HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolutions - 1989.07.20 - 17274Miscellaneous Resolution 89173 July 20, 1989
BY: PLANNING AND BUILDING COMMITTEE - Anne M. Hobart, Chairperson
IN RE: DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS - SOLID WASTE - MALCOLM PIRNIE, INC. ENGINEERING
CONTRACT FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF A MATERIAL RECOVERY FACILITY, COMPOSTING
FACILITY, HOUSEHOLD HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL PROGRAM AND INFECTIOUS WASTE
SURVEY
TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
Mr. Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen:
WHEREAS Oakland County is in the process of implementing a countywide
solid waste management program consisting of waste-to-energy facilities, recycling
centers, composting and landfills; and
WHEREAS the Oakland County Solid Waste Task Force has prepared the
Oakland County Solid Waste Management System Status Report I, which recommends the
implementation of a 400 ton per day Material Recovery Facility (MRF), a 300 ton
per day composting facility, household hazardous waste disposal program, the
performance of a survey of infectious waste disposal practices in the county and
the development of a battery collection and disposal program; and
WHEREAS Malcolm Pirnie, Inc. is a national recognized environmental
engineering firm with extensive experience in the proper disposal of waste; and
WHEREAS the engineering firm of Hubbell, Roth & Cl-rk, Ina. will be a
sub-consultant to Malcolm Pirnie, Inc. as the local Oakland County firm to assist
in the development of these Programs; and
WHEREAS this contract costs not to exceed $302,000 in 1989 and $515,000
in total is consistent with Miscellaneous Resolution #89126 - Solid Waste 1989
Professional Services Amendment,
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED the Oakland County Board of Commissioners
hereby authorizes the Chairperson of the Board of Commissioners and the Oakland
County Executive to execute a contract with Malcolm Pirnie, Inc. for the purpose
of implementing a 400 ton per day material recovery facility, furnish technical
support for the development of a composting facility, develop a household
hazardous waste program, performance of a survey of infectious waste disposal
practices in Oakland County and develop a program for the collection and disposal
of batteries as per the attached contract.
Mr. Chairperson, on behalf of the Planning and Building Committee, I
move the adoption of the foregoing resolution.
LDINO COMMITTEE
FISCAL NOTE
July 20, 1989
BY: FINANCE COMMITTEE, DR. G. WILLIAM CADDELL, CHAIRPERSON
IN RE: DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS - SOLID WASTE - MALCOLM PITNTE, INC.
ENGINEERING CONTRACT FOR IMPLEMENTATION OF A MATERIAL RECOVERY
FACILITY, COMPOSTING FACILITY, HOUSEHOLD HAZARDOUS WASTE DISPOSAL
PROGRAM AND INFECTIOUS WASTE SURVEY
TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
Mr. Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen:
Pursuant to Rule XI-G of this Board, the Finance Committee has
reviewed Miscellaneous Resolution # and finds:
1) The county is actively pursuing the _implementation of a 400 ton
per day Material Recovery Facility (MRF) and a 300 ton per day
composting facility, a household hazardous waste disposal
program, a survey of infectious waste disposal, and the
development of a battery disposal program,
2) The county has negotiated a contract from Malcolm Pirnie Inc.
Engineers, (a nationally recognized environmental engineering
firm from White Plains, New York) for engineering service as
described in Attachment A,
3) The costs for these services are estimated not to exceed $302,000
for 1989 and $515,000 for the entire contract,
4) The 1989 work scope is consistent with Miscellaneous Resolution
#89126 - Solid Waste 1989 Professional Services Amendment which
authorized the current funding level (as detailed on Attachment
A),
5) This contract has been approved as to form by Corporation
Counsel,
6) Funding for this contract is available in the Solid Waste unit
Professional Services line item (4-10100-141-15-00-3128) in the
amount of $302,000 and it is recommended that the contract be
awarded in an amount not to exceed $302,000 for 1989,
7) Funding. for 1990, in excess of $302,000, will be contingent upon
issuance of bonds.
