HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolutions - 1974.01.10 - 15077Miscellaneous Resolution 6534 January 10, 1974
BY BUILDINGS & GROUNDS COMMITTEE - Richard R. Wilcox, Chairman
IN RE: CONSTRUCTION OF PROPOSED SKILLED CARE MED ICAL FACILITY
TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
Mr, Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen;
WHEREAS the Facilities and Operations Division of the Board of Auditors
has presented to the Buildings and Grounds Committee a cost estimate report For the
construction of a proposed County skilled care medical facility; and
WHEREAS your Committee recommends that the County of Oakland construct
a 120-bed skilled care medical facility on County property at an approximated cost
of $2.5 mil lion;
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the County of Oakland construct
a 120-bed skilled care medical facility on County property at an approximated cost
of $2,5 million,
The Buildings and Grounds Committee, by Richard R. Wilcox, Chairman, moves
the adoption of the foregoing resolution.
BUILDINGS AND GROUNDS COMMITTEE
Richard R. Wilcox, Chairman
OAKLAND COUNTY HOSPIAL PROPOSALS
SCHEDULES OF C0f.';PT,R,,\TiVE COSTS
Schedule
Total Construction Costs
(a) Cost per sq. ft. New Const, Only
(b) Cost per sq. ft. Total ConsLruction
(Inclusive Renovation)
(c) Cost per sq. ft. Total Project
Operating Costs
(a) Annual Patient Days
(b.) Average cost per patient day
(c) Annual Operating Costs in excess
of 130 bed plan for equivalent number
of patients ,(120)
71-77 Net Annual Operating Subsidy:
(a) Medical & Skilled Care Pa:ients
(b) Additional Subsidy presu min g Medicade
establishes limitations on Skilled Care
reimbursement, similar to Blue Cross
46,00 per day,
T.B. Patients
1!f Facility
Hospital Beds
80 Skilled Care
3,4 19,000
51,02
51.02
60.19
43,800
65,42
565,891 (1)
166,422 (2)
228,215 (3)
394,637
4-58,3 23
852 ,960
(2 )
New Facility
Skilled Care''
120 aeH5
2,469,000
40,82
40,82
48,69
43,800
60,88
367,044 (1)
221,921 (2)
508,360 (3)
73Bi 281.
458,323 (4)
188,6-04
(3)
.Story Addition
& Renovation
130 Beds
4,674,000
54,09
33.93
40.57
65,700
52.50
145,294
9,873
155,167
T80,175'
335,342 (c) (4)
Annual costs in excess of the 180 bed plan represent the difference in patient day cost multiplied by number
Plan 2 $8.38 X 43,800)
(2) Annual subsidy presumes that a r0.4 facility will result in additional revenue, based on 100% reimbursement of
cos t s bj Medicare, Approximately 78% of the Skilled Care patients will qualify for Medicare.
(3) Additieel subsidy necessary if Medicare establishes limits to reicr.ursement of rz...22 ,1e costs, similar to Blue
Cross (approximately $46.00 per day)
patient days (Plan 1 $12.92 X 43,800)
(14): in the New Facility P
are recoverable from
State Subsidy.
posal an average of 16 T.B. Patients would be cared for in outside 'facilities; Of these 287,
dicare. The cost of care for the balance was computed at $115,00 per day less $6,00 per day
OAKLAND COUNTY HOSPITAL PROPOSALS
COMPARISON OF NET OPERATING SUBSIDIES
Present
Operation
165 Beds
1 Story Addition
and Renovation
180 Beds
1 Story Addition
& Partial Renov.
126 Beds
New Facility
40 Bed Hospital
80 Skilled Care
New Facility
Skilled Care
120 Bed
New Annual Operating Subsidy
T. B. Patients
Other Patients
Total (Present
Reimburs. Formula)
Net Annual Operating Subsidy
with Anticipaed New Revenues
T, B. Patients
Other Patients
Total
flt Average Cost Per Patient Day
180,175
382,418
562,593
180,175
382,413
562,593
50.95
180 ,175
544:49 1
724,666
180,175
145,294
325,469 (4)
52.50
180,175
559,747
739,922
180,175
144,408
324,583 (4)
62.09
458,323 (3)
624,376
1,082,699
458,323 (3)
166,422
624,745 (4)
65,42
458,323 (3
1,008,732
1,467,c
458,323 (3
221,921
680,244 (4
60,88
(1) Plans for all facilities are adjusted for the new $22.50 per day reimbursement rate for Skilled Care Patients.
