HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 2004.04.08 - 35895CHUCK MOSS
Chairperson
BILL BULLARD
Vice Chairperson
VINCENT GREGORY
Minority Vice Chairperson
April 8, 2004
Chairperson Moss called the meeting of the Finance Committee to order
at 9:00 a.m., in the Board of Commissioners' Committee Room A, Commissioners' Wing, County
Service Center, Pontiac, Michigan.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT :
Chuck Moss, Vincent Gregory, Charles Palmer, Hugh Crawford , Peter Webster, Christine Long,
George Suarez.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT WITH NOTICE:
Bill Bullard, Greg Jamian, Helaine Zack
COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT:
Martin Knollenberg
OTHERS PRESENT :
CIRCUIT COURT Kevin Oeffner, Administrator
COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS Barb Hankey, Manager
CORPORATION COUNSEL Judy Cunningham, Corporation Counsel
Jody Schaffer, Assistant Counsel
DRAIN COMMISSIONER Joe Colaianne, Insurance Administrator
Leo Lease, Accountant
EXECUTIVE OFFICE Doug Williams, Deputy Ex ecutive
Robert Daddow, Assistant Deputy Executive
FACILITIES MANAGEMENT Mike Hughson, Property Management Specialist
FISCAL SERVICES Tim Soave, Manager
Nancy Fournier, Chief
LaVerne Smith, Supervisor
Joe Matkosky, Supervisor
Holly Conforti, Supervisor
Michael Pohlod, Analyst
HUMAN RESOURCES Ed Poisson, Director
Nancy Scarlet, Manager
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Colleen Prosyniuk, User Support Specialist
LeAnne Robinson, User Support Specialist
MANAGEMENT & BU DGET Laurie Van Pelt, Director
Art Holdsworth, Deputy Director
PARKS AND RECREATION Ralph Richard, Executive Officer
PURCHASING Joe Hylla, Manager
SHERIFF Michael McCabe, Undersheriff
Dale Cunningham, Business Manager
OTHERS PRESENT CONTINUED
OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1200 N. TELEGRAPH ROAD, PONTIAC, MI 48341-0470
Telephone (248) 858 -0100 FAX (248) 858-1572
FINANCE COMMITTEE
Charles Palmer
Hugh D. Crawford
Peter Webster
Greg Jamian
Martin J. Knollenberg
Christine Long
George Suarez
Helaine Zack
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 2
April 8, 2004
ROAD COMMISSION FOR OAKLAND Brent Bair, Manager
COUNTY Richard Skarritt, Commissioner
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS David Moffitt, Vice Chairman
Tom Middleton, District #4
Eileen Kowall, District #6
Harvey Wedell, Analyst
Sheryl Mitchell, Analyst
Helen Hanger, Sr. Committee Coordinator
APPROVAL OF THE PREVIOUS MINUTES
Crawford moved approval of the minutes of March 25, 2004, as printed. Supported by
Suarez.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
PUBLIC COMMENT
Corporation Counsel Judy Cunningham explained that the County has filed a lawsuit in federal court
against Affiliate Computer Systems for breach of contract, misrepresentation and a claim against
the performance bond regarding the Judicial Information Manageme nt System contract.
Commissioner Long asked for a moment of silence in memory of Walled Lake Northern High School
student Ryan Anderson.
5. CONTINGENCY REPORT
The FY 04 Contingency Fund balance of $152,842 will be reduced $58,264 by item 6 and $68,16 9
by item 7. The ERP - 2003 ODP State Homeland Security Exercise Grant for $17,000 previously
placed into the Contingency Fund per MR 03356 will be removed, leaving a balance of $9,409.
Undersheriff McCabe reported on the status of the Sheriff's Law En forcement Contract with Royal
Oak Township. The $13,000 arrearage is a result of several contract payments not having been
made at 2004 rates. The total arrearage of $101,239.02 is due April 30, 2004. Contract language
involving the Michigan State Polic e has been sent to the State for signature.
Long moved to receive and file the revised Contingency Report dated April 7, 2004.
Supported by Palmer.
Motion to receive and file carried on a voice vote.
