HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 2008.06.04 - 36271
OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1200 NORTH TELEGRAPH ROAD PONTIAC, MICHIGAN 48341-0470
Telephone: (248) 858-0100 FAX: (248) 858-1572
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
June 4, 2008
The meeting was called to order by Chairperson Middleton at 9:34 a.m. in Committee Room A,
Auditorium Wing, County Service Center, Pontiac, Michigan.
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT:
Tom Middleton, Bradford Jacobsen, Sue Ann Douglas, Mike Rogers, John A. Scott, Robert
Gosselin, Helaine Zack, Mattie Hatchett and Karen Spector
PERSONNEL COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT WITH NOTICE:
George Suarez and Eric Coleman
OTHERS PRESENT:
Human Resources Nancy Scarlet, Director
Cathy Shallal, Manager
Jennifer Mason, Manager
Heather Mason, Analyst
Kelly Siddiqui, Analyst
Lori Motyka, Supervisor
Dana Cosby, Analyst
Joyce Harbison, Analyst
Jordie Kramer, Analyst
Karen Jones, Supervisor
Judy Fandale, Supervisor
County Executive Jerry Poisson, Deputy County Executive
Sheriff’s Office Mike McCabe, Under Sheriff
Dale Cunningham, CFO
Ann Russell, Corrections Administrator
Circuit Court Kevin Oeffner, Court Administrator
Management & Budget Laurie VanPelt, Director
Fiscal Services Tim Soave, Manager
Auditing Terri A Meiers, Supervisor
Pamela Weipert, Manager
Board of Commissioners Larry Doyle, Administrative Director
Sheryl Mitchell, Senior Analyst
Harvey Wedell, Senior Analyst
Nancy Wenzel, Committee Coordinator
Tom Middleton
Chairperson
Brad Jacobsen
Majority Vice-Chair
George Suarez
Minority Vice-Chair
Sue Ann Douglas
Mike Rogers
John A. Scott
Robert Gosselin
Eric Coleman
Helaine Zack
Mattie Hatchett
Karen Spector
Personnel Committee Page 2
June 4, 2008
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Chairperson Middleton led the Committee in the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance.
The Committee took a moment to reflect on the health of Commissioner Suarez.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES OF MAY 14, 2008
Gosselin moved to approve the minutes of May 14, 2008 as printed. Supported by
Scott.
Motion carried on a voice.
PUBLIC COMMENT
None
MR #08105 BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS – SET COMMISSIONERS’ ANNUAL COMPENSATION
FOR 2009 AND 2010
Due to current economic conditions in Michigan several Commissioners feel that as leaders they
should lead by example and reduce Commissioners’ compensation by 3.9% from 2008 levels to a
rate for 2009 and 2010 of $32,500 to demonstrate a serious approach to helping resolve the
economic issues facing the County.
Gosselin moved the Personnel Committee Report to the Board with the recommendation
MR #08105 be adopted. Supported by Jacobsen.
Motion failed on a roll call vote:
Middleton, Douglas, Rogers, Zack, Hatchett and Spector – no
Jacobsen, Scott and Gosselin – yes
Suarez and Coleman – absent
MR # 08102 DRAIN COMMISSIONER – DOWNWARD RECLASSIFICATION AND TRANSFER OF
TWO (2) POSITIONS
The demand for the design and construction of new storm drains, sanitary sewers, water mains,
wastewater treatment facilities and lake level control structures has diminished due to the lack of
new construction projects. To increase efficiency while lowering costs, the Drain Commissioner
requests to downwardly reclassify two vacant (SR) Construction Inspection II positions to the
classification of Maintenance Mechanic II transferring these posi tions to the Operations and
Maintenance Division. This will result in a savings of approximately $418 to the Special Revenue
fund on an annual basis.