(2) if the Building Authority is used, the cost per day will be increased approximately $3.00 per Patient Day.
(3) In the New Facility Proposal, an average of 16 T.B. Patients would be cared for in outside facilities; Of these 28%
are recoverable from Medicare. The cost of care for the balance was computed at $115.00 per day less $6.00 per day
State Subsidy,
(4) Improved Facilities will result in new revenues due to the Medicare/Blue Cross Certification of the balance of the
beds presently not certified. Approximately 78% of the Skilled Care Patients will qualify for Medicare.
(5) All proposals are based on the 1973 Salary Schedule.
(6) The quality of care in all proposals is comparable to the present operation.
Revised 1/8/74
411,000
295,000
2,134,8m
93,400
90,000
168,500
2,803,275
95,000
1,974,775
95,000
3,908,200
21,712
33.93
3,192,700
25,339
N/A
2,069,775
17,248
40.82
2,898,275
24,152
51,02
25,967 30,579 28,491 20,575
40,57 N/A 60.19 48.69
4,674 cm 3,853,000
40,000
263,000
170,000
15,000
25,000
30,000
222,800
40,000
225,000
150,000
12,000
20,000
25,000
188,300
40,000
175,000
150,000
15,000
20,000
20,000
100,725
3 419 cm
40,000
125,000
120,000
12,000
15,000
17,000
70,225
2,469,000
OAKLAND COUNTY HOSPITAL
COMPARATIVE SCHEDULE OF CONSTRUCTION COSTS
1 Story Addition .
and Renovation
180 Beds
Construction Costs
1 Story Addition
& Partial Renov.
126 Beds
New Facility
40 Hospital Beds
80 Skilled Care
New Facility
Skilled Care
120 Beds
1926 Building Renovations 990,000
410,000
2,134,8m
93,400
90,000
190,000
1954 Building Renovations
New Construction
Site Work & Utilities
Other Exterior Renovations
Overhead & Profit
Construction Total
Const. Costs per Bed
Const, Costs per Sq. Ft,
Other Capital Expenses
Landscaping
Architect's Fees
Equipment & Furniture
Administrative
Construction Supervision
Start Up Expenses
Project Contingency
Project Total
Total Costs per Bed
Total Costs per Sq. Ft.
115,200 Sq, Ft. N/A 56,805 Sq. Ft. 50,710 Sq. F
(1) costs for the new 120 Bed Facility are based on the presumption that present steam heat facilities would be utilized.
0
HOSPITAL AREAS
BASIC
CART=
NURSING
SKILLED
CARE
NURSING
-0-
-0-
100 soft.
-0-
-0-
-0-
Work Area
Storage
Waiting
400 sp.ft.
600 sq.ft.
100 sa.ft.
400 so.ft. 100 so.ft.
600 so.ft. . -n-
100 sa.ft.
u
(75
Prooct- 71-28
OA M'1D COUNTY BOARD OF AUDIT 0-.S
DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES AND OPD-JIONS
FACILITIES ENGINEERING DIVISION
MEDICAL FACILITIES COMPARISON
Revised:
December 28, 1973
(.0
E
Director's Office
Asst. Director's Office
Secretarial
Conference Room
Business Office
Accountant
Switchboard/Information
TOTALS
200 sa.ft.
150 soft.
150 sn.ft.
250 sa.ft,
750 sq.ft.
125 sq.ft.
100 sn.ft.
1,725 sq.ft.
200 sa.ft.
150 sq.ft.
150 sq.ft.
250 soft.
750 so.ft.
125 soft.
100 sn.ft.
175 sq.ft.
-0-
100 sn.ft.
250 sa.ft.
500 sa.ft.
-0-
100 soft.
1,725 sa.ft. f 1,125 soft..
;
Medical Director
Staff Physicians
Consultant's Office
Medical Records
Clerical/Waiting
.Employee's Examination
150 soft.
200 so.ft.(2)
100 se.ft.
200 soft.
200 sq.ft.
100 sa.ft.
150 sg.ft.
100 sa.ft.
100 se.ft.
200 sq.ft.
200 sa.ft.
100 so.ft.
TOTALS , 950 sa.ft. 850 sp.ft. 10 0 sa.ft,
TOTALS 1,100 so.ft. 1,10n so.ft. sa.ft.
Admitting Office
Patient Services
Volunteer Room
Waiting
300 so.ft.
100 sa.ft.
100 sq.ft.
100 sq.ft.
300 sa.ft.
100 sq.ft.
100 sq.ft.
100 sq.ft.
