HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 2003.06.02 - 35813WILLIAM R. PATTERSON
Chairperson
PETER H. WEBSTER
Vice Chairperson
DAVID COULTER
Minority Vice Chairperson
June 2, 2003
Chairperson Patterson called the meeting of the General Government Committee t o
order at 2:01 p.m. in Committee Room A, Commissioners’ Wing, County Service
Center, Pontiac, Michigan.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
William R. Patterson, Peter Webster, Bill Bullard, Martin Knollenberg, Jeff Potter,
John Scott, David Coulter, Eileen Kowall and Mattie McKinney Hatchett
COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT WITH NOTICE:
None
OTHERS PRESENT
CLERK - REGISTER OF DEEDS William G. Caddell, Clerk/Register
OLHSA Ron Borngesser, CEO
EXECUTIVE OFFICE Doug Williams, Deputy County Executive
Bob Daddow, Asst. Deputy County Executive
Kristie Everett Zamora, Arts, Culture & Film
Carmen Talbot, South Oakland Liaison Special
Projects
CORPORATION COUNSEL Judy Cunningham, Director
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Phil Bertolini, Director
Mike Wilk, Deputy Director
David Veit, Manager
Kevin Bertram, Chief – Tech. Operations
Harshika Patel, Chief – Tech. Services
Joseph Tabor, Tech. Operations Supervisor
Norma Miller, Program Manager
MANAGEMENT & BUDGET Art Holdsworth, Deputy Director
HUMAN SERVICES Thomas J. Gordon, Ph.D., Director
DTE ENERGY Carla Gribbs, Regional Manager
Michael Palchesko, Regional Manager
EXECUTIVE OFFICE Lynn Alexander, Senior Citizen Advocate
CITIZEN Dr. Steffan Taub, Retired Physician
THE OAKLAND PRESS Charles Crumm, Reporter
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Tom McMillin, Commissioner, District #11
OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1200 N. TELEGRAPH ROAD, PONTIAC, MI 48341-0470
Telephone (248) 858-0100 FAX (248) 858 -1572
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE
Bill Bullard
Martin Knollenberg
Eileen Kowall
Jeff Potter
John Scott
Mattie McKinney Hatchett
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE Page 2
June 2, 2003
Hugh D. Crawford, Commissioner, District #9
Eric Coleman, Commissioner, District #23
Harvey Wedell, Analyst
Pamela Worthington, Committee Coordinator
PUBLIC COMMENT
Ms. Zamora mentioned that she is sponsoring a workshop on the Michigan Council for Arts
and Cultural Affairs (MCACA) Minigrant Program on Tuesday, June 10, 2003, from 10:00
a.m. until 11:30 a.m. at the Orion Art Center, 115 South Anderson Street, Lake Orion. She
handed out a copy of the Press Release that is available on the Oakland County web site in
regards to this workshop.
She also handed out an invitation card for the Treasures Lost: The Baghdad Museum
Brown Bag Lecture which will take place on June 19, 2003, from noon – 1:00 p.m. at the
Oakland University. The speaker will be Dr. Susan Wood, who has been very active in the
study of art history. She will be giving a presentation on the current situation involving
ancient artifacts stolen from the Baghdad Museum. She invited all commissioners to attend
both of these events.
Mr. Caddell informed the committee that the Governor signed the Presidential Primary
Cancellation Senate Bill #397, so it’s official that there will be no presidential primary in
2004.
Ms. Alexander mentioned that some Oakland County Senior Directories are available at the
Board Office, and a larger directory will be produced in the near future.
Chairperson Patterson reminded the commissioners that if they have not yet appointed a
representative from their district to the Senior Advisory Council, they should do so soon.
APPROVAL OF THE PREVIOUS MINUTES
Scott moved to amend the minutes of May 12, 2003 to reflect under Other Business
that a CMH Application Study Group was created by Ch airperson Patterson, and
David Coulter, Marty Knollenberg and John Scott were appointed to this study
group. Supported by Coulter.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
Coulter moved approval of the minutes of May 12, 2003, as amended. Supported
by Scott.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
AGENDA ITEMS
1. DTE ENERGY – INFORMATION REGARDING APRIL ICE STORM (POSTPONED
FROM MAY 12TH
Ms. Carla Gribbs and Michael Palchesko, Regional Managers of DTE Energy, were present
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE Page 3
June 2, 2003
to inform the committee about the April 2003 Ice Storm and the challenges that the
employees had in getting power restored to the almost 403,000 customers affected. They
handed out a sheet with some facts about the ice storm, which hit southeastern Michigan
on April 3, 2003 and lasted for six days. There was not only freezing rain, but it turned into
ice on the lines and trees, and on top of that there was snow, wind and near freezing
temperatures. As a result, there were 100 circuit lockouts; almost 3,500 primary wire-down
locations; over 11,000 service trouble cases; over 625,000 feet of wire was replaced; over
40 poles were replaced; over 1,700 cross arms were replaced; and almost 200 distribution
transformers replaced. In response, Detroit Edison had almost 6,500 workers out in the
communities working on getting power restored to its customers. They were getting 100
calls a day for five weeks after the storm. The normal amount of calls a day is ten. Ms.
Gribbs mentioned that they prioritize power outages. Priority #1 is safety of the public, as
well as their employees. Priority #2 is human services (i.e. hospitals, police and fire
dispatch and communications, sewer, water and pump stations. Priority #3 is the largest
number of customers impacted by each repair.
