HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolutions - 2014.02.06 - 21172MISCELLANEOUS RESOLUTION # 140 11 January 22, 2014
BY: GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE, Christine Long, Chairperson
IN RE: HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES - HOMELAND SECURITY DIVISION —
PORT AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY WORLD TRADE CENTER
ARTIFACT ACCEPTANCE
TO: THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
Mr. Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen:
WHEREAS the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey have donated an official
item from the September 11, 2001, attack on the World Trade Center; and
WHEREAS the piece of steel of the former World Trade Center, identified as G-0002e
in the Port Authority's World Trade Center Archive, will be transferred to and become the
property of Oakland County; and
WHEREAS the guidelines and agreement for accepting and preserving the items will be
implemented; and
WHEREAS Corporation Council has reviewed the legal documents and accepts the
terms and conditions of the item; and
WHEREAS the Michigan Fallen Heroes Memorial has agreed to accept and display this
item along with other artifacts previously obtained relating to the September 11, 2001 attacks;
WHEREAS the Michigan Fallen Heroes Memorial will fund any costs associated with
the display and upkeep of the items.
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Oakland County Board of
Commissioners pursuant to MRfl83204 accepts the donation of a steel beam of the former
World Trade Center.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the County of Oakland will be responsible for all
costs of the removal and transportation of the 'steel' to the designated site.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that acceptance of this item does not obligate the
County to any further funding or donations from the source.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Board Chairperson is authorized to execute the
Letter of Agreement with The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, on behalf of the
County of Oakland, and hereby accepts and binds the County of Oakland to the terms and
conditions of this Agreement.
Chairperson, on behalf of the General Government Committee, I move the adoption of
the foregoing resolution.
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE
(joivt1-*‹- -1°-\AnAti
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote.
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1200 N. Telegraph Rd.
Pontiac, MI 48341-0470
Phone: (248) 858-0100
Pax: (248) 858-1572 January 22, 2014
The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
225 Park Avenue South
New York, New York 10003
The purpose of this letter is to confirm and memorialize the full and complete legal
transfer by The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (the "Port Authority")
to the County of Oakland of that certain piece of steel of the former World Trade
Center, identified as G-0002e in the Port Authority's World Trade Center Archive:
Artifact Inventory Report of January 31, 2007 (the "Steel"). The County of Oakland
has requested that the Steel be made available to them, in its present condition.
1. A property interest in the above-described Steel is hereby conveyed, and full
and complete legal ownership of the Steel is given,
2. The Port Authority makes no representation or warranty whatsoever as to
the condition or fitness of the Steel, either express or implied, and no
Commissioner, officer, agent, or employee of the Port Authority is authorized to
make any representation or warranty as to the Steel. The County of Oakland shall
have no claim against the Port Authority for any defect or other condition of the
Steel and agrees to accept the Steel "as is," There are no warranties, express or
implied.
3. To the extent permissible by applicable law, the County of Oakland agrees
to defend, indemnify and hold the Port Authority, its Commissioners, officers,
representatives and employees harmless from and against all losses, liabilities,
damages, injuries, claims, demands, costs, attorney fees, and other expenses
incurred by the Port Authority and/or its Commissioners, officers, representatives
and employees in any manner resulting from or arising with respect to the County
of Oakland's use or operation of the Steel or the possession, use or operation of
the Steel by any person under the control and authority of the County of Oakland.
4. The County of Oakland will be responsible for all costs of the removal and
transportation of the Steel to its facility.
5. This agreement may not be assigned by either party without the approval of
the other party.
6. This Agreement is subject to all the terms and conditions of either or both of
Letter to The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
Re: World Trade Center Artifact # G-0002e
January 22, 2014
Page 2
a Court Order dated December 4, 2009 or July 22, 2010, of the United States
District Court for the Southern District of New York, both annexed hereto.
7. Any written notice given by either party to the other under the provisions of,
or with respect to, this letter agreement, shall be delivered in person, or by certified
or registered mail to the following addresses:
Port Authority:
County of Oakland:
The Port Authority of NY NJ
225 Park Avenue South
New York, NY 10003
Attn.: Executive Director
The Port Authority of NY NJ
225 Park Avenue South
New York, NY 10003
Attn.: General Counsel
County of Oakland
Director, Department of Human Services
1200 North Telegraph Road
Pontiac, MI 48341
or to such other address(es) as each party hereto may notify the other.
8. To the extent permissible by applicable law, this agreement shall be
governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of New York.
9. The entire agreement of the parties is contained herein and no changes or
modifications shall be valid or enforceable unless in writing and signed by the party
to be charged therewith.