1110 sq.ft.
-0-
-0-
-n-
TOTALS 600 soft. 600 soft. 100 sq.ft.
C") AREAS HOSPITAL
BASIC
CARE
NUPSIN0
SKILLED
CARE
NURSING
-0-
-0-
-0-
-0 -
-0-
-0-
-0-
-0-
-0-
-0-
• -...
cri
0
• rCE•
250 sa.ft.
75 sq.ft.
100 sa.ft.
75 sq.ft.
50 sq.ft.
X-Ray Room
Dark Room
.Waitina
Technician Office
Dressing/Toilet
_0_ 550 sq.ft. TOTALS
TOTALS 3,850 sq.ft.
Soiled Linen Holding
Soiled Linen Cleanup
Clean Linen Issue
-.Clean Linen . Storage
General Storage
200 so.ft.
400 sa.ft.
300 sq.ft,
400 sq.ft.
1,200 sq.ft.
Food Preparation Area
Kitchen Office
Freezer/Cooler
Storage
Receiving Area
Dishvashing
Trash Room
Staff Dining
2,000 sa.ft.
100 sq.ft,
400 sg.ft.
400 sq.ft.
100 sq.ft.
300 sq.ft.
150 sq.ft,
400 sq.ft.
1,500 sq.ft.
100 sq.ft.
400 sa.ft.
400 sa.ft. I
100 sq.ft.
300 sg.ft.
150 sg.ft.
300 sq.-ft-
200 sa.ft.
400 sq.ft.
300 sa.ft
400 sg.ft,
1,200 sg.ft.
sajt.
-0-
40-0'sft
400 sg.ft.
100 sq.ft.
300 sq.ft.
150 sa.ft.
300 sq.ft,
100 so.ft.
200 so.ft.
-0-
400 so.ft.
1,200 sg.ft.
•
3,250 sg.ft. t. .3,150 saJt.
TOTALS A 2,500 sq.ft.
I, 3
2,500 sg.ft. j 1,900 sa.ft.
("J
U
U
Vi •
• (1)
Examination
Hydro-Therapy
Gymnasium/Treatment Area
O. T. Office
O. T. Workshop
Beauty and Barber Shop
Storage
TOTALS
100 sq.ft.
350 sq.ft.
650 sg.ft.
150 sq.ft-
1,000 sa.ft.
150 sg.ft.
150 sa,ft.
100 sa.ft.
350 sq.ft.
650 sg.ft.
150 so.ft.
1,000 sa.ft.
150 sa.ft.
150 sq.ft.
-n- •
-0-
55n soft
-0- •
559 scl.ft,
150 sg.ft,
15n - so.ft.
2,550 sa.ft. 2,550 soft. 1 1,500 sa.ft.
L>,
"rr 1 AREAS I HOSPITAL I CARE CARE
1
1 i
1 I
1 1
SKILLED BASIC
CARE CARE
MHDCTM12. NURSING NURSING
1 500 sq.ft.
! 200 sq.ft.
-
Cr
°
3 '75 1
1 Laboratory
Storage
Nursing Stations
•Nedication Storage Area
Clean Linen Storage
Soiled Linen Storage
Bathing Facilities (6)
Examination Room
Dayrooms
3 0 15(L=
450 sq.ft
0)150 sq.ft
1 (3)300 . sq.ft
1(3)375 soft
1 1,200 sq.ft
i 3 100 =
1 300 sq.ft
i 3,600 sq.ft
-
a
•
•
•
("7
n
124,485 sq.ft. TOTALS
500 sq.ft
6,460 sq.ft
10,500 sq.ft
900 sq.ft, 800 sq.ft
TOTALS 700 sq.ft.
150 sq.ft.
-0-
150 sq.ft.
150 sq.ft.
-0-
150 sq.ft.
•
Director of Nursing 1 150 sq.ft.
, ,
1 Asst. Director of Nursing i 100 sq.ft.
i Classroom 200 sq.ft.
Clerical r 200 sq.ft.
to A
Single Patient Rooms (4)
Semi-Private;-Rooms (34)
Four-Bed Wards (12)
u)
150 sq.ft.
100 sq -,..ft.
150 sq.ft.
200 soft.
500 sq.ft.-
6,460 sq.ft.
I 10,500 sq.ft.
2 0 150 =
300 sq.ft.
1(2) 100 sq.ft.
1(2) 300 sq.ft.
1(2 ) 300 sq.ft.
i 1,200 soft.
3 2 0 100 =
200 sq..
i 3,600 so.ft.