Finance Committee
fndpwmalc
ATTACHMENT A
OAKLAND COUNTY
SOLID WASTE PROGRAM
MALCOLM PIRNTE INC. ENGINEERS
CONTRACT FISCAL ANALYSIS
FUNDING MALCOLM - PIRNIE
APPROVED FOR 1989 CONTRACT PROPOSAL
TASK BY MR #89126 1989 1990 TOTAL
Material Recovery Facility
1) Request for Qualifications $ 23402 $ 15,000 $ 15,000
2) Vendor Evaluation 19,020 20,000 20,000
3) Technical Specifications 66,789 40,000 40,000
4) Simultaneous Negotiations/other 78,089 100,000 100,000
Subtotal Material Recovery $187,000 $175,000 $ -0- $175,000
Facility
5) Compost Assistance $ 20,000 $ 20,000 $ 40,000 $ 60,000
6) Household Haz. Waste Frog. 55,000 55,000 55,000 110,000
7) Infectious Waste Investigation 50,000 40,000 10,000 50,000
8) Battery Investigation -0- 12,000 48,000 60,000
9) General Engineering -0- -0- 60,000 60,000
Total $312,000 $302,000 $213,000 $515,000
Prepared by Budget Division - DQ
7/10/89
fridpwralc
RESOLUTION # 89173 July 20, 1989
Moved by Hobart supported by Jensen the resolution be adopted.
AYES: Bishop, Caddell, Chester, Crake, Ferrens, Gosling, Hobart, Jensen,
Johnson, S. Kuhn, Law, Luxon, McConnell, McCulloch, McPherson, Moffitt, Oaks, Olsen,
Pappageorge, Pernick, Price, Rewold, Skarritt, Wolf, Aaron. (25)
NAYS: None. (0)
A sufficient majority having voted therefor, the resolution was adopted.
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
I, Lynn D. Allen, Clerk of the County of Oakland and having a seal, do
hereby certify that I have compared the annexed copy of the attached resolution,
adopted by the Oakland County Board of Commissioners at their regular meeting
held on July 20 , 1989 with the original record thereof now remaining
on file in my office, and that it is a true and correct transcript therefrom,
and of the whole thereof.
In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal
of said County at Pontiac,Michigan this 20th day of July , 198g
D. ALLEN, County Clerk
Register of Deeds
1442-01-10q5 -1-
AGREEMENT
between
OAKLAND COUNTY, MICHIGAN
and
MALCOLM PIRNIE ENGINEERS
THIS AGREEMENT, made this day of , 2989 by and between
Oakland County, Michigan (OWNER) and Malcolm Pirnie Engineers, 2 Corpo-
rate Park Drive, White Plains, New York 10602, (ENGINEER).
WHEREAS, the OWNER desires to employ, the ENGINEER to render certain
professional engineering services related to recycling.
WHEREAS, the ENGINEER is willing to provide these services for the
consideration and upon the terms hereinafter stated;
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of these premises and of the mutual
convenants herein set, forth, the parties hereto agree as follows: •
SECTION 1. BASIC SERVICES OF THE ENGINEER
1.1 It is agreed that the ENGINEER'S obligations under this
Agreement run to and are for the benefit of only the OWNER.
1.2 The scope and details of the services to be performed under
this Agreement are more fully described in Exhibit 1, Scope of Basic
Services attached hereto and made a part hereof.
1.3 An estimate of the hours and the cost for each task and for
the total contract is detailed on Exhibit 4. The accumulative fees and
reimbursable expenses will not exceed $515,000 without the prior written
approval of the OWNER. The ENGINEER will notify OWNER when such fees
and reimbursable expenses equal $412,000. At which time, if necessary,
an extension of the contract m&y 7-Ere negotiated. APP9OVEDATQFORA,1
DoparmiP,F,Corparation C,oursr,of
1442-01-1095 -2-
SECTION 2. OPTIONAL SERVICES BY ENGINEER
2.1 One or more additional services may be required in carrying
out the work, because it is not possible to determine in advance the
need for such services they are included as separate from the basic
services, as Exhibit 2. :These optional services will be undertaken only
upon written authorization by the OWNER.