10. Neither the Commissioners of the Port Authority, nor any director, officer or
employee thereof shall be held personally liable under or in connection with this
letter agreement.
11. If any provision of this letter agreement is determined to be unlawful,
contrary to public policy, void or unenforceable, all remaining provisions shall
continue in full force and effect.
12. Each person signing this Agreement on behalf of the parties hereto warrants
and assures that s/he has been duly authorized to execute such agreements to
bind the party on whose behalf s/he executes this Agreement.
Letter to The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey
Re: World Trade Center Artifact # G-0002e
January 23, 2014
Page 3
To confirm the agreement of the Port Authority with the foregoing, kindly sign a
counterpart of this letter in the space provided below, and return such signed
counterpart to the attention of the undersigned.
Very truly yours,
The County of Oakland
By:
Michael J. Gingell
Chairperson, Oakland County Board of Commissioners
The Port Authority of New York
and New Jersey
By:
Title: Executive Director
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 F lied 12/04.010 12,91-9.,-,::,=.=ii
I
ET
DOC
DATE 12_,E3 7):
IN RE: SEPTEMBER 11 LITIGATION 21 MC 97
X
X
IN RE: SEPTEMBER 11 PROPERTY DAMAGE 21 MC 101
AND BUSINESS LOSS LITIGATION
X
X
IN RE: WTC DISASTER SITE LITIGATION 21 MC 100
X
ORDER
Upon consideration of the application of the Port Authority of New York and
New Jersey (the "Port Authority"), and an opportunity having been given to all parties in
the above-entitled action to object, it is hereby
ORDERED, that the Port Authority is permitted to transfer full and complete
legal ownership of the attached list of steel (Exhibit A) currently located at John F.
Kennedy International Airport, Hangar 17, and it is further
ORDERED, that the transfer and the recipient organization's possession of
certain WTC Artifacts will be subject to the right of any party to the September 11
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12/04/2009 Page 2 of 9
Litigations or their representatives to inspect and test any steel artifact upon ten days
notice to the recipient organization and the Port Authority.
Dated: New York ,York
/ -1," , 009
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12/04/2009 Page 3 of 9
Port Authority's WTC Artifacts
Inventory Archive Item Number
A-0004
A-0007
A-0009
A-0016
A-0017
A-0023
A-0024
A-0039
A-0041
A-0043
A-0044
B-0024
B-0025
B-0026
B-0027
B-0028
B-0030
B-0031
B-0032
B-0034
B-0038
B-0041
B-0046
B-0047
B-0048
B-0050
B-0062
C-0011.001
C-0011.002
C-0011.003
C-0011.004
C-0011.005
C-0011.006
C-0011.007
C-0013
C-0021
C-0024
C-0033
C-0034
C-0035
E-0001
E-0002
E-0003
E-0004
E-0005
E-0006
E-0007
E-0009
EXHIBIT A
Item Type
Steel Column
Structural Triad (Part)
Steel Box Beam
Tower Core Column
Tower Exterior Wall Column
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Wall Panel
Steel Beam
Steel Plate
Tower Exterior Wall Panel
Tower Exterior Wall Panel
Cladding Aluminum Panel
Cladding Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Trim
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Trim
Cladding Aluminum Trim
Cladding Aluminum Trim
Cladding Aluminum Angle
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Panel
Cladding — Aluminum Trim
Bronze Anodized Aluminum Panel
001 North Tower Antenna (Part)
002 North Tower Antenna (Part)
003 North Tower Antenna (Part)
004 North Tower Antenna (Part)
005 North Tower Antenna (Part)
006 North Tower Antenna (Part)
007 North Tower Antenna (Part)
North Tower Antenna
Elevator Motor
Elevator Motor
Flag Pole
Flag Pole
Flag Pole
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12/04/2009 Page 4 of 9
E -0010
E-0011
E-0012
E-0013
E-0014
E-0015
E-0016
E-0017
E-0018
E-0019
E-0022
E-0024
E-0025
E-0026
E-0028
E-0029
E-0030
E-0031
F-0004
F-0006.001
F-0006.003
F-0006.004
F-0008
F-0009
F-0014
F-0021.000
F-0032.014
G-0011
G-0012
G-0016
G-0020
G-0033
G-0039
G-0041
G-0048
G-0050
G-0057
G-0058
G-0059
0-0060
0-0061
0-0062
G-0063
G-0065
G-0072
G-0073
G-0074
G-0075
G-0076
G-0077
G-0079
G-0080
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Steel Column
Tower Exterior Tree Panel (Part)
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Tower Exterior Tree Panel
Steel Column
Tower Exterior Column with Spandrel
Steel Exterior Column Section
001 Composite #1: Fragment
003 Composite #1: Fragment
004 Composite #1: Fragment / Debris
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Light Pole
000 Miscellaneous Building Material
014 Metal File Cabinet (Part)
Steel Bent Plate
