HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 2004.02.26 - 35881CHUCK MOSS
Chairperson
BILL BULLARD
Vice Chairperson
VINCENT GREGORY
Minority Vice Chairperson
February 26, 2004
Chairperson Moss called the meeting of the Finance Committee to order
at 9:00 a.m., in the Board of Commissioners' Committee Room A, Commissioners' Wing, County
Service Center, Pontiac, Michigan.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT :
Chuck Moss, Bill Bullard, Vincent Gregory, Hugh Crawfo rd, Peter Webster, Greg Jamian, Martin
Knollenberg, George Suarez, Helaine Zack.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT WITH NOTICE:
Charles Palmer, Christine Long.
OTHERS PRESENT :
AVIATION Karl Randall, Manager
CLERK/REGISTER OF DEEDS William Caddell, Clerk/Register
CORPORATION COUNSEL Judy Cunningham, Corporation Counsel
DISTRICT COURT 52-3 Julie Nicholson, Chief Judge
Lynda Hammerstein, Administrator
EMERGENCY RESPONSE Mike Sturm, Administrator
Gail Novak, Chief
Brandon Lewis, Technic al Assistant
EQUALIZATION Rick Vincent, Administrator
EXECUTIVE OFFICE Doug Williams, Deputy Executive
Robert Daddow, Assistant Deputy Executive
FACILITIES MANAGEMENT Mike Hughson, Property Management Specialist
FISCAL SERVICES Tim Soave, Manager
Nancy Fournier, Chief
LaVerne Smith, Supervisor
Joe Matkosky, Supervisor
Linda Pearson, Analyst
Prentiss Malone, Analyst
Michael Pohlod, Analyst
HUMAN RESOURCES Ed Poisson, Director
Nancy Scarlet, Manager
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Phil Bertolini, Director
Scott Oppmann, GIS Chief
Tammi Shephard, GIS Support Specialist
MANAGEMENT & BUDGET Laurie Van Pelt, Director
Art Holdsworth, Deputy Director
PARKS & RECREATION Mike Donnellon, Architect/Engineer
OTHERS PRESENT CONTINUED
OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1200 N. TELEGRAPH ROAD, PONTIAC, MI 48341-0470
Telephone (248) 858 -0100 FAX (248) 858-1572
FINANCE COMMITTEE
Charles Palmer
Hugh D. Crawford
Peter Webster
Greg Jamian
Martin J. Knollenberg
Christine Long
George Suarez
Helaine Zack
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 2
February 26, 2004
SHERIFF Dale Cunningham, Business Manager
Captain Damon Shields
Kent Gardner, Crime Lab Supervisor
TREASURER Keith Sawdon, Chief Deputy
VETERANS' SERVICES Diana Calvin, Manager
Garth Wootten, Supervisor
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Harvey Wedell, Analyst
Helen Hanger, Sr. Committee Coordinator
APPROVAL OF THE PREVIOUS MINUTES
Crawford moved approval of the minutes of January 29, 2004, as printed. Supported by
Zack.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
PUBLIC COMMENT
Mr. Soave reviewed the Governor's proposed budget message, which includes a suspension of
revenue sharing for counties and moving the collection of county tax levies permanently from
December 1 to July 1 beginning this year. Mr. Soave explained the problems that this action would
cause for both counties and taxpayers. The administration will be meeting with state legislators on
the issue.
5. CONTINGENCY REPORT
The FY 04 Contingency Fund balance will not be impacted by item s on today's agenda. The
previously adopted Medical Examiner's Fees are anticipated to increase the Contingency Fund by
$55,250 to $152,842.
Royal Oak Township is current on payments for its Law Enforcement Contract.
Suarez moved to receive and file the Contingency Report dated February 25 2004.
Supported by Crawford.
Motion to receive and file carried on a voice vote.