SECTION 3. SERVICES BY OWNER
3.1 It is agreed that certain services shall be performed or
furnished by the OWNER. These servicesjnclude:
3.1.1 Assisting and cooperating with the ENGINEER in complet-
ing the work in a timely and effective manner;
3.1.2 Designating a representative who ., shall have authority
to transmit instructions, receive notices and information and enunciate
OWNER'S policies and decisions; the OWNER'S representative shall be Mr.
Milton W. Handorf, P.E., or his designee and/or H. Lawrence Fox of
Bishop, Cook, Purcell & Reynolds, 1400 L Street, N.W., Washington D.C.
20005-3502.
3.1.3 Arranging for and holding promptly any required meet-
ings, including the provision of meeting facilities and the serving of
all required public and private notices;
3.1.4 Providing access to and obtaining permission for the
ENGINEER to enter upon public and/or private lands as required for
ENGINEER to perform surveys, observations or other necessary functions;
3.1.5 Furnishing required approvals, permits or consent from
governmental or regulatory- bodies or others, necessary for the com-
pletion of the work;
3.1.6 Making available to the ENGINEER all of its existing
information which may in any way be pertinent to the work herein de-
scribed;
3.1.7 Responding within a reasonable time to the ENGINEER'S
requests for written decisions or determinations, pertaining to the
work, so as not to delay the services of the ENGINEER.
3.1.8 Giving prompt written notice to the ENGINEER whenever
the OWNER becomes aware of any event, occurrence, condition or
circumstance which may substantially affect the ENGINEER'S performance
of services under this Agreement;
3.1.9 Taking all municipal, corporate or other action neces-
sary to authorize, finance and carry out this Agreement and to ensure
that this Agreement constitutes a valid and binding Agreement of OWNER.
SECTION 4. TIME SCHEDULE
4.1 The ENGINEER shall commence the performance of the Basic
Services upon written authorization by OWNER which shall constitute
• Authorization to Proceed.
4.2 The ENGINEER recognizes that the Basic Services under this
Agreement are to be performed as expeditiously as is practical. Every
reasonable effort will be made to substantially complete the Basic
Services within a six month period after Authorization to Proceed.
4.3 Performance of any of the Optional Services described in
Section 2 will commence only upon separate written authorization by the
OWNER and shall be completed in accordance with a schedule set forth in
such authorization.
SECTION 5. AMOUNT AND METHOD OF PAYMENT
5.1 For services provided under Section 1, Basic Services, and
Section 2, Optional Services, payment shall be made in accordance with
Exhibit 3, Method of Payment.
SECTION 6: CHANGES
6.1 The OWNER may, at any time, by written order, make changes in
the specific tasks or work to be performed within the general scope of
this Agreement.
6.2 If such changes cause an increase or decrease in the ENGI-
NEER'S cost of, or time required for, performance of any specific tasks
under this Agreement, an equitable adjustment shall be made and this
Agreement shall be modified in writing accordingly.
1442-01-1095 -3-
6.3 At no time shall any of these changes increase the accumula-
tive fees- and reimbursable expenses limit of $515,000, without the prior
written approval of OWNER:
SECTION 7. SUSPENSION OF WORK
7.1 The OWNER may order the ENGINEER in writing to suspend, delay,
or interrupt all or any part of the ENGINEER'S services for such period
of time as the OWNER may determine to be appropriate.
7.2 If such suspension delay or interruption is longer than 30
days and causes an increase or decrease in the ENGINEER'S cost of, or
time required for, performance of any specific tasks under this Agree-
ment, an equitable adjustment shall be Made and this Agreement shall be
modified in writing accordingly.
SECTION 8. TERMINATION OF AGREEMENT
r, 1•••It••is . expressly -understood ard agrccd that the ,rM 7 R me,y
terminate this Agreement at any time by giving the ENGINEER 10 days
written notice either personally at one of the offices of the ENGINEER
or by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the principal office
of the ENGINEER_ The ENGINEER may terminate this Agreement upon 10 days
written notice if the OWNER substantially fails to, fulfill its obliga-
tions under this Agreement.