Steel Beam
Steel Column & Diagonal
Beam and Post Connection
Galvanized Steel Stud
Steel Tube
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Angle
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Column
Steel Column
Steel Column
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Bent Plate
Steel Angle
Sheet Metal
Built-Up Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12/04/2009 Page Sot 9
G-0081
G-0082
G-0084
G-0085
G-0088
G-0089
G-0090
G-0091
G-0092
G-0093
G-0095
G-0097
G-0098
G-0100
G-0101
G-0102
G-0113
G-0114
G-0121
G-0134
G-0141
G-0144
G-0146
G-0147
G-0158
H-0040
H-0047
H-0048
H-0049
H-0050
H-0052
H-0053
H-0054
H-0055
H-0056
H-0057
H-0058
H-0059
H-0060
H-0061
H-0062
H-0063
H-0065
H-0067
H-0068
H-0069
H-0072
H-0073
H-0074
H-0075
H-0076
H-0078
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Tube
Steel Column
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Bent Plate
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Plate
Steel Column
Steel Column
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Column
Steel Tube Post
Steel Plate
Steel Plate
Miscellaneous Steel
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Miscellaneous Steel
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Column — Tube Section
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Column
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12/0412009 Page 6 of 9
H-0079
H-0081
H-0082
H-0083
H-0084
H-0087
H-0089
H-0092
H-0093
H-0094
H-0095
H-0096
H-0097
H-0098
H-0103
H-0104
M-0106
H-0108
H-0109
H-0110
H-0111
H-0114
H-0115
H-0116
H-0117
H-0119
M-0121
H-0122
H-0124
H-0125
H-0126
H-0127
H-0129
H-0130
M-0131
H-0132
H-0133
H-0138
H-0139
H-0141
H-0142
1-1-0156
H-0162
1-0067
1-0070
1-0072
1-0073
1-0074
1-0075
1-0076
1-0077
1-0078
Steel Angle
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Double Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Tube
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12104/2009 Page 7 of 9
1-0080
1-0081
1-0082
1-0083
1-0085
1-0087
1-0088
1-0089
1-0090
1-0091
1-0092
1-0093
1-0094
1-0095
1-0096
1-0098
1-0099
1-0100
1-0101
1-0102
1-0103
1-0104
1-0105
1-0106
1-0107
1-0108
1-0109
1-0110
1-0111
1-0112
1-0113
1-0114
1-0116
1-0117
1-0118
1-0121
1-0126
1-0128
1-0132
1-0133
1-0138
1-0139
1-0142
1-0143
1-0145
1-0147
1-0149
1-0150
1-0151
1-0152
1-0153
1-0154
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Column
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Pipe
Crash Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Plate
Steel Plate
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Box Column
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Train Rail
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Plate
Steel Beam
Steel Bent Plate
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Post
Steel Column
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-TI-1K Document 1506 Filed 12/04/2009 Page 8 of 9
1-0155 Steel Beam (Part)
1-0158 Steel Beam
1-0160 Steel Beam
1-0166 Steel Column
1-0168 Steel Beam
1-0171 Steel Column
1-0175 Steel Beam
1-0176 Steel Column
J-0002 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0003 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0004 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0008 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0009 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0010 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0011 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
L-0001 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0005 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0006 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0014 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0025 Tower Exterior Wall with Symbol Cutouts
NISI Number
ASCE-3
B-1075
B-6152-1
B-6152-2
C-10
C-11
C-15
C-28
C-32
C-35
C-43
C-44
C-45
C-47 (not visbl on pc)
C-49 or S-6
C-54
C-55
C-61
C-62
C-64
C-67
C-68
C-71
C-73
C-74
C-75
C-78
Brief Description
1 column, bottom 1/3rd of left column
Wide flange
Heavy rectangular column
Heavy rectangular column
Full panel
2 columns, upper 2/3rds
Partial of single column
1 column of unknown location
1 column, upper 1/3rd
Wide flange
1 column, lower 1/2
Wide flange, FEMA reported possible core cols
Wide flange, FEMA reported possible core cols
3 columns, upper 1/2
portion of 1 column
1 column,small piece with extended outer web
1 column, lower 1/3rd
Wide flange
Wide flange
1 column with a lot missing
1 column, rest unknown
1 column, upper 1/2
Wide flange
1 column, upper 1/2
Wide flange
Portion of 1 column and spandrel, rest unknown
Wide flange