Gosselin moved the Personnel Committee Report to the Board with the recommendation
MR #08102 be adopted. Supported by Jacobsen.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Suarez and Coleman absent
Personnel Committee Page 3
June 4, 2008
MR # 08103 DRAIN COMMISSIONER – DELETION OF ONE CONSTRUCTION INSPECTOR II
POSITION
In reaction to the difficult economic times facing Oakland County a hiring freeze has been
imposed and an Estimated Budget Reduction Task has been established for Fiscal Year 2008-2010.
The Drain Commissioner proposes to delete one vacant GF/GP Construction Inspector II position
from the Engineering and Construction/Soil Erosion Unit. The duties assigned to this position will
be redistributed to other divisional employees. This will result in an annual savings of
approximately $58,038 to be applied to the FY 09-10 budget tasks and a savings for the remainder
of FY 08 of approximately $22,807.
Gosselin moved the Personnel Committee Report to the Board with the recommendation
MR #08103 be adopted. Supported by Hatchett.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Suarez and Coleman absent
MERIT SYSTEM
A replacement for page 2 (blue copy) was distributed by Human Resources adding a BE IT
FURTHER RESOLVED paragraph instructing Corporation Counsel to draft proposed ballot
language.
The Oakland County Board of Supervisors established a merit system for the County’s employees
on a trial basis with the adoption of MR #4551 on April 12, 1966. On September 19, 1966 MR
#4606 was adopted establishing a merit system. Since the establishment of the Oakland County
Merit System the County has experienced considerable changes including moving from a Board
of Supervisors form of government to a County Executive, updates and changes in employment
laws and advancements in technology. These changes and other legal and technol ogical
advancements make it necessary to modify the Merit System Resolution. In order to modify the
Merit System the changes must be approved by a majority of electors, therefore it is requested
Corporation Counsel draft proposed ballot language for these changes, to be reviewed by the
Personnel Committee and approved by the Board of Commissioners and placed on the November
2008 election ballot for approval. The major change to the Merit System involves the Personnel
Appeal Board, changing the number of members to six, to establish two hearing panels that will
be conducted by three members each in an effort to clear up the backlog of appeals. In addition
Section VI, K, 2, a, b & c establishes the “Recusal/Disqualification of Personnel Appeal Board
Member”.
Scott moved approval of the attached suggested resolution. Supported by Spector.
Hatchett moved to amend the resolution under Section VI, K, second paragraph, “The Appeal
Board shall be made up of six members; two members selected by the County’s e mployees in
the same manner in which employee members of the Oakland County Employees’ Retirement
Commission are elected; two members, one from the majority party and one from the
minority party, of the Board of Commissioners, appointed by the Chairperson of the Board of
Commissioners with the approval of the Board of Commissioners….” Supported by Zack.
Motion to amend failed on a roll call vote:
Middleton, Jacobsen, Douglas, Rogers, Scott, and Gosselin – no
Zack, Hatchett and Spector – yes
Suarez and Coleman – absent
Main motion carried on a roll call vote:
Middleton, Jacobsen, Douglas, Rogers, Scott and Gosselin – yes
Zack, Hatchett and Spector – no
Suarez and Coleman - absent
Personnel Committee Page 4
June 4, 2008
MERIT RULE 15 – HOURS OF WORK, MERIT RULE 2 – SALARIES – AUTHORIZATION FOR 4/40
PILOT WORK HOUR PROGRAMS
Oakland County Merit Rules 2 and 15 authorize the County Executive and Board of
Commissioners to adopt alternative work schedules where prudent. The County Executive is
requesting authorization to establish pilot programs implementing a 4/40 work week throughout
the departments and divisions reporting to him and in other county work force areas to enhance
customer services and help diminish the affects of soaring gasoline prices and employee
commuting costs.
Scott moved approval of the attached suggested resolution. Supported by Douglas.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Suarez and Coleman absent.