CONSENT AGENDA
6a. MR #04032 - DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES MANAGEMENT - REQUEST FOR
APPROVAL OF CONSTRUCTION LICENSE AND LEASE AGREEMENT WITH THE TOWNSHIP
OF GROVELAND FOR THE NEW COUNTYWIDE RADIO SYSTEM
Facilities Management is requesting authorization to enter into a construction license and lease
agreement with Groveland Township to construct a tower, equipment shelter and install a ge nerator
for the countywide radio system at 4695 Grange Hall Road, Holly, Michigan. The County will sell
the tower to Groveland Township for $1 upon completion and Groveland Township will lease the
County space on the tower for $1 per year. The initial te rm of the lease is 15 years with three
renewable five-year terms. Construction and lease costs will be covered by the 4% emergency
telephone operational charge levy authorized by MR #99279, pursuant to MCL 484.1401.
6b. MR #04033 - DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES MANAGEMENT - REQUEST FOR
APPROVAL OF CONSTRUCTION LICENSE AND LEASE AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 3
February 26, 2004
TOWNSHIP OF WHITE LAKE FOR THE NEW COUNTYWIDE RADIO SYSTEM
Facilities Management is requesting authorization to enter into a construction license and lease
agreement with White Lake Township to construct a tower, equipment shelter and install a
generator for the county -wide radio system at 7525 Highland Road, White Lake, Michigan. The
County will sell the tower to White Lake Township for $1 upon completion a nd White Lake Township
will lease the County space on the tower for $1 per year. The initial term of the lease is 15 years
with three renewable five -year terms. Construction and lease costs will be covered by the 4%
emergency telephone operational charge levy authorized by MR #99279, pursuant to MCL
484.1401.
7. MR #04043 - ENVIRONMENTAL INFRASTRUCTURE FUND REIMBURSEMENT FOR
PROJECT IN THE VILLAGE OF MILFORD - FISCAL YEAR 2003 ALLOCATION
The Village of Milford is requesting authorization for its $22,64 9.48 FY 2003 Environmental
Infrastructure Fund Reimbursement for expenses relating to the Old Plank Road Landfill Remedial
Investigation.
Suarez moved to recommend approval of Consent Agenda Fiscal Notes 6a - 7. Supported
by Crawford.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
8. MR #04036 - 52ND DISTRICT COURT/DIVISION III, ROCHESTER - CREATION OF
ADDITIONAL STAFF IN THE PROBATION UNIT
The 52-3 District Court is requesting authorization to create three new positions w ithin its Probation
Unit to address the increased caseload. Two full -time eligible (FTE) Probation Office I positions and
one FTE District Court Clerk I position will be created. It is anticipated that position costs of
$83,227 for the remainder of FY 04 and $154,564 for FY 05 will be covered by increased revenue of
$150,000 per year. A reduction in the Training & Psychological & Medical Exam line item for both
fiscal years is anticipated to cover the remaining balance, including associated operating co sts.
Mr. Webster asked what the criterion was per probation officer for caseload.
Judge Nicholson explained that the Court has experienced an 11% increase in caseload in the last
two years. Probation Officers can handle about 250 cases each. Caseload h as increased from 288
in 1992 to 520 for 2003. Creation of these positions will allow for more offenders to be given
probation and for more reports to be written by staff rather than contractors.
Mr. Webster asked for written information on caseload.
Suarez moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Knollenberg.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
9. RESOLUTION TO INITIATE ACTION TO REDEEM ALL OF THE OUTSTANDING
CALLABLE COUNTY OF OAKLAND, MICHIGAN, OAKLAND COUNTY CHARTER TOWNSHIP
OF WATERFORD WATER AND SEWER BONDS PRIOR TO MATURITY
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 4
February 26, 2004
The Treasurer is requesting authorization to redeem all of the outstanding callable bonds previously
authorized by the Board of Commissioners to finance the acquisition and construction of the Charter
Township of Waterford Water and Sewer Bonds to service the Township, as identified within the
resolution.