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1506 Filed 12/0412009 Page 9 of 9
C-79
C-80
C-82
C-89
C-91
C-93
0-95
C-97
C-99
C-100
C-101
C-102
C-104
C-105
C-117
0-118
C-124
C-126
C-129
C-130
C-133
C-142
C-143
C-145
C-146a
C-147
C-148
C-149
C-150
C-152
C-153
C-154
0-155
M-11
M-18
M-20
M-22
M-23
M-24
M-28
M-37
N-3
N-4
N-5
N-6
8-10 or C-17
1.1-6
n-0017
n-0033
n-022
-141
Rectangular col, FEMA rptd pos core col
Wide flange, FEMA reported possible core col
Wide flange
2 full columns
Channel
Partial of single column
Channel
Channel
Channel
Possible angle from a floor truss
Similar to corner column, but much thinner
Partial of single column
Possible angle from a floor truss
Channel
3 columns, lower 113
Channel
Channel
Wide flange
Channel
Wide Flange
1 column, bottom 1/3rd of unknown location
Wide flange
Channel
Channel
Mangled ball of steel and concrete--Composite
Channel
Channel
Piece of floor truss
Wide flange
Channel
Channel
Thin rectangular beam with supports
Wide flange
Wide flange
Large box beam, 19" x 21" x 17.6' long
2 columns, lower 1/3rd
Large box beam, 19" x 26.5" x 9.5' long
Possibly part of Wide flange or I-beam
Channel
3 columns, lower 114th
Wide flange
1 column, upper 1/2
1 column, middle 1/3rd
Part of spandrel plate with bolts
1 column, length of spandrel, crushed
2 columns, lower 1/2
3 columns, upper 114
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1509 Filed 07/2
X
IN RE: SEPTEMBER 11 LITIGATION
IN RE: SEPTEMBER 11 PROPERTY DAMAGE
AND BUSINESS LOSS LITIGATION
21 MC 97
21 MC 101
X
X
X
X
IN RE: WTC DISASTER SITE LITIGATION 21 MC 100
X
ORDER
Upon consideration of the application of the Port Authority of New York and
New Jersey (the "Port Authority"), and an opportunity having been given to all parties in
the above-entitled action to object, it is hereby
ORDERED, that the Port Authority is permitted to transfer full and complete
legal ownership of the attached list of items (Exhibit A) currently located at John F.
Kennedy International Airport, Hangar 17, and it is further
ORDERED, that the transfer and the recipient organization's possession of
certain WTC Artifacts will be subject to the right of any party to the September 11
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document 1509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 2 of 11
Litigations or their representatives to inspect and test any steel artifact upon ten days
notice to the recipient organization and the Port Authority.
Dated: New Yoilc, New York
2----2--;2010
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Documat t1A509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 3 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number Description
A-0001 Tower Exterior Wall Spandrel
A-0002 Tower Exterior Wall Spandrel
A-0003 Tower Core Column
A-0005 Steel Beam
A-0006 Steel Beam
A-0008 Tower Core Column
A-00W Tower Core Box Column
A-0011 Tower Core Column
A-0012 Tower Exterior Wall Column
A-0013 Tower Exterior Wall Column
A-0014 Tower Exterior Well Column
A-0015 Tower Exterior Wall Column
A-0025 Steel Beam
A-0026 Tower Exterior Wall Column
A-0027 Tower Exterior Wall Column
A-0028 Steel Beam
A-0029 Steel Beam
A-0030 Steel Beam
A-0031 Steel Beam
A-0032 Steel Column
A-0033 Steel Beam
A-0034 Steel Beam
A-0035 Steel Beam
A-0036 Steel Beam
A-0037 Steel Beam
A-0038 Steel Beam
A-0040 Steel Beam
A-0042 Steel Plate
A-0045 Steel Column
A-0046 Steel Column
A-0047 Steel Beam
A-0048 Steel Beam
B-0029 Cladding -- Aluminum Trim
B-0033 Cladding -- Stainless Steel Trim
B-0035 Cladding -- Aluminum Trim
B-0036 Cladding -- Aluminum Trim
8-0037 Cladding -- Aluminum Trim
B-0039 Cladding-- Aluminum Panel
B-0040 Cladding — Aluminum Tube
8-0042 Cladding -- Aluminum Tube
B.-0043 Cladding-- Aluminum Tube
B-0044 Cladding -- Aluminum Angle
B-0049 Cladding — Aluminum Panel . B-0051. Cladding -- Aluminum Panel
B-0053 Cladding -- Aluminum Trim
B-0054 Cladding -- Aluminum Panel
B-0056 Cladding — Aluminum Panel
8-0061 Bronze Anodized Aluminum Panel
B-0063 Bronze Anodized Aluminum Panel
B-0064 Bronze Anodized Aluminum Panel
B-006S Cladding -- Aluminum Panel
B-0068 Granite Coping Stone
C-0001 North Tower Antenna
C-0002 North Tower Antenna
C-0004 North Tower Antenna
C-0005 North Tower Antenna
C-0006 1North Tower Antenna
C-0008 North Tower Antenna
C-0011
C-0012
North Tower Antenna
North Tower Antenna
C-0014 North Tower Antenna
Page 1
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Documal t1A509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 4 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number Description
C-0015 North Tower Antenna ._ ,.. .