6. MR #04090 - VISITING JUDGE APPROPRIATION AND CRE ATION OF COURT CLERK
POSITION
Circuit Court is requesting authorization to appropriate funding for one visiting judge and to create
one general fund/general purpose Court Clerk to assist in the processing of case backlog to ensure
that cases are settled, tried or otherwise concluded in accordance with time guidelines for civil case
processing. In August of 2003, the State Court Administrative Office reported on the judicial needs
of Michigan trial courts and determined that Oakland County has a need of ne arly three judgeships
for its Circuit and Probate Courts. Totals costs, including associated operational expenses, are
$58,264 for FY 04 and $137,716 for FY 05 and will be funded by the General Fund Non -
Departmental Contingency. The Circuit Court has impl emented changes to enhance the use of
alternative sentencing practices to expedite criminal cases and to avert jail overcrowding
emergencies and continues to review its practices regarding the handling of family cases that could
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 3
April 8, 2004
result in residential placement of children at taxpayer expense.
Mr. Oeffner reported that Court Rules confer authority to the Chief Circuit Court Judge in
assignment of visiting judges. A list of eligibility will be provided by the State Court Administrator's
Office. The Court is required to pay the difference between the salary of a sitting judge and the
retirement rate of visiting judge.
Suarez moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Palmer.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with B ullard, Jamian, Knollenberg and Zack
absent.
7. MR #04042 - BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS - ADDITION OF TWO (2) DEPUTY I
POSITIONS TO THE SHERIFF'S TRANSPORT UNIT TO PROVIDE PRISONER TRANSPORT TO
THE WATERFORD TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT AND THE ADDITION OF ONE (1)
TRANSPORT VAN TO THE COUNTY FLEET
This resolution was introduced by Commissioners Kowall, Scott and Middleton to provide two
Deputy I positions in the Sheriff's Satellite Services Division, Transport Unit, to provide transport of
offenders to and from the Waterford Township Police Department for 51 st District Court
appearances. One transport van with radios will also be needed. Total operating and capital costs
for FY 04 are $68,169 and $123,054 for FY 05. Funding will be provided by the General Fun d Non-
Departmental Contingency.
Undersheriff McCabe explained that these two deputies would not be restricted to this particular
function but would augment the transport responsibilities of the unit as a whole. Expansion of the
Video Arraignment System to the courts, implementation of teleMed and pending legislation may
result in a reduced number of transports.
Palmer moved to report with the recommendation that the resolution title be amended to read as
follows.
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS - ADDITION OF TWO (2) DEPUTY I POSITIONS TO AUGMENT
THE SHERIFF'S TRANSPORT UNIT AND TO PROVIDE PRISONER TRANSPORT TO THE
WATERFORD TOWNSHIP POLICE DEPARTMENT AND THE ADDITION OF ONE (1)
TRANSPORT VAN TO THE COUNTY FLEET.
Supported by Gregory.
Motion to report to amend carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian,
Knollenberg and Zack absent.
Palmer moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Gregory.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knol lenberg and Zack
absent.
8. MR #04055 - DRAIN COMMISSIONER - RESOLUTION TO APPROVE PROJECT COSTS,
ASSESSMENT ROLL AND ISSUANCE OF BONDS FOR WATKINS LAKE
The Drain Commissioner is requesting approval of project costs, the assessment roll and the
issuance of bonds, in an amount not to exceed $520,000, for the construction of a new
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 4
April 8, 2004
augmentation well and drain outlet for Watkins Lake in Waterford Township. MR #02324
acknowledged receipt of the petition to establish a winter level through determination of the Circuit
Court and to construct the augmentation well.
This resolution was brought before the Finance Committee on March 11, 2004, and was
recommended for approval. This item was removed from the March 18, 2004, Board of
Commissioners' agenda to correct the assessment roll in follow up to the public hearing. The Fiscal
Note did not change.
Palmer moved to report in concurrence with the Planning and Building Committee's action. Supported by Long.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
9. MR #04056 - DRAIN COMMISSIONER - WATKINS LAKE AUGMENTATION WELL
PROJECT - FULL FAITH AND CREDIT RESOLUTION
The Drain Commissioner is requesting that the Board of Commissioners pledge the f ull faith and
credit of the County for payment of the principal and interest on the Bonds called Watkins Lake
Level Bonds, Series 2004 for the Watkins Lake Augmentation Well Project, in an amount not to
exceed $520,000.