8.2 In the event that this Agreement is terminated by either the
OWNER or the ENGINEER, the ENGINEER shall be compensated for all ser-
vices performed to the date of termination including reimbursable
expenses then due. Such compensation shall be based on the arrangement
set forth in Exhibit 3, unless otherwise agreed. For those portions of
services rendered to which this arrangement cannot be applied, payments
shall be based upon reasonable rates for the ENGINEER'S actual time
spent on the work.
1442-01-1095 -4-
SECTION 9. INSURANCE
9.1 The ENGINEER represents and agrees that it is acting and shall
continue to be an independent contractor and that no liability or
benefits such as,. but not limited to, Workmen's Compensation benefits,
retirement and pension benefits, or insurance benefits, or such other
rights or liabilities arising out Of a contract of hire or employer -
employee relationship shall arise or accrue to either party as a result
of this agreement.
9.2 The ENGINEER agrees to defend, indemnify and hold the OWNER,
its officials, employees and agents harmless from any and all liability,
loss or damage which results from any-.and all claims, demands, costs,
judgements or causes of action, including reasonable attorneys fees,
arising solely from the actions or omissions of the ENGINEER, its
officers, directors, employees or agents under this agreement.
SECTION 10, GENERAL PROVISIONS
10.1 This Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be binding
upon the legal representative and successors of the parties, respective-
ly.
10.2 interpretation and enforcement of this Agreement shall be in
accordance with laws of the State of Michigan.
1442-01-1095 -5-
1442-01-1095 -6-
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the OWNER and the ENGINEER, acting herein by
. their duly authorized representatives have hereunto set their hands this
day and year first above_ written
OAKLAND COUNTY, MICHIGAN
By
Daniel T. Murphy
Oakland County Executive
By
Roy Rewold, Chairperson
Board of Commissioners
Attest:
MALCOLM PIPNIE ENGINEERS
By
Title
Attest:
EXHIBIT 1
SCOPE OF BASIC SERVICES
Task 1 - Development of Request for Qualifications (RFQ)
In order to initiate the procurement of a vendor for the Oakland
County Materials Recovery Facility (MRF), the ENGINEER shall partici-
pate in the issuance of the RFQ. Qualified firms identified through
the RFQ process would include only those with the clear ability to
participate in the MRF project.
The ENGINEER shall modify and expand the draft RFQ (dated January
13, 1989) prepared by others. .Based on a preliminary review of the
draft RFQ, the following schedules and appropriate data will be
required of prospective vendors:
1) The historical experience of vendors.
2) Description of any current or proposed joint ventures with
other recycling industries/companies.
3)• • SpetificatIons (quality) of processed material.
4) Description of methods for phasing/expanding processing
capacity of the MRF.
5) Description of process-line and equipment types.
6) Description of mechanical processing versus hand sorting..
7) Vendor recommendation on incorporating plastics into the
initial process design.
Task 2 - Review and Shortlisting of RFQ Submittals
The ENGINEER shall participate in the development of a recommended
shortlist with respect to technical and environmental issues.
Task 3 - Construction and Service Agreement
The ENGINEER shall review the draft Materials Recovery Facility
Construction and Service Agreement (dated May 26, 1989) prepared by
others and modify and expand the technical and environmental
sections as necessary. The following items will be developed, among
others:
PR9-0425-739 7-1
1) Comments and modifications to draft technical specifications
governing equipment selection and design, including conveyors,
balers, crushers, mobile equipment, containers, magnetic
separators, etc.
2) Technical review of architectural specifications governing
interior and exterior building design, appearance and.materials
selection.
3) Review and provide recommendations on operations and mainten-
ance requirements with respect to processed materials specifi-
cations, operating schedule, equipment repair and maintenance,
environmental impact (noise, odor, wastewater discharge, water
use, etc.), residue generation and handling,
materials storage, etc.
