app: yi p -:ernent for the surgeon' ser- vices an tYn. A ir the 20% reduction, call the Pete:, ,e EXAMPLE C • Your physician recommends that you have surgery to correct a knee problem. You schedule the surgery and have it performed. • The Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan full, approved payment is made for the surgery be- cause knee surgery is not one of the ten (10) surgeries for which a second opinion consulta- tion is required under the Program. Even though you were not required to obtain a second opinion, you could have arranged one at no cost to you through the Referral Center. Second opinions are also available if you choose for inpatient surgeries other than the ten (10) surgeries for which they are required. Remember, a second opinion will enable you to make a more informed decision about surgery. EXAMPLE D • Your physician tells you that you require emergency surgery for a hernia and you have the surgery without a second opinion. • The Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan full, approved payment will be 'made for the sur- geon's services even though it is one of the ten (10) surgeries generally requiring a second opinion. In this case, the surgery is considered an emergency and the second opinion is waived under the Program. If you have any questions regarding the Second Surgical Opinion Program or want to schedule an appointment, Call: In the Metropolitan Detroit Area . (313) 225-0700 or outside of Metropolitan Detroit 1-800-832-6789 Write: Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan Referral Center J713 600 Lafayette East Detroit, Michigan 48226 SECOND SURGICAL OPINION PROGRAM You and your eligible dependents are covered under a new Second Surgical Opinion Program from Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan. WHAT IS COVERED UNDER THIS PROGRAM? The Program offers a second surgical opinion consultation at no cost to you when a physician recommends and plans to perform any type of non-emergency surgery by admitting you to a Michigan hospital. The Program consists of two parts: • For most non-emergency surgeries, you may obtain a second opinion. • For any of the ten (10) following categories of surgery, you must arrange a second opinion consultation in order for Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan to make the full, approved payment for the surgery, thus avoiding an addi- tional liability. 1. cataract removal 7. fallopian tubes and 2.. gall bladder surgery ovaries surgery 3. hernia repair 8. nasal surgery 4. heart bypass surgery 9. tonsils and/or 5 heart valve surgery adenoids removal hysterectomy 10. prostate surgery In most instances, if you decide not to obtain a nd opinion consultation through the Blue : • . nd Blue Shield of Michigan Referral Center :Iten (10) categories of surgery, you will be ed to sign a form ("Patient Notification of Sec- ond Opinion Requirement") agreeing to pay 20% ef the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan approved amount for the surgeon's services. I he Program will also cover the following services, if you choose to obtain them: • a second surgical opinion for any of the ten (10) surgeries listed above if these surgeries are to be performed in the outpatient depart- ment ol a Michigan hospital, , a third surgical opinion for the ten (10) .surgeries listed above when the second opin- ion did not confirm your surgeon's recommen- dation, • a non-surgical (medical) consultation when recommended by the second opinion con- sulting physician because you have medical complications which may ailed your having surgery. When the appointment is arranged through the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan Referral Center, the program will pay the full cost of the consultation. Laboratory or x-ray tests which the consultant may need to perform will be cov- ered according to your contract benefits. AM I REQUIRED TO HAVE A SECOND OPINION? Yes, but only when the ten (10) categories of elective surgical procedures described in this brochure are planned to be performed while you are an inpatient in a Michigan hospital. If you do not obtain a second opinion arranged through the Referral Center, generally you will be required to pay 20% of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan approved payment for the surgeon's services. If you also sign the Michigan Health Benefits C;lairn Form, you will be responsible for an additional amount il your physician's charge exceeds the Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan approved payment amount for the ten (10) surgeries listed above. WHO IS AFFECTED BY THE PROGRAM? Those subscribers and their eligible dependents enrolled with Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan who have the second opinion rider are subject to the Program. Individuals enrolled in Medicare Part B (as primary coverage) or • members of Health Maintenance Organiza- tions (HMO) are not