HomeMy WebLinkAboutMinutes - 2011.11.10 - 36587TOM MIDDLETON
Chairperson
SHELLEY TAUB
Vice Chairperson
DAVID WOODWARD
Minority Vice Chairperson November 10, 2011
Chairperson Middleton called the meeting of the Finance Committee to order at 9:09 a.m. in the Board
of Commissioners' Committee Room A of the Commissioners' Auditorium Wing, County Service Center
in Pontiac, Michigan.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT
Tom Middleton, Shelley Taub, David Woodward, David Potts, Kathy Crawford, Bill Dwyer,
Helaine Zack, Tim Greimel, Nancy Quarles
COMMITTEE MEMBERS ABSENT WITH NOTICE:
Christine Long, Jim Runestad
OTHERS PRESENT
CIRCUIT COURT John Cooperrider
CIRCUIT COURT – FAMILY DIVISION Pamela Davis Drake
ANIMAL CONTROL Larry Obrecht, Manager
Joanie Toole,
EXECUTIVE Bob Daddow, Deputy
Phil Bertolini, Deputy/CIO
FACLITIES MANAGEMENT Art Holdsworth, Director
Mike Hughson, Property Specialist
MANAGEMENT & BUDGET Laurie Van Pelt, Director
FISCAL SERVICES Tim Soave, Manager
Lynn Sonkiss, Chief
LaVerne Smith, Supervisor
Shiela Cox, Supervisor
Leo Lease
Linda Pearson, Analyst
Prentiss Malone, Analyst
Nancy Falardeau, Analyst
Anthony Pisacreta, Analyst
Monica Tinsley, Analyst
PURCHASING Jack Smith, Manager
HUMAN RESOURCES Nancy Scarlet, Director
Karen Jones, Manager
Brenthy Johnston, Analyst
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Ed Poisson, Director
Janette McKenna, C hief
PROSECUTING ATTORNEY Terri Meiers, Administrative Supervisor
SHERIFF Michael McCabe, Undersheriff
OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
1200 N. TELEGRAPH ROAD, PONTIAC, MI 48341-0475
Telephone (248) 858 -0100 FAX (248) 858-1572
FINANCE COMMITTEE
Christine Long
David Potts
Jim Runestad
Kathy Crawford
Bill Dwyer
Helaine Zack
Tim Greimel
Nancy Quarles
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 2
November 10, 2011
Dale Cunningham, Business Manager
WATER RESOURCES COMMISSIONER Philip Sanzica,
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS Jim Ver Ploeg, Administrative Director
Harvey Wedell, Sr. Analyst
Helen Hanger, Sr. Committee Coordinator
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Chairperson Middleton led the Pledge of Allegiance.
APPROVAL OF THE PREVIOUS MINUTES
Dwyer moved approval of the previous minutes o f October 27, 2011 as printed. Supported
by Taub.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
AGENDA
No changes were made to the printed agenda. Chairperson Middleton reported that two issues would
be discussed under Other Business - an update on the sale of the Walled Lake property and a review of
the county’s procedures to avoid fraud.
PUBLIC COMMENT
FY 2012 CONTINGENCY REPORT
The Fiscal Year 2012 Contingency Fund balance of $300,000 remains unchanged by today’s agenda
items.
Taub moved to receive and file the FY 2011 Contingency Report dated November 7 , 2011.
Supported by Zack.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
CONSENT AGENDA
1a. MR #11270 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE TOWNSHIP OF ADDISON, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER 31, 201 2
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the
Township of Addison for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The number
of contracted positions will remain at seven. Cont ract revenues and expenditures for the period 2012 –
2014 have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1b. MR #11271 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF BRANDON, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER 31,
2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Charter
Township of Brandon for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The number
of contracted positions will remain at 11.5. One Deputy II position assigned to Independence Township
provides law enforcement services estimated at 1,040 hours/year to the Charter Township of Brandon and
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 3
November 10, 2011
the cost of this position will be shared by both munic ipalities Contract revenues and expenditures for the
period 2012 – 2014 have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1c. MR #11272 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF COMMERCE, JANUARY 1, 2