C-0016 North Tower Antenna
C-0017 ..._____..... _. North Tower Antenna
C-0018 ,North Tower Antenna
C-0020 Elevator Motor
C-0026 Elevator Motor
C-0027 Elevator Motor
C-0028 Elevator Motor
-0029 Elevator Motor
C-0030 Elevator Cab Floor Platform
C-0031 Flag Pole
C-0032 Flag Pole
C-0040 Path Signage
C-0041 Path Signage
C-0042 Path Signage
C-0043 Mall Signage
C-0044 WTC Signage
C-0045 WTC Signage
C-0046 WTC Signage
C-0047 PATH Signage
C-0048 •MC Signage
C-0049 Street Signage
C-0050 WTC Signage
C-0051 Sign age: the letter "D"
C-0052 Signage: the letter "5'
C-0053 Pre-cast Concrete Planter
C-0056 Pre-cast Concrete Bench
C-0059 Signage from WTC Concourse Level
C-0060 Signage from WTC Concourse Level
C-0061 Replacement Connections
D-0001 PATH Train Car 4745
D-0002 PATH Train Car 4143
F-0001 Reinforced Concrete Column
F-0002 Reinforced Concrete Column
F-0011 Steel Reinforcing Bar
F-0013 Pipe--10im Diameter
F-0015 Steel Figure
G-0001 Steel Ream
G-0002 Steel Box Beam (Part)
G-0003 Steel Beam
G-0004 Steel Box Beam (Part)
G-0005 Steel Train Rail
G-0006 Steel Tube
G-0007 Steel Train Rail
G-0008 Steel Plate
G-0009 Steel Plate
G-0010 Steel Column
G-0013 Steel Beam
G-0014 Steel Beam
6-0015 Steel Box Column
G-0017 Built-Up Steel Beam
G-0018 Steel Beam
G-0019 Steel Beam
G-0021
i
__ISteel
Steel Box Beam (Part)
Beam
_..
Steel Beam
G-0022
G-0023
G-0024 'Steel Beam , G-0025 Steel Tube 84Connection
G-0026 Steel Beam
G-0027 Steel Beam
G-0028 Steel Beam
Page 2
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Documa1A509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page Sot 11
Inventory Archive Item Number ,Description
6-0029 Steel Beam
6-0030 Steel Beam
6-0031 Steel Channel
6-0032 Steel Beam (Part)
6-0035 Steel Column Base Plate
6-0036 Steel Beam
16-0037 Steel Beam
G-0038 Steel Beam
6-0040 Steel Strap With Stud
6-0042 Steel Train Rail
6-0043 Steel Base Plate
G-0044 Steel Beam
6-0045 Steel Beam (Part)
6-0046 Built-Up Section
G-0049 Steel Beam
G-0053 Steel Beam
6-0054 Steel Beam -
6-0056 -I Steel Beam (Part)
G-0067 Steel Beam
6-0068 Steel Beam
6-0069 Steel Beam
G-0070 Transfer Girder
G-0078 Steel Beam
6-0083 Steel Beam
6-0086 Steel Plate
G-0086 Steel Plate
6-0087 Steel Column
6-0096 Steel Train Rail
6-0103 Steel Column
6-0104 Steel Column
6-0106 Steel Beam
6-0107 Steel Beam
6-0108 Steel Tube
6-0109 Steel Train Rail
G-0110 Steel Beam
G-0111 Steel Beam
6-0112 Steel Beam
6-0115 Steel Train Rail
6-0116 Steel Beam
6-0117 Steel Beam
6-0118 Steel Beam
6-0119 Steel Column
6-0120 Steel Box Beam (Part)
6.0121 Steel Tube Post
G-0122 Steel Plate
G70123 Steel Plate
-6-0124 --- ._ . Steel Post -- Tube & Connection
6-0125 Steel Beam (Part)
6-0126 Steel Beam
6-0127 Steel Beam
6-0128 Steel Beam
6-0130 Steel Beam
6-0131 _ Steel Beam
6-0132 Steel Column
6-0135 Steel Beam
6-0137 Steel Beam
G70138 Steel Column _
6-0139 _ Steel Beam
6-0140 Steel Plate
G-0142 Steel Channel - Stair Carriage .____
G-0145 Steel Beam
Page 3
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK DocumgpL1A509 Filed 07122/2010 Page 6 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number lpescription