affected by this Pro- gram. WHAT HAPPENS IF I RESIDE OUTSIDE OF MICHIGAN? The Second Surgical Opinion Program only applies to members enrolled with Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan, who are scheduled to have surgery as an inpatient in a hospital lo- cated in Michigan. If you have surgery performed in a hospital located outside of Michigan, you are not required to have a second opinion lor the ten (10) surgeries described above. WHAT IF THE SURGERY IS AN EMERGENCY AND CANNOT BE DELAYED? The second opinion consultation will not be re- quired for documented emergency surgery. The full, approved payment will also be made when a second opinion is not obtained (1) for surgery performed while hospitalized for another condi- tion or (2) when a consulting physician is un- available duo to time or distance as determined by Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan. ARE THERE ANY SPECIAL PAYMENT PROVISIONS? Yes. In most instances, if you decide not to obtain a second opinion consultation for the ten (10) categories of elective surgical procedures through the Referral Center, you will be asked to sign a form ('Patient Notification of Second Opinion Requirement"), agreeing to pay 20% of the Blue Cross and Blue' Shield of Michigan ap- proved payment for Ihe surgeon's services. IF THE SECOND AND/OR THIRD . OPINION DO NOT AGREE WITH THE FIRST AND I STILL WANT THE SURGERY, WILL BLUE CROSS AND BLUE SHIELD PAY FOR IT? Yes. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Michigan will make lull, approved payment for the surgery will regard to the consulting physician's opinion. HOW CAN THIS HELP ME AND MY ELIGIBLE DEPENDENTS? Surgery is an important decision. Another physi- ciali's opinion gives you and your dependents ad- ditioiral information on which to base the decision whether to have surgery. A second opinion can help you weigh the benefits and risks of the surgery and help you understand any alternative treatment for your medical condition. • HOW DO I ARRANGE FOR A SECOND OPINION? You must contact the Referral Center. The Refer- ral Analyst, who is a Registered Nurse, will ask you to choose a consulting physician from a list of physicians available in your area, The Referral Center will schedule your appointment with the FISCAL NOTE BY: FINANCE COMMITTEE, DR. G. WILLIAM CADDELL, CHAIRPERSON IN RE: PERSONNEL DEPARTMENT-REQUESTED CHANGES TO EMPLOYEE BENEFIT PROGRAM-MISCELLANEOUS RESOLUTION #86313 TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Mr. Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen: Pursuant to Rule XI-G of this Board, the Finance Committee has reviewed Miscellaneous Resolution #86313 and finds: 1) There are no fiscal implications for the 1986 Budget, 2) The fiscal implications for 1987 are included in the 1987 Recommended Budget. FINANCE COMMITTEE November 20, 1986 Resolution # 86313 Moved by McDonald supported by Hassberger the resolution (with Fiscal Note attached) be adopted. Moved by Nelson supported by Hassberger the resolution be amended by adding the following BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED paragraph: BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that these benefit changes also be applied to the AFSCME (American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees) represented employees of the Probate Court, Children's Village and Camp Oakland. A sufficient majority having voted therefor, the amendment carried. Moved by Pernick supported by R. Kuhn the vision care portion of the benefit program be referred back to the Personnel Committee to have it rebid for better vision care coverage. AYES: Page, Perinoff, Pernick, Price, Rowland, Aaron, Doyon, Fortino, R. Kuhn, S. Kuhn, McConnell, McPherson. (12) NAYS: Moffitt, Nelson, Olsen, Rewold, Skarritt, Webb, Wilcox, Caddell, Calandro, Gosling, Hassberger, Hobart, Lanni, Law, McDonald. (15) A sufficient majority not having voted therefor, the motion failed. Vote on resolution as amended: AYES: Nelson, Olsen, Page, Perinoff, Pernick, Price, Rewold, Rowland, Skarritt, Webb, Wilcox, Aaron, Caddell, Calandro, Doyon, Fortino, Gosling, Hassberger, Hobart, R. Kuhn, S. Kuhn, Lanni, Law, McConnell, McDonald, McPherson, Moffitt. (27) NAYS: None. (0) A sufficient majority having voted therefor, the resolution (with Fiscal Note attached) was adopted. $TATE OF MiCH(GAN)_ COUNTY OF OAKLAND) F, Lynn D. Allen, Clerk of the County of Oakland and having a seal, do hereby certify. that I have compared the annexed copy. of Miscellaneous Resolution adopted by the Oakland County Board of Commissioners at their meeting held on November 20, 1986 with the original record thereof now remaining in my office, and that it is a true and correct transcript therefrom, and of the whole thereof. In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of said County at Fontrac, Michigan this 20th day of tictvzjaLp_r____198_§ Lynn/It Allen, Coun .y Cle Register of Deeds