Webster moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Resolution. Supported
by Zack.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
10. MR #04037 - SHERIFF'S OFFICE - USE OF FORFEITED FUNDS FOR EQUIPMENT
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to use $152,000 from the Sheriff's Forfeited Fund balanc e of
$949,976.20 (as of 12 -31-03) to purchase equipment, including bulletproof vests, long and short -
range rifles and a vacuum fuming chamber) to enhance law enforcement efforts in compliance with
state law.
Suarez moved to recommend approval of the attac hed suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Gregory.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
11. SHERIFF'S OFFICE - CY 2004 AND CY 2005 AUTOMOBILE THEFT PREVENTION
AUTHORITY GRANT ACCEPTANCE
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to accept Automobile Theft Prevention Authority grant
awards for 2004 and 2005. An award of $431,193 has been granted for the period January 1, 2004
through December 31, 2004, that includes $297,956 to the County, $73,013 to Waterford Townshi p
and $60,170 to Pontiac. Required matches for the 2004 program include $99,318 from the County,
$24,337 from Waterford Township and $20,057 from Pontiac, for a program total of $574,851.
The 2005 award of $432,722 includes $295,796 to the County, $75,36 6 to the Waterford Police
Department and $61,560 to the Pontiac Police Department. Required matches include $98,598
form the County, $25,122 from Waterford PD and $20,520 from Pontiac PD, for a program total of
$576,962.
The program also includes the Mad ison Heights and Hazel Park police departments who are
requesting their own funding.
Mr. Cunningham introduced Kent Gardner who is supervising the Crime Lab. Commissioners will
be invited to an open house for the new lab some time in March.
Suarez moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Knollenberg.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
12. PARKS AND RECREATION - SUPPORT FOR SUBMISSION OF GRANT APPLICATION
TO THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES TO ACQUIRE ADDITIONAL
ACREAGE FOR EXPANSION OF ADDISON OAKS COUNTY PARK
The Oakland County Parks and Recreation Commission is requesting support for submitting an
application to the Michigan Department of Natural Resources Trust Fund for a grant to purchase
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 5
February 26, 2004
346.5 acres of land to expand Addison Oaks County Park. The total cost of this property acquisition
is $4,280,000. The MDNR Trust Fund will provide $1,712,000 and the Parks and Recreation
Capital Improvement Fund will s upply the required 60% match of $2,568,000. This resolution of
support is required as part of the application process.
Crawford moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Gregory.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
13. PARKS AND RECREATION - SUPPORT FOR SUBMISSION OF GRANT APPLICATION
TO THE MICHIGAN DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES AND LAND AND WATER
CONSERVATION FUND TO PROVIDE A CONNECTOR TRAIL AT INDEPENDENCE OAKS
COUNTY PARK
The Oakland County Parks and Recreation Commission is requesting support for submitting
application to both the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) Trust Fund and the
MDNR Water Conservation Fund for a grant to provide a connector trail a t Independence Oaks
County Park. The total project cost is $365,000. The Trust Fund application will be for $219,000,
with the Parks and Recreation Capital Improvement Fund supplying the remaining 40% match of
$146,000. The Land and Water Conservation F und application will be for $182,500, with the Parks
and Recreation Capital Improvement Fund supplying the remaining 50% match of $182,500. This
resolution of support is required as part of the application process.
Gregory moved to recommend approval of t he attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Crawford.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
14. DEPARTMENT OF CENTRAL SERVICES - OAKLAND/SOUTHWEST AIRPORT - 2004
GRANT PROGRAM ACCEPTANCE - WETLAND DELINEATION
The Department of Central Services - Oakland/Southwest Airport is requesting authorization to
accept a Michigan Department of Transportation Grant Contract for Federal funds of $4,491 and
State funds of $249 to be used for a wetland delineation project. The required 5% match of $250
will be provided by the Airport Fund.
Webster moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Knollenberg.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote.
15. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SERVICES/VETERANS' SERVICES DIVISION - PUBLIC ACT
290 OF 2003 AMENDING PUBLIC ACT 235 OF 1911
The Department of Management and Budget reports that the currently budgeted $200,000 line item
for Soldier's Burial will be sufficient to handle the estimated $6,000 cost increase resulting from the
passage of Public Act 290 of 2003. The new law increases the estate limitation for the $300 County
Burial Allowance and Marker Installation Allowance, for deceased veterans with dependents, from
$25,000 to $40,000. Pub lic Act 290 allows for a Board of Commissioners to adopt a resolution to
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 6
February 26, 2004
opt out of the increased estate limitation if desired.
Suarez moved to receive the written report from Management and Budget and the Veteran
Services Division. Supported by Crawford.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
16. COUNTY EXECUTIVE - EMERGENCY RESPONSE AND PREPAREDNESS -
APPLICATION/ACCEPTANCE FOR FY 2002 SUPPLEMENTAL ASSISTANCE PROGRAM FOR
CITIZEN CORPS/COMMUNITY EMERGENCY RESPONSE PROGRAMS (CERT)
Emergency Response and Prepa redness has applied for and is requesting authorization to accept
grant reimbursement from the State of Michigan, under the U.S. Department of Homeland Security
for 2002 Supplemental Assistance Grant Program, for qualified expenses not to exceed $37,169 f or
the period of December 16, 2002 through May 11, 2004. These funds will be used to establish
Citizen Corps Councils, to support council oversight and outreach functions and to expand
Community Emergency Response Team training to develop the Corps.
Mr. Sturm explained that these funds are used to train volunteers, such as retired nurses, and
pharmacists, in disaster relief efforts relating to biological events. These particular funds will be
used to expand the ham radio program.
Webster moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Zack.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
17. COUNTY EXECUTIVE - EMERGENCY RESPONSE AND PREPAREDNESS -
APPLICATION/ACCEPTANCE FOR FY 2003 ODP STATE HOMELAND SECURITY GRANT
PROGRAM, PART II, TRAINING GRANT AGREEMENT
Emergency Response and Preparedness has applied for and is requesting authorization to accept
grant reimbursement from the State of Michigan, under the U.S. Department of Homeland Securi ty
Office for Domestic Preparedness, State Homeland Security Grant Program, Part II Training Grant
Program, for qualified expenses not to exceed $960,810.79 for the period of March 1, 2004 through
February 28, 2005. These funds will be used for first resp onder training exercises and for first
responders to attend the 2004 Michigan Homeland Security Training Conference.
Knollenberg moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note.
Supported by Zack.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
18. DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT & BUDGET/EQUALIZATION AUTHORIZING THE
EQUALIZATION DIVISION AND DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY TO ENTER
INTO A SOLE SOURCE CONTRACT WITH BS&A SOFTWARE
The Equalization Division is requesting authorization to appropriate the Division's previously
designated CRIMP (Cost Reduction Incentive Management Program) funds of $89,388 to
implement BS&A assessment and taxation software for use by the County and its subscribing local
cities, villages and townships. The resolution will also authorize negotiation of this sole source
contract by Information Technology and Management and Budget. The County's current mainframe
tax and assessment system has become financially impractical. Over the l ast five years, almost
25% of the parcel count in Oakland County have migrated from the county's assessment systems to
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 7
February 26, 2004
this software, including Farmington Hills, Rochester Hills, Troy and Southfield. BS&A Software is
the leading provider of these systems in the State of Michigan and Oakland County.
Mr. Webster asked whether the long -term implications in providing this program to the local units
would realize more or less services and how this program relates to the County's thin client
initiative.
Mr. Vincent indicated that services should be similar or better. This software is state -certified and is
the only product that has kept up with changes in property tax laws since Proposal A was
implemented.
Mr. Oppmann explained that this software is a desk top program based on Information Technology
servers and is, therefore, compatible with the Thin Client initiative.