G-0148 Steel Beam
G-0149 Steel Beam
G-0150 Steel Column
G-0151 Steel Beam
G-0152 Steel Beam
G-0153 Steel Beam
G-0154 Steel Column
G-0155 Steel Column
G-0156 ,Steel Beam
G-0157 1Steel Beam
Steel Beam G-0159
G-0160 Steel Strap
G-0161 Steel Beam
11-0001 Steel Column
11-0002 Steel Beam
11-0003 Steel Beam
H-0004
[
Steel Column
11-0005 Steel Beam
H-0006 Steel Beam
11-0007 Steel Column
11-0008 Steel Beam
11-0009 Steel Train Ball
H-0010 Steel Beam
I-1-0011 Steel Plate
11-0012 Steel Train Rall
11-0013 Steel Train Rail
1-1-0014 Steel Column
11-0015 Steel Beam
11-0016 Steel Tube
11-0017 Steel Beam
11-0018 Steel Box Beam. (Part)
H-0019 Steel Beam
11-0020 Steel Beam
140021 Steel Beam
H-0022 Steel Train Rail
1-1-0023 Steel Beam
11-0024 Steel Train Rail
11-0025 Steel Beam
1-1-0026 Steel Beam
11-0027 Steel Train Rail
11-0028_ Steel Beam
11-0029 Steel Beam
H-0030 Steel Column
11-0031 Steel Beam
H-0032 Steel Beam
H-0033 Steel Beam
11-0034 Steel Beam
H-0035 Steel Column
1-1-0036 Steel Beam
11-0037 Steel Beam
11-0038 Steel Beam
11-0039 Steel Beam
H-0041 Steel Beam
11-0042 Steel Beam
11-0043 Steel Beam
11-0044 Custom Steel Beam
H-0045 Steel Beam
H-0046 Steel Beam
H-0051 Steel Beam
11-0064 Steel Box Column
140066 Steel Column
Page 4
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Docur1a0 \509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 7 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number Description
H-0070 Steel Column
H-0071 Steel Column
H-0077 Steel Beam
H-0079 Steel Angle
H-0080 Steel Column
H-0086 Steel Beam
1-1-0088 Steel Column
H-0090 Steel Beam
H-0091 Steel Beam
H-0099 Steel Plate
!H-0100 _ Steel Plate
H-0101 Steel Plate
H-0105 Steel Column
H-0107 Steel Beam
1-0112 Steel Beam
H-0113 Steel Train Rail
H-0118 Steel Beam
11-0120 Steel Bent Plate
11-0123 Steel Beam
11-0128 Steel Beam
H-0134 Steel Beam
H-0135 Steel Beam
H-0136 Steel Beam
H-0137 Steel Beam
H-0140 Steel Beam
1-1-0143 Steel Column
H-0144 Steel Beam
H-0145 Steel Beam _
H-0146 Steel Column
1-1-0147 Steel Column
H-0148 Steel Beam
H-0149 Steel Beam
H-0150 Steel Beam
1-1-0151 Steel Beam
H-0152 Steel Beam
H-0153 Steel Column
11-0154 Steel Beam
H-0155 Steel Beam
H-0157 Steel Beam
H-0158 Steel Beam
11-0159 Custom Steel Beam
H-0160 Steel Beam
11-0161 Steel Box Column
1-0001 Steel Beam
1-0002 Steel Diagonal Brace
1-0003 Steel Beam
1-0004 Steel Beam
1-0005 Steel Beam
1-0006 Steel Beam
1-0007 Steel Beam
1-0008 Steel Column
1-0009 Steel Column
1-0010 Steel Column
1-0011 Steel Train Rail
Steel Column 1-0012
1-0013 Steel Column
1-0014 Steel Column
1-0015
1-0016
Steel Column
steel Column
1Steel Column 1-0017
1-0018 Steel Bent Plate
Page 5
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK Document it1A509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 8 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number Description
1-6019 Steel Beam
1-0020 Steel Column
1-0021 Steel Beam
1-0022 Steel Box Column
1-0023 Steel Box Column
1-0024 Steel Column
1-0025 Steel Column
1-0026 Steel Beam ._
1-0027 Steel Column
1-0028 Steel Beam
1-0029 Custom Steel Construction
1-0030 Steel Column
1-0031 Steel Beam ...