24,05 0 so.ft.
150 sq.ft,
-0- •
• -0-
100 so.ft.
500.
6,450 so.ft.
10,500 SO.ft.
2 P 150 =
300 sq.ft.
1(2) 100 sq.ft.:
1(_2) 300 sq.ft.i
(z) 300 soft.
. 1,200 so.ft,
2 0 100 =
- 200 so.ft.
2,400 so.ft.i
22,510 sq.ft.1
I
0 (1.)
ro r
(7)
f..„)
!
!
•
Staff Locker Rooms
Maintenance
Lobby
5 .00 sq.ft.
400 sq.ft.
300 sq.ft.
400 sq.ft.
300 sq.ft.
200 sq,ft.
3011 sq.ft1
, , 1
3011 scl.ft.i
200 soft
, 1
TOTALS i. 1,200 sq.ft. , , , , .
MARY .
. -.HOSPITAL
A. Gross Area
-4--
1. Administrative
2. Medical
3. Pharmacy
4, Social Services
5. Radiology
6. Food Service
7. Housekeeping
8. Physical Medicine .
9. Laboratory
10. Nursing Units
11. Miscellaneous
1,725 sa.ft. X 1.4 =
950 sq.ft. X 1.4 =
1,100 sg.ft. X 1.2 =
600 sg.ft. X 1.4 -
550 sa.ft. X 1,3 =
3,850 sg.ft. X 1.2 -
2,500 sa.ft. X 1.2 =
2,550 so.ft.. X 1.3 =
700 sg.ft. X 1.2
24,485 sq.ft. X 1.5 =
1,200 soft. X 1.4 =
TOTAL GROSS AREA:
2,415 so.ft.
1,330 so..ft.
1 -,320 sa.ft.
840 so.ft.
715 sq.ft.
4,620 sq.'ft.
3,000 sa.ft.
3,315 sg.ft,
840 sa.ft..
36,730 sq.ft.
1,680 sa.ft.
56,805 sg.ft.
Cost Data
1. Administrative
2. Medical
.3. Pharmacy
4. Social. Services
5. Radiology
6. Food Service
7. Housekeeping
8. Phy cal Medicine
9. Laboratory
10. Nursina Units
11. Miscellaneous •
2,415 so.ft.
1,330 so.ft,
1,320 sg.ft.
840 soft.
715 soft.
4,620 sg.ft.
3,000 sg.ft.
3,315 sq.ft-
840 sg. L. .
36,730 sq-ft-
1,580 sa.ft.
X $45 =
X $45 -
X $40 =
X $45 =
X $100 -
X $50 =
X $35 =
X $50 =
X $70 =
X $50 =
X $45 =
108,675
59,850
52,800
37,800
71,500
231,000
105,000
165,750
58,800
1,836,500
75,600
$2,803,275
95,000
$2,898,275
TOTAL BUILDING COST:
SITE iORK ALLOVAI'TF:
TOTAL ESTIMATED CONSTRUCTION COST:
$2,898,275 = 120 Beds $24,153 Per Bed (CONSTRUCTION)
$2,898,275 -
56,805 sq .f
$51.02 Average Cost Par Snuare Foot
3,900 sa.ft.
3,000 so.ft.
3,31,5 sa.ft.
195 sa.ft.
33,685 so.ft.
1,170 sn.ft.
50,710 so.ft.
2,240 sq .ft. , 1,105 sa.ft. . 1,320 so.ft.