4) Review and comment upon acceptance test requirements.
5) Review and comment upon construction requirements, including
scheduling, construction techniques, use of subcontractors,
as-built drawings, etc.
6) Provide input on specifications pertaining to the marketing of
recovered materials, including the quality of processed
- • material, leQitidLe markets for -materiei, efforts to obtain
favorable pricing, and revenue sharing.
7) Provide recommendations on recordkeeping and reporting
requirements.
Task 4 - Evaluation and Negotiation of Construction and Service Agreement
The ENGINEER shall participate, as part of the County-formed
negotiating team, in simultaneous negotiations with qualified
vendors. This will most likely include:
1) Review and evaluation of technical and environmental vendor
comments and requested modifications to the County's draft
Construction and Service Agreement.
Participation in meetings with qualified vendors inorder to
negotiate agreements that can be compared with those of other
qualified vendors.
3) Calculation of cost and revenue estimates associated with
vendor modifications to the Construction and Service Agreement
for economic comparison.
4) Compilation of results of negotiations and a recommendation as
to the vendor proposal representing the lowest cost to the
OWNER.
PR9-0425-739 1-2
Task 5 - Composting Technical Support
Under this task, the ENGINEER shall provide technical support for
the development of the County Composting System. Essentially, this
task is in the nature of assisting the county staff and reviewing
materials prepared by the staff. This may include:
1) Review of existing and proposed State and Federal regulations
and guidelines with respect to compost systems.
2) Assist in development of siting criteria and candidate site(s)
analyses.
3) Assist in the analysis of the potential to process and produce
a quality compost product from lake weeds or provide
alternative disosal or usage options.
4) Develop and recommend options for recycling other vegetative
wastes such as brush, grass, and tree-trimmings.
5) Provide technical input for the 'evaluation of composting
options, including technologies, size. (regional versus local),
materials handling equipment, volumes, etc.
5) Provide technical recommendations for producing quality
compost.
7) Assist in determining an overview of local material markets.
8) Technical support to enable County staff to develop compost
facility design including site layout, equipment requirements,
drainage requirements and backup calculations.
9) Recommendations on operational scenarios.
10) Estimated capital, operation and maintenance costs for compost
facility.
Task 6 - Household Hazardous Waste - Assist in Preparation of Program and
Vendor Bidding Documents
Under this task, the ENGINEER shall:
1) Develop an estimate of the amounts of Household Hazardous Waste
(HFW) generated within the County and the number of Clean-up
Days that may be required per year.
Research potential funding sources.
PR9-0425-739 1-3
3
2
Develop a list of companies providing HHW hauling and disposal
services.
Develop bid specifications for procuring vendor; conduct
background search on history of vendor operations.
5) Provide siting criteria for an ongoing HHW Disposal Program.
6) Assist in final vendor selection in order to verify vendor
capabilities and experience.
7) Develop and provide elementary media plan for informing
residents of the services to be provided.
Task 7 - Infectious Waste - Determination of Critical Issues
Under this task, the ENGINEER shall:
1) Analyze and report on existing or anticipated State & Federal
regulations pertaining to infectious waste transport and
disposal.
Develop and distribute infectious waste survey, receive and
compile information, and develop
a) data base on estimated quantities of infectious waste
generated within the County.
b) data base on existing hospital incinerators and current
methods of handling and disposal.
3) Identify and compile currently available disposal capacities.
4) Prepare report on the results obtained from the above
sub-tasks, and on transport and disposal alternatives for
future consideration.
Task 8 - Battery Recycling
Essentially, this task involves development of a .program for
collection of batteries and preparation of cost estimates and
payment systems.
1) Analyze and present overview of the positive effects on
Resource Recovery emissions and residue quality through the
removal and recycling of various types of batteries.
2) Review and track pending State regulations governing battery
disposal; examine responsibilities of County in meeting State
Regulations.
PR9-0425-739 1-4
R9-0425-739 1-5-
3) Identify recyclability of specialty batteries (e.g.,
lead/cadmium, lighium).