Suarez moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested resolution. Supported by
Webster.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Palmer and Long absent.
19. DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET - FISCAL YEAR 2004 FIRST
QUARTER FINANCIAL FORECAST AND BUDGET AMENDMENT
This resolution and supporting material was distributed to committee members for review prior to
consideration at the next meeting.
Suarez moved to receive and file Management and Budget's Fiscal Year 2004 First Quarter
Report. Supported by Webster.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
20. DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET - FY 2005 AND FY 2006 REVENUE
ESTIMATES
Two versions of revenue assumptions were provided to the committee. Version A assumes the
Governor's budget proposal does not pass but the reduction of $3 million in state revenue sharing
continues each year, as the County has currently budgeted. Management and Budget is
forecasting that preliminary revenue estimates will remain flat for the next several years.
Management and Budget also reported that the House Tax Policy Committee has passed out
legislation to exempt the first $10,000 of person al property tax for each taxpayer. In the first year
Oakland County would lose $1.4 million, with a loss to the local units and the state of $16 million.
Version B incorporates the Governor's Proposal regarding revenue sharing. This includes
collection of the December 2004 tax levy in July, placing $223 million in reserve and leaving $116
million for general fund operations. This would leave the County with a 6 -month operating shortfall
of $100 million.
Mr. Webster asked that Management and Budget but together a one or two -page document for the
commissioners to use in discussion with legislators on how the Governor's proposal would impact
the County's budget.
Mr. Crawford asked that this document be provided to the local units to explain to them how th is
proposal will impact both their communities and the County.
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 8
February 26, 2004
Mr. Caddell reported that the Governor's proposal also includes the addition of a $5 surcharge on
vital records, of which the entire amount would be sent to the state.
21. DISCUSSION OF ENVIRONMENTAL INFRASTRUCTURE FUND
Mr. Williams explained the operations of the Delinquent Tax Revolving Fund (DTRF). The corpus of
the DTRF is held at $200 million in accordance with Board resolution. Interest derived from the
corpus of the DTRF is used for long -term capital projects. Operating transfers Out are done by
resolution. This includes Environmental Infrastructure Fund (EIF) appropriations to local units, for
which $25 million of the DTRF corpus was used.
Mr. Bullard asked if commissioners could get a list of programs that would include dollar amounts,
to show what the County provides to the local units.
Mr. Bertolini explained how several of Information Technology's projects benefit the local units. He
distributed a spreadsheet showing what IT pro grams are being used by each community.
COMMUNICATIONS
A. Department of Information Technology - CLEMIS Project - Negotiated Agreement with CrisNet -
COPS MORE Grant #1999CLWX0239
C. Community and Economic Development Division - PY 2004 Consolidated Grant A pplication for
Community Development Block Grant, HOME Investment Partnership Grant and Emergency
Shelter Grant
D. Oakland County Parks and Recreation (OCPR) - FY 2004 On Stage Arts Mini -Grant Oakland
County Cultural Council/Michigan Council for Arts and Cultural Affairs - Application
E. County Executive - Emergency Response and Preparedness - Hazard Mitigation Grant
Program Planning Application
Crawford moved to receive and file the communications A, C, D, E. Supported by Gregory.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
B. Department of Management/Purchasing Division - Contract Exception Report for the Month of
January, 2004
Mr. Webster asked if this contract would impact the JIMS project.
Ms. Van Pelt indicated this was a separate program and that a re view would need to be
conducted to determine how or if the Jury Management System would impact the JIMS
system.
Suarez moved to receive and file the communication B. Supported by Knollenberg.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
OTHER BUSINESS/ADJOURNMENT
There being no other business to come before the committee, the meeting was adjourned at 10:45 a.m.
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 9
February 26, 2004
________________________ _______________________________
Helen Hanger Nancy Wenzel
Senior Committee Coordinator Committee Coordinator
NOTE: The foregoing minutes are subject to Committee approval.