780 sq.ft,
SUMMARY - (Cont'd)
II. SKILLED CARE NURSING FACILITY
A. Gross Area
I. Administrative
2. Medical
3, Pharmacy
4. Social Services
5, Radiology
6. Food Service
7. Housekeeping
8. Physical Medicine
9. Laboratory
10. Nursina Units
11, Miscellaneous
1,725 so.ft.. X 1.3
850 sq.ft 'X 1.3
1,100 sq.ft, X 1.2
600 sq.ft. X 1 -3
3,250 tcl,f -L X 1.2
2,500 sq.ft. X 1.2
2,550 s'a.ft. X 1.3 =
150 sq.ft. X 1,3 =
24,060 so„ft: X 1.4 =
900 so.ft. X 1.3 -
TOTAL GROSS AREA:
B. Cost Data
1. Administrative
2. Medical
3. Pharmacy
4, Social Services
5. Radiology
6. Food Service
7, Housekeeping
8, Physical Medicine
9. Laboratory
10. Nursing Units
11, Miscellaneous
2,240 sci.ft. X $37 --
1,105 so.ft. X $37 =
1,320 sq.-ft. X =='
780 sa.ft. :t37 =
3,900 sa.ft. X $42
3,000 sa.ft. X S30
3,315 sa.ft. X $40
195 soft. X $40
33,685 sq.ft. X $4 0
1,170 SO.ft. X $35
$ 82,880
40,885
39,600
28,860
163,800
90,000
132,600
7,800
.1,347,400
40,950
$1,974,775
95,9 0.ft
$2,059,775
TOTAL BUILDING COST:
SITE WORK ALLOWANCE:
TOTAL ESTIMATED CONSTRUCTION COST:
$2,069,775
120 Beds - $17,248 Per Bed (CONSTRUCTION)
_$2,069,775
50,710 sq.ft. = $40.81 Average Cost Per Square Foot
SUMMARY - (Cont'd)
III. BASIC CARE NURSING UNIT
A. Gross Area
1. Administrative
2. Medical
3. Pharmacy
4. Social Services
5. Radiology
6. Food Service
7. Housekeeping
8. Physical Medicine
9. Laboratory
10. Nursing Units
11. Miscellaneous
1,460 sa.ft.
130 sa.ft.
130 sg.ft.
130 sa.ft.
3,780 sq.ft.
3,380 sq.ft.
1,950 sq.ft.
210 sq.ft.
31,515 se.ft.
1,040 sa.ft.
X $30 =
X $30 -
X $30 =
X $30 =
X $35 =
X $25 =
X $32 =
X $30 =
X $32 =
X $30: =
43,800
3,900
3,900
3,900
132,300
57,000
62,400
6,300
1,003,480
• .1,200
1,125 sp.ft. X 1.3
100 sq.ft. X 1,3
100 sq.ft. X 1.3
100 sg.ft. X 1,3
3,150 so.ft. X 1.2 = 3,780 sa.ft-
1,900 sq.ft. X 1,2 - 2,280 sa.ft.
1,500 sa.ft. X 1.3 = 1,950 sa.ft.
150 sq.ft- X 1.4 = 210 sa.ft.
22,510 so.ft. x 1.4 = 31,515 so.ft.
800 sq.ft. X 1.3 = 1,040 so.ft.
TOTAL GROSS AREA 42,625 so.ft.
1,460 sa.ft.
130 sa.ft,
130 so.ft.
130 so.ft.
B. Cost Data
1. Administrative.
2. Medical
3. Pharmacy
4. Social Services
5. Radiology
6, Food Service
7, Housekeepina
8. Physical Medicine
9. Laboratory
10. Nursing Units
11. Miscellaneous
TOTAL BUILDING COST: S1,353,180
SITE WORK ALLO ANCE: .40,000
$1,393,180 TOTAL ESTIMATED CONSTRUCTION COST:
1,393,180 - $11,610 Per Bed (CONSTRUCTION) 120 Beds
$.1,393,180
42,625 sg.ft, = $32.68 Average Cost Per Square Foot
-7 -
SUMMARY - (Cont'd)
IV. TOTAL PROJECT COSTS
A. Hospital
Estimated Building Cost
Site Work Allowance
Landscaping
Architect/Engineer Fees
Equipment & Furniture
Construction Supervision
Start-Up Expenses
Administrative
Contingency
$2,803,275
95,000
40,000
175,000
150,000
20,000
20,000
15,000
100,725
TOTAL ESTIMATED PROJECT COST: $3,419,000
B. Skilled Care Nursing Unit
Estimated Building Cost
Site Work Allowance
Landscaping
Architect/Engineer Fees
Equipment & Furniture
Construction Supervision
Start-Up Expenses
Administrative
Contingency
edical Care Facility)
$1,974,775
95,000
40,000
125,000
120,000
15,000
17,000
12,000
70,225
TOTAL ESTIMATED PROJECT COST: $2,469,000
C. Basic Care Nursing Unit
Estimated Building Cost
Site Work Allowance
Landscaping
Architect/Engineer Fees
Equipment & Furniture
Construction Supervision
Start-Up Expenses
Administrative
Contingency
$1,353,180
40,000
10,000
70,000
100,000
10,000
15,000
10,000
50,820
TOTAL ESTIMATED PROJECT COST: $1,659,000
Started 9-70
Cost Per Bed
(126 Beds)
Started 4-71
Cost Per Bed
(48 Beds)
$40,587.94
$21,851;16
1970
Cost Per Bed
(200 Beds)
1972
Cost Per Bed
(325 Beds)
1972
Cost Per Bed
(87 Beds) $12,000
1971
Cost Per Bed
(100 Beds) $13,500
1973
Cost Per Bed
(150 Beds) •$9,240
SUMMARY - .(Cont'd)
V. COST ..COMPARISONS
A. Hos_p_itals
1. Garden City Hospital
(Garden City, Michigan)
2. Scheurer Hospital
(Pigeon, Michigan)
B. Skilled Care Nursing Unit (Medical Care Facility)
1. Michigan Veteran's Facility Started 11-72
(Grand Rapids, Michigan) Cost Per Bed
(343 Beds) $20,606
2. Fairview Medical Care
Facility (Centreville,
Michigan)
Started 1-72
Cost Per Bed
(64 Beds) $14,090
C. Basic Care Nu .rsiho Unit
1. Southfield Medicenter
(Southfield, Michigan)
2. :Fairlane Nursing
(Detroit, Michigan)
3. Longfellow Nursing •
(Detroit, Michigan)
4. Olivet Nursing
(Detroit, Michigan)
Clinton Aire Nursing
(Clinton Twp., Michigan
$11 ,816
$1 1,8 00
#6534
Moved by Wilcox supported by Dunleevy the resolution be adopted.,
Discussion followed.