They handed out several photographs that showed the thickness of ice on trees and power
lines, along with areas that were broken on the poles. There were also circumstances
where the workers had repaired a line, got in their truck to leave, and a tree branch had
broken, fell on the line that had just been repaired, and it caused the workers to repair it
again. This was the worst ice storm in 25 years. It took 15 days back then to restore power
to all its’ customers, and it took 6 days this past April to restore power to 95% of th e
customers who had lost power during this storm. Linemen from the States of Ohio,
Kentucky and Missouri had come to Michigan to help in the power restoration effort. Tree
trimmers from other states also had helped. Approximately 250,000 of those 403,000
customers without power were in northern Oakland County. Mr. Palchesko mentioned that
DTE Energy would be upgrading their 1-800 system to a voice-activated system. The
current system does not have enough prompts necessary for every situation.
2. DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY – THIN CLIENT COMPUTING
PROPOSAL
The resolution approves the implementation of the Thin Client Computing Phase 1. Mr.
Bertolini and Mr. Veit gave a presentation on the possibility of converting current personal
computers (PCs) within the Oakland County offices into what are called Thin Client
Computers. Thin Client computers are without hard drives, and they would link up to
servers at the Information Technology Department. When upgrades in software would be
necessary, they would be installed on the main servers, as opposed to physically going to
each PC site and installing software on each PC. There are currently 3,600 PCs in the
Oakland County network today. The age of these PCs vary from one to six years old.
Some of these PCs do not have enough memory to upgrade, for instance, to Windows XP;
therefore, they would need to be upgraded in hardware before a new operating system,
such as Windows XP, could be installed. Industry experts estimate the costs would be well
over $9,000 per year to maintain a networked PC, and it would save 35% to 57% of that
cost to convert to a Thin Client environment. Another advantage of converting to Thin
Client is security reasons, better protection against viruses and hackers. The primary goal
of Phase 1 is to establish the baseline configuration and deployment strategy of the Thin
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE Page 4
June 2, 2003
Client environment. Approximately 280 PCs will be converted to Thin Clients in Phase 1.
Costs of Phase 1 are estimated at $517,428, estimating total net savings to Oakland
County of $3,317.
Bullard moved approval of the attached suggested resolution. Supported by Potter.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote.
3. MR #03121 – BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS – OAKLAND COUNTY
COMMISSIONER PARTICIPATION ON REGIONAL AND NATIONAL BOARDS
The resolution approves the establishment of a policy authorizing the payment of
registration and travel expenses, in accordance with the County’s established travel
guidelines, for Oakland County Commissioners who are appointed to serve on regional,
state or national boards, committees and/ or subcommittees.
Coulter moved approval of the attached suggested resolution.
Motion failed due to lack of support.
4. BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS – APPOINTMENT TO COMMUNITY MENTAL
HEALTH BOARD
This is a report to the Board of Commissioners recommending the appointment of Dr.
Steffan Taub to the Community Mental Health Services Board to fill the General Public
vacancy. The CMH Application Study Group met and reviewed all applications, and this
recommendation came out of their review.
Scott moved approval of the attached suggested resolution. Supported by Kowall.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote.
5. BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS – APPOINTMENT TO THE PUBLIC SERVICES
COMMITTEE
This is a report to the Board of Commissioners recommending the appointments of Sue
Ann Douglas and Christine Long to the Public Services Committee, filling the vacancies left
by the resignations of Lawrence A. Obrecht and David L. Moffitt. Upon approval of these
appointments, Sue Ann Douglas will discontinue her appointment on the Planning &
Building Committee, and Christine Long will discontinue her appointment on the Personnel
Committee.
Webster moved approval of the attached suggested resolution. Supported by
Knollenberg.
Motion carried on a roll call vote with Hatchett voting no.
COMMUNICATIONS
A. May 14, 2003 – County of Antrim Board of Commissioners Resolution Opposing
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE Page 5
June 2, 2003
Passage of SB244
B. May 12, 2003 – Family Independence Agency Board Meeting Notice and Agend a
C. February 18, 2003 – Family Independence Agency Meeting Minutes
D. April 17, 2003 – Airport Committee Meeting Minutes
E. May 19, 2003 – Memo from Bill Patterson to Tom Law – Appointment of Study Group
F. Oakland County Community Mental Health Authority 2002 Annual Report
G. May, 2003 Area Agency on Aging 1-B Newsletter – Home-Based Long Term Care
Potter moved to receive and file the communications. Supported by Kowall.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
OTHER BUSINESS/ADJOURNMENT
Mr. Webster mentioned a May 21, 2003 letter that was addressed to the Clerk’s Office from
David E. Wresinski, Administrator of the Project Planning Division at the State of Michigan
Department of Transportation. This letter was in response to the Oakland County
Commissioners’ MR #03101, which urged the Michigan Department of Transportation to
reinstate funding for the highway and road improvement projects that are important to the
continued growth and safety of Oakland County residents and the residents of Southeast
Michigan. Mr. Webster felt the letter was an inefficient response, and that the Board of
Commissioners may want to respond to this letter. Mr. Williams stated that Mr. L. Brooks
Patterson is communicating with Governor Granholm on this issue. Mr. Williams will keep
Mr. Webster informed on the status of this issue.
Mr. Potter mentioned that on Saturday, June 7, 2003, 10:00 a.m. there would be a grand
opening of the Huron Valley Trail System at the Lyon Oaks Park, just west of Milford Road.
This trail system connects the cities of Wixom, South Lyon, Highland Lake Recreation Park
and the Huron/Clinton Authority. He invited everyone to attend.
There being no other business to come before the committee, the meeting was adjourned
at 4:40 p.m.
________________________ _______________________________
Pamela Worthington James H. VanLeuven, Jr.
GENERAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE Page 6
June 2, 2003
Committee Coordinator Administrative Director
NOTE: The foregoing minutes are subject to Committee approval.