1-0032 Steel Beam
1-0 33 Steel Train Rail
1-0034 Steel Train Rail
1-0035 Steel Train Rai/
1-0036 Steel Beam
1-0037 Steel Beam
1-0039 Steel Beam
1-0040 Steel Column
1-0041 Steel Beam
1-0042 Steel Column
1-0043 Steel Column
1-0045 Steel Beam
1-0046 Steer Beam
-0047 Steel Train Rail
1-0048 Steel Beam
1-0049 Steel Beam
1-0050 Steel Beam
f-0051 Steel Column
1-0052 Steel Beam
1-0053 Steel Beam
1-0054 Steel Beam
1-0055 Steel Beam (Part)
1-0056 Steel Train Rail
1-0057 Steel Train Rail
1-0058 Steel Train Rail
1-0059 Steel Beam
1-0060 Steel Beam
1-0061 Steel Beam
1-0062 Steel Beam
1-0063 Steel Beam
1-0064 Steel Beam
1-0065 Steel Bent Plate
1-0066 Steel
1-0068 Steel Beam
1-0069 Steel "T"
1-0071 Steel Column
1-0079 Steel Reinforcing Bar
1-0086 Steel Beam . . . 1-0097 Steel Beam
1-0119 Steel Beam
1-0120
1-0122
1-0123 . . .
.1-0124
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
Steel Train Rail
Steel Column
1-0125 Steel Column
1-0127 Steel Bent Plate .
1-0129
1-0130
iSteel Column
IStee1Beam
Page 6
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK DocumgpA ttlA509 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 9 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number Description
1-0131 Steel Column
1-0134 Steel Beam
1-0135 .Steel Train Rail
1-0136 Steel Train Rail
1-0141 Steel Bent Plate
1-0144 Steel Beam
1-0146 Steel Ream
Hj156 Steel Beam
1-0157 Steel Column
1-0159 Steel Column
1-0161 Steel Post
1-0162 Steel Column
1-0163 Steel Column
1-0164 Steel Column
1-0165 Steel Column
1-0167 Steel Column
1-0169 Steel Beam
1-0170 Steel Beam
1-0172 Steel Column
1-0173 Steel Box Column
-0174 Steel Column
1-0177 Steel Stair Channel
1-0178 Steel Stair Channel
J-0001 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0005 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0006 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0007 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0012 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0013 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0014 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
J-0015 Tower Exterior Wall Steel
L-0002 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0003 Tower Exterior Wall with Symbol Cutouts
L-0004 Steel Beam with Symbol Cutouts
L-0007 Steel Beam (Part) with Symboi Cutouts
L-0008 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0009 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0010 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0011 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0012 Steel Beam (Part) With Symbol Cutouts
L-0015 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0016 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0017 Tower Exterior Wall Aluminum with Cutouts
L-0018 Steel Beam with Symbol Cutouts
L-0019 Steel Beam with Symbol Cutouts
L-0020 Steel Beam with Symbol Cutouts
L-0021 Steel Plate with Symbol Cutouts
L-0022 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
L-0023 Steel Beam with Symbol Cutouts
L-0024 Steel Beam with Symbol Cutouts
L-0026 Steel Beam (Part) with Symbol Cutouts
M-0001 Steel Beam
M-0002 Steel Column
M-0003 Steel Beam
M-0004 Steel Beam
M-0005
M-0006
Steel Beam
Steel Beam
M-0007 Steel Beam
M-0008 Steel Beam
M-0009 Steel Beam
M-0010 Steel Column
Page 7
Case 1:21-mc-00097-AKH-THK DocumEtApo9 Filed 07/22/2010 Page 10 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number Description
NIST-007 Column .
NIST-012 NIST Steel
NIST-013 NIST Steel
NIST-014 MST Steel
NIST-015 NIST Steel
NIST-016 NIST Steel
NIST-017 NIST Steel
NIST-018 Corner Column
NIST-023 NIST Steel
NIST-031 Wide flange
NIST-035 Channel
NIST-036 NIST Steel
NIST-037 NIST Steel
NIST-039 NIST Steel
NET-044 Channel
NI5T-052 NIST Steel
NIST-054 Long beam
NIST-055 Narrow beam with rivets
NISI-056 Small beam
NIST-058 Steel Channel
NIST-063 Box column
NIST-065 Long beam
NIST-066 Very long beam
MIST-068 Two beams
NIST-069 Long beam
NIST-072 Gnarled beams
NIST-073 Metal decking
NIST-074 NISI Steel
NIST-075 NISI Steel
NIST-076 Three columns
NIST-078 Steel
NIST-079 Steel box
NIST-080 Steel box
NIST-081 Three Columns
NIST-082 NIST Steel
NIST-083 NIST Steel
NIST-084 NIST Steel
NIST-085 Aluminum Sheathing
NIST-101 NIST Steel
NIST406 Three columns
NIST-107 Two columns
NIST-109 Steel Column
NIST-110 Three columns
NIST-111 Panel
NIST-112 Two columns
NIST-113 Two Columns
NIST-114 Column
NIST-115 Three full columns
NIST-116 _ Two Columns
NIST-117 _ Three full columns
NIST-118 Column
Washer and nut
NIST-119
NIST-120 Partial single column
NIST-121 Steel column
, NIST-123 Three Column _
NIST-124 Steel Column
NIST-125 One column
NIST-126 Two full columns
NIS1-127 Two Columns
NIST-128 lBowtie Section
NIST-129 18owtie Section
Page 8
Case 1:21-mo-00097-AKH-THK DocumObN09 Filed 07/2212010 Page 11 of 11
Inventory Archive Item Number IDescription .