MR #08097 DEPARTMENT OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET – REORGANIZATION AND
POSITIONS DELETIONS TO MEET FISCAL YEAR 2008-2010 BUDGET TASK
In order to meet a portion of its share of the County Executive’s budget task, the Department of
Management and Budget proposes a reorganization to merge the Reimbursement Division into
the Fiscal Services Division, which includes the deletion of three positions, reclassification of
seven positions and the creation of one full-tie non-eligible position. The results of this proposal
will generate $106,096 in savings for Fiscal Year 2008 and $459,749 savings in Fiscal Years 2009
and 2010.
Gosselin moved the Personnel Committee Report to the Board with the recommendation MR
#08097 be adopted. Supported by Scott.
Gosselin moved MR #08097 be amended as follows:
To the paragraph which starts NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED change the text to: NOW
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Oakland County Board of Commissioners approves the
reorganization of the Department of Management and Budget, effective June 21, 2008, except
Section 3. effective 12/31/08, as follows:
- To Section 2. “The following positions are deleted,” add the following:
d. User Support Specialist II (position #102061501939)
- To Section 3. “The following classifications are deleted,” add:
h. Payroll Coordinator
- To Section 5. “The following positions are reclassified with no change in salary grade
level,” change the Payroll Supervisor title to Supervisor – Payroll in item 5.f.
- To the next paragraph which starts BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED the text would be modified to
read:
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that one (1) full-time non-eligible (FTNE) Account Clerk I
position be created in the new Reimbursement unit of the Fiscal Services Division and one (1) full -
time non-eligible (FTNE) Accountant I position be created in the Central Fiscal Services unit of the
Fiscal Services Division.
Supported by Scott.
Motion to amend carried on a voice vote.
Main motion as amended carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Suarez and Coleman
absent
Personnel Committee Page 5
June 4, 2008
HUMAN RESOURCES DEPARTMENT – EXTENSION OF MERIT SYSTEM ELIGIBILITY LISTS
Under the provisions of Section VI-H-1, of Merit System Resolution #4606 regarding the
extension of Merit System eligible lists the Human Resources Department is requesting the
extension of 12 lists.
Zack moved approval of the extension of the 12 requested lists. Supported by Rogers.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Suarez and Coleman absent.
COMMUNICATIONS
Scott moved to Receive & File Communication Items A – H.
A. Position Change Summary Report
B. Vacancy Report
C. Gretchen’s House @ Little Oaks – 1st Quarter, 2008 Report
D. Human Resources Department – Retirement Incentive Update
E. Circuit Court FY 2009 Michigan Drug Court Grant Program (Adult Treatment Court)
Application
F. Sheriff’s Office – 2008 Jail Alliance with Supports (JAWS) – Grant Application
G. Sheriff’s Office – FY 2009 Oakland County Narcotic Enforcement Team (NET) Grant
Application
H. Salary Administration Second Quarterly Report for FY 2008 Memo
Supported by Hatchett.
Nancy Scarlet commented on Item C – Gretchen’s House @ Little Oaks – 1st Quarter, 2008
Report. The Gretchen’s House contract expires on June 30th it is Human Resources intention to
renew the contract for another two years. An audit was perform ed; the majority of issues are
in compliance, however, the auditors made a couple of recommendations regarding
maintenance issues and cost of advertising and publications for the Little Oaks facility only . In
2006 there was an under statement of revenue by Gretchen’s House because they changed
their reporting form, the money coming back to the County was less that it should have been
by $19,000. Gretchen’s House will pay the County $19,000.
Item D – Retirement Incentive Update. 153 applications for reti rement have been received as of
today, 28 are within the 7 day period where they can still elect to revoke their application. The
original goal was 150.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
Personnel Committee Budget hearings have been scheduled for August 13th and 27th
immediately following the regularly scheduled Committee meeting.
Human Resources put out a bid request for Medicare A & B, the law requires health care be bid
out every three years. Etna has been chosen as the new provider.
There being no further business to come before the Committee t he meeting was adjourned at
11:26 a.m.
_____________________________________ __________________________________________
Nancy Wenzel, Committee Coordinator Lawrence M. Doyle, Administrative Director
NOTE: The foregoing minutes are subject to Committee approval.