4) Identify optional disposal methods and costs of alternate
disposal practices for non-recyclable batteries.
Task 9 - General Engineering
ENGINEER shall provide the OWNER with additional services necessary
to implement Materials Processing Facility, Composting Systems,
Household Hazardous Waste Program, Infectious Waste Program and
Battery Recycling Program on an as required basis, if authorized in
writing by the OWNER. Additional services may include, but not be
limited to feasibility studies, surveys, plotting, expert testimony,
public information programs, project financing assistance,
environmental assessments, etc.
1442-01-1095 2-1
, EXHIBIT 2
SCOPE OF OPTIONAL SERVICES
If authorized in writing by the OWNER, the ENGINEER shall furnish
or obtain from others Optional Services of the following types which are
not included in the basic services to be provided; these will be paid
for by the OWNER as indicated in Exhibit 3.
. Preparation and submittal of local and/or state permits, as neces-
sary.
2. Field work required to perform Basic Services, including but not
limited to investigations of:
- soils/bedrock
- wetlands
- hydrogeology
- property boundary lines
- location of utilities
3. Performance of design or construction monitoring services for the
compost, infectious waste, or materials recovery facilities.
4. Preparation and presentation of materials for public meetings and
hearings.
5. Other recycling planning and implementation services as may be
requested, such as those related to yard waste composting, infec-
tious waste collection and disposal, tire recycling, procurement of
goods made with recycled material, design of drop-off sites/
transfer stations, etc.
EXHIBIT 3
PAYMENT FOR SERVICES
PAYMENTS TO ENGINEER
Method of Payment for Services and Expenses of ENGINEER
1.1 For basic services rendered under Section 1, OWNER shall pay
ENGINEER at ENGINEER'S hourly rates.
1.2 In addition to payments provided in paragraph 1.1, OWNER shall
pay ENGINEER the amounts of reimbursable expenses as defined
- in 3.2.
1.3 The terms "hourly rates" and "reimbursable expenses" will have
. the meanings assigned to them in Section 3.2 and 3.2.
1.4 The named principal individuals assigned to this contract are
listed in Exhibit 5.
2. Times of Payments
2.1 ENGINEER shall submit monthly invoices for services rendered
and for reimbursable expenses incurred. OWNER shall make
payments within 45 days after receipt of ENGINEER'S invoices.
3. Definitions
3.1 The hourly rates for the services provided under this contract
are for 1989. On January 1, 1990, these rates may be subject
to a negotiated adjustment subject to an increase cap of 10
percent. For each following year, these rates may be subject
to negotiated adjustment in accordance with the ENGINEER'S
standard hourly rates. The OWNER'S representative for such
negotiations is Mr. Milton W. Handorf, P.E., or his designee.
1442-01-1095 3-1
1442-01-1095 3-2
Hourly Rate Schedule
Classification Hourly Rate
Grade 1 (Technician) $ 28/hour
Grade 2 (Technician) 33
Grade 3 (Technician) 38
Grade 4 (Engineer/Technician) 48
Grade 5 (Engineer/Technician) 57
Grade 6 (Project Engineer/Technician) 68
Grade 7 (Project Engineer/Technician) 79
Grade 8 (Senior Project Engineer) 94
Grade 9 (Associate) 110
Grade 10 (Senior Associate) 130
Grade 11 (Officer) 170
3.1.1. It is understood that travel time beyond the
standard eight-hour work day is non-reimbursable.
3.2 Reimbursable Exnenses - These expenses shall include_ the
following reasonable actual costs when incurred in connection
with the services rendered by the ENGINEER
3.2.1 Travel costs including transportation, lodging, sub-
sistence and incidental expenses incurred by person-
nel or consultants while in a travel status in
connection with the performance of services re-
quired. Air travel shall not exceed coach rates and
local overnight travel shall be at the the Holiday
Inn, unless unavailable, as negotiated by the OWNER.-
All other travel costs shall not exceed amounts
-approved by the OWNER. :Automobile transportation
shall be reimbursed at $0.24 per mile.