This resolution was brought before the Finance Committee on March 11, 2004, and was
recommended for approval. This item was removed from the March 18, 2004, Board of
Commissioners' agenda in conjunction with item #8 (above). The Fiscal Note did not change.
Webster moved to report in concurrence with the Planning and Building Committee's action.
Supported by Long.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
10. MR #04089 - DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES MANAGEMENT - REQUES T TO CONVEY
GIDDINGS ROAD RIGHT OF WAY TO THE CITY OF AUBURN HILLS PART OF PARCEL NO.
14-03-100-028
Facilities Management is requesting authorization to convey via quit claim deed the east 60 -feet of
parcel 14 -03-100-028 to the City of Auburn Hills, for road right of way purposes, for the sum of one
dollar. The property will be used for road right of way purposes, with installation of underground
electrical conduit by Detroit Edison. The County Animal Shelter and Trusty Camp are both located
on this parcel.
Mr. Palmer explained that the Board of Commissioner's Procedures for the Sale, Purchase and
Leasing of property details the steps necessary for the sale of property. The local unit, adjacent
property owners and public agencies are provided with the first opportunity to make an offer.
Palmer moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Long.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
11. MR #04087 - DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES MANAGEMENT - APPROVAL AND
ACCEPTANCE OF LEASE WITH OPTION TO PURCHASE AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF
SOUTHFIELD, PART OF THE SOUTHFIELD HEALTH CENTER PROPERTY, PART OF PARCEL
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 5
April 8, 2004
NOS. 24-13-426-001 AND 24-13-404-13
Facilities Management is requesting a pproval of a lease with option to purchase agreement with the
City of Southfield for 22 acres of Health Center property, located at 27725 Greenfield Road, parcel
nos. 24-13-426-001 and 24-13-404-13. Since 1978, the County has leased 25 -acres of this
property to the City for recreation purposes (Catalpa Park). The City is requesting that the current
lease for 25-acres be extended and that negotiations for the purchase of 22 -acres of the property
commence. The lease will continue until May 5, 2005 for the s um on one dollar per year, during
which time the City will have the option to purchase the property. If the option to purchase is
exercised, proceeds from the sale will be receipted in the Building Improvement Fund.
Mr. Webster asked if the County would be maintaining enough open space for the County's
Southfield Health facility for emergency response purposes.
Mr. Hughson indicated that he had talked to Mike Sturm, the County's ERP Administrator, who
informed him that this property is not on the list fo r that particular use.
Ms. Van Pelt reported that the County's grants writer is working with Dave Ross to find parks money
for Southfield to purchase the property.
Gregory moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Palmer.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
12. MR #04088 - DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES MANAGEMENT - APPROVAL AND
ACCEPTANCE OF LICENSE AGREEMENT WITH SPRINT SPECTRUM, LP FOR
CONSTRUCT ION OF RADIO TOWER AND SUPPORT FACILITIES AT ADDISON OAKS
COUNTY PARK, PART OF PARCEL NO. 05 -33-100-004
Facilities Management is requesting approval of a License Agreement to allow Sprint Spectrum, LP
to construct, own, operate and maintain a 190 -foot radio tower and related support facilities at
Addison Oaks County Park, for an initial term of five years with the option for three renewable five -
year terms. Spectrum will pay the County a $5,000 non -refundable legal and administration fee
upon execution of the agreement and an annual license fee of $21,600 for the initial term of the
lease, at an increased rate of 15% at each five -year renewal. Sprint shall also pay the County 30%
of any co-location revenue generated, subject to a 15% increase at each five -year renewal of the
license. The Oakland County Parks and Recreation Commission has negotiated and approved the
terms and conditions of the license agreement. All fees will be receipted to Parks and Recreation.
Ms. Schaffer explained that Sprint origi nally offered a 15% share to the County of co -location
revenue.
Mr. Crawford explained that the Parks and Recreation Commission sent back this initial 15% offer
for further negotiations after reviewing other community contracts.