Moved by Dearborn supported by Burley the resolution be amended by
adding, after 'and' in the first paragraph, "and other medical facilities
including a 180-bed renovation of the existing hospital". In the NOW THEREFORE
BE IT RESOLVED paragraph, delete 'a 120-bed skilled care medical facility', and
insert, "the 180-bed renovation, as presented for consideration by the
Buildings and Grounds Committee at a cost of approximately $4.6 million".
Discussion followed.
The Chairman declared a recess at 11:15 A. M. for discussion of the
amendment. The Board reconvened at 11:45 A. M.
Discussion followed.
Mr. Brotherton moved the previous question. Seconded by Dr. Montante,
The Chairman stated that those in favor of calling the question, say Aye
and those opposed, say No. The vote was as follows:
AYES: Houghten, Kasper, Moffitt, Montante, Patnales, Richardson,
Brotherton, Hoot. (8)
NAYS: •Lennon, Mathews, Nowak, Olson, Perinoff, Pernick, Vogt, Walker,
Wilcox, Berman, Burley, Button, Coy, Dearborn, Dunleavy, Gabler, Hobart. (17)
A sufficient majority not having voted therefor, the motion lost.
Discussion followed.
Mr. Brotherton moved the previous question. Seconded by Dr. Montente.
A sufficient majority having voted therefor, the motion carried.
The Chairman called for a vote on the amendment. The vote was as follows:
AYES: Lennon, Mathews, Olson, Patnales, Perinoff, Pernick, Walker, Berman,
Burley, Coy, Dearborn. (11)
NAYS: Moffitt, Montante, Nowak, Richardson, Vogt, Wilcox, Brotherton,
Button, Dunleavy, Gabler, Hobart, Hoot, Houghten, Kasper. (14)
A sufficient majority not having voted therefor, the motion lost.
Discussion followed.
Vote on resolution:
AYES: Mathews, Moffitt, Montante, Olson, PatnaleS, Perinoff, Pernick,
Richardson, Welker, Wilcox, Berman, Brotherton, Burley, Button, Coy, Dearborn,
Dunleavy, Gabler, Hobart, Hoot, Houghten, Lennon. (22)
NAYS: Nowak, Vogt, Kasper. (3).
A sufficient majority having voted therefor, the resolution was adopted.
STATE OF Miri-ifGA0
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
1, Lynn IL Alien, Clerk of the County of Oakland and
having a seal, do herehy certify that i have compered the annexed copy of
Resolution #6534 adopted by the Oakland County Board of Commissioners ea a .v 9999 440444 44046,4“9499 49994595e.eaaemct"s".....w.fiv Soot stOe qpias
at their January 10, 1974 meeting
4499499440Br44.00e440f.4909944444444649494-900444 n 499999 ..w ae“peoq.eemsaa
with the original record thereof ncm rcp -ainin ,:i in my
office, and that it is a true and correct transcript
therefrom, and of the whole thereof.
In Test imony Wherof, 1 have heir-cunto set my hand and
-affixed the seal of said County at Pontiac, Michigan
lIth
thiSgoie eev w4p...449440490pdaY Of40').”(9-1TOr:Y0904949"114 74 s .,444r
Lynn D. 00.01,00ad.A"CICrk
By. flepty Clerk