(1) Long distance telephone, telegraph, fax, and
cable expenses to be incurred in connection
with performance of services required in
connection with this agreement.
1442-01-1095 3-3
(2) Reproduction costs including blueprints, black
and white prints, solid prints, photographs,
photostats, negatives, and express charges.
(3) Commercial printing, binding, art work, and
models.
(4) Special equipment.
3.2.3 Services and expenses of special consultants pro-
vided under subcontract to the ENGINEER in the
amount billed to the ENGINEER plus 7.5 percent of
such billed amount. All subcontractors must have
the prior approval of the OWNER.
3.2.4 Premiums for special insurance coverage obtained for
the services provided, if applicable.
3.2.5 Laboratory use charges, if applicable.
3.2.6 Computer use charges, including CADD programs use,
if applicable.
3.2.7 No other costs will be charged unless approved by
the OWNER.
PR9-0425 -739 4-1
Exhibit 4
Estimated Manhours and Costs
Task Task _Estimated EStimated
Number Description Manhours Cost*($)
1989 1990 Total
1 Request for Qualifications 120 15,000 - 15,000
2 Vendor Evaluation 180 20,000 - 20,000
3 Technical Specifications .300 40,000 - _ 40,000
4 Simultaneous Negotiations , 860 100,000 - 100,000
5 Compost Assistance 550 , 20,000 40,000 60,000
6 Household Hazardous _900 55,000 55,000 110,000
Waste Program
7 infectious Waste investigation 400 40,000 10,000 50,000
8 Battery Investigation 500 12,000 48,000 60,000
9 General Engineering 450 - 60,000 60,000
, Totals 4,260 $302,000 $213,000 $515,000
* Estimated costs include estimated labor and expenses
Exhibit 5
Principal Individuals to Oakland County Contract
Specialty
Robert J. Schneider, Vice President
Naomi I, Starobin, Manager, Recycling
John R. Ettinghouse, Senior Solid Waste Administrator/
Recycling
Sydney L. Zeid, Vice President
Amit Chattopadhyay, Associate
David S. Cerrato, Associate
Stephen C. Schwarz, Vice President
Thomas J. Hickey, Vice President
Barbara A. Riley, Project Engineer
Jeffrey L. Hunts, Solid Waste Administrator
Brian M, Cunningham, Engineer
Randi F. Sachs, Senior Project Scientist
Todd G. Teryek, Solid Waste Administrator
Erik F, Reffmler, Solid Waste Administrator
ihomas A. Till, Engineering Specialist
Edward L. von Stein, Senior Project Engineer
Anthony D. Pacaro, Project Engineer
David J. Lewandowski, Engineer
Raul A. Torres, Senior Project Engineer
Gerard P. Cavaluzzi, Assistant Counsel
Judy Berkun, Associate
Lorraine R. Samuels, Marketing Support Coordinator
Peter L. Wolfe, Public Affairs Coordinator
Tina M. Camporeale, Graphic Artist
Evelyn Snitofsky, Public Relations Specialist
Lee Rudolph, Secretary
Robin Faulkner, Technical Assistant
Barbara Anderson, Administrative Assistant
Geryl L. Prescott, Supervisor Word Processing
Leslie F. Cohen, Senior Word Processor
Gale Wilson, Word Processor
Jackie Crane, Word Processor
Maria Rodriguez, Word Processor
Dorthy Menzel, Word Processor
Cathy Corrado, Word Processor
Project Officer
Project Manager
Project Leader
Michigan Engineer
Thermal Systems
Solid Waste
Technical Director
Legal
Solid Waste/Recycling
Solid Waste/Recycling
Solid Waste
Solid Waste
Solid Waste/Composting
Solid WAtP/RPryrliny
Technical
Engineering
Engineering
Engineering
Engineering
Legal
Public Relations
Public Relations
Public Relations
Public Relations
Public Relations
Administrative -
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
Administrative
PR9-0425-739 5-1