Palmer moved to recomme nd approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Crawford.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
13. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SERVICES/COMMUNITY CORRECTIONS DIVISION - FY
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 6
April 8, 2004
2003/2004 DRUNK DRIVER JAIL REDUCTION AND COMMUNITY TREATMENT PROGRAM
GRANT AMENDMENT
Community Corrections has been awarded amended grant funding of $570,038 from the State of
Michigan for the period February 1, 2004, through September 30, 2004, for the Drunk Driver Jail
Reduction and Community Treatment Program. This funding will be used to enhance previously
awarded Community Corrections funding of $3,616,669, to support eighteen Community Specialist
II, one Community Corrections Specialist I, one Of fice Assistant II, one Community Corrections
User Support Assistant II and one Community Corrections Specialist III. These additional funds will
be used to enhance treatment and supervision services for OUIL 3 rd offenders. It is anticipated that
the Sheriff's Office, General Fund Budget, will increase as a result of assessment fee revenue
charged to this grant. Once information becomes available regarding the number of assessments, a
budget adjustment will be made with the Third Quarter Financial Forecast.
Ms. Hankey explained that assessments would be reimbursed at $45.00 in keeping with what many
district courts charge. The fee must be competitive and must be agreed to by the State. Roughly
$12,000 has been budgeted for this program in keeping with pre vious history. The Sheriff will
provide an invoice for this service which will be sent to the State for reimbursement. Once
reimbursement is received, it will be placed in the Sheriff's line item and will be charged against the
grant.
Crawford moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Suarez.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
14. MR #04085 - DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - INTERLOCAL
AGREEMENT BETWEEN OAKLAND COUNTY AND THE CITY OF SOUTH LYON FOR THE
FIRE RECORDS MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
Information Technology is requesting approval of an Interlocal Agreement with the City of South Lyon to
join the County's Fire Records Management System (FRMS). The City will be charged a $3,500 start -
up fee and $3,500 annual department fee. The acquisition of one HP printer for the City at a cost of
$1,484 will be offset by FRMS entry fees of $4,667 for the remaining four months in FY 2004.
Long moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by
Crawford.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
15. MR #04068 - ROAD COMMISSION FOR OAKLAND COUNTY - APPROPRIATION OF
ONE-TIME FUNDING FOR COUNTY ROAD PROJECTS
Commissioners Law, Moffitt and Moss introduced this resolution to appropriate one -time funding of
$400,000 for FY 2004 to be used for construction, maintenance and repair of highways. Funding will
be released upon the Board of Commissioners' General Government Committee's approval of a
specific use plan. This assistance would allow the Road Commission to redirect some of its current
year's budget for equipment and facility replacement costs not covered by insurance as a result of
the recent fire at its Springfield Township facility.
Mr. Skarritt thanked the committee and assured them these funds would only be used as the
resolution directed.
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 7
April 8, 2004
Webster moved to recommend approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported
by Suarez.
Motion to report carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Bullard, Jamian, Knollenberg
and Zack absent.
COMMUNICATIONS
A. Department of Management/Purchasing Division - Contract Exception Report for the Month of
March, 2004 (dated March 30, 2004)
B. Prosecuting Attorney - FY 2005 Victims of Crime Act (VOCA) Grant Application
C. Department of Information Technology - 44th District Court Security Project
D. Department of Information Technology - Status of Jail Diversion - Substance Abuse / Mentally Ill
Grant Application
Suarez moved to receive and file communications A -D. Supported by Gregory.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
Mr. Daddow provided updated information on item D to the committee in a memo dated April 5,
2004, which includes revised dollar figures. A grant application is being finalized for submission
to the Office of Drug Control Policy to fund a program that would target that portion of the jail
population with substance abuse/mental health problems f or which there is currently no services
available. The other aspect of this program will be to provide housing for this population
through reopening of the L Building. This facility was closed in 2003 in order to expand the work
release facility, etc., to mitigate jail overcrowding. Community Corrections will be requesting
additional Probation Residential Center dollars from the State. Jail overcrowding is expected to
occur again even with implementation of this program. The chief judges are trying to enc ourage
the use of alternative sentencing. The Data Warehousing Program identifies offenders that
could be alternatively sentenced. This information will be discussed with the courts. Funding of
$65,000 to implement technology to track recidivism has been set aside in the General Fund
designated equity.
Palmer moved to receive and file Mr. Daddow's memo dated April 5, 2004. Supported by Webster.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
OTHER BUSINESS/ADJOURNMENT
There being no other business to come bef ore the committee, the meeting was adjourned at 10:32 a.m.
________________________ _______________________________
Helen Hanger Nancy Wenzel
Senior Committee Coordinator Committee Coordinator
NOTE: The foregoing minutes are subject to Committee approval.