NIST-130 Three Columns
N1ST-131 Two full columns
NI5T-132 Channel
N1ST-133 Thin steel
NISI-134 Thin steel
NIST-135 Wide Flange
NIST-136 Bent beam
NIST-138 Wide Flange
NIST-139 Straight beam
IST-140 Wide Flange
NI5T-141 Wide Flange
NIST-142 Column
N151-143 Partial column
NIST-144 Curved beam
NIST-145 Wide Flange
NIST-146 Corner column ---I NIST-147 Column
NMI-149 Long beam
NiST-150 Full panel
NIST-151 Wide flange
NIST-153 Two Columns
NIST-154 Column
N151-156 Wide Flange
NIST-157 Single column
NIST-159 Two columns
NI5T-161 Wide flange
NIST-162
NIST-163
Rectangular Column
One column
NIST-164 Column
NIST-165 Two columns
NIST-166 Full panel
NIST-167 Full column
NIST-168 Partial panel
NIST-169 One column
NISI-172 Small Steel
NIST-173 NIST Steel
NI51-174 NIST Steel
N1ST-175 NIST Stee
NIST-176 NIST Steel
NIS-1-177 NISTSteel
N1ST-178 NIST Steel
N1ST479 NW- Steel
NIST-180 NISI- Steel
Page 9
Resolution #14011 January 22, 2014
The Vice-Chairperson referred the resolution to the Finance Committee. There were no objections.
FISCAL NOTE (Misc. #14011) February 6,2014
BY: FINANCE COMMITTEE, TOM MIDDLETON, CHAIRPERSON
IN RE: HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES - HOMELAND SECURITY DIVISION — PORT
AUTHORITY OF NEW YORK AND NEW JERSEY WORLD TRADE CENTER ARTIFACT
ACCEPTANCE
TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen:
Pursuant to Rule XII-C of this Board, the Finance Committee has reviewed the above
named Miscellaneous Resolution and finds:
1. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey have donated an official item
from the September 11, 2001, attack on the World Trade Center.
2. The Michigan Fallen Heroes Memorial has agreed to accept and display the
piece of steel of the former World Trade Center along with other artifacts
previously obtained relating to the September 11, 2001 attacks.
3. The County of Oakland will be responsible for all costs of the removal and
transportation of the 'steel to the designated site. At this time, the cost
associated with the removal and transportation of this item is undetermined.
4. Any costs associated for this item will be the responsibility of the Fallen Heroes
Memorial Fund.
5. No budget amendments are required.
FINANCE COMMITTEE
FINANCE COMMITTEE VOTE:
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote.
Resolution #14011 February 6,2014
Moved by Spisz supported by McGillivray the resolutions (with fiscal notes attached) on the amended
Consent Agenda be adopted (with accompanying reports being accepted and appointments being
confirmed),
AYES: Dwyer, Gingell, Gosselin, Hoffman, Jackson, Long, Matis, McGillivray, Middleton,
Quarles, Runestad, Scott, Spisz, Taub, Weipert, Woodward, Zack, Bosnic, Crawford. (19)
NAYS: None. (0)
A sufficient majority having voted in favor, the resolutions (with fiscal notes attached) on the amended
Consent Agenda were adopted (with accompanying reports being accepted and appointments being
confirmed).
HEREBY APPROVE THIS RESOLUTION
CHIEF DEPUTY COUNTY EXECUTIVE
ACTING PURSUANT TO MCL 45.559A (7)
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
I, Lisa Brown, Clerk of the County of Oakland, do hereby certify that the foregoing resolution is a true and
accurate copy of a resolution adopted by the Oakland County Board of Commissioners on February 6,
2014, with the original record thereof now remaining in my office.
In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of the County of Oakland at
Pontiac, Michigan this 6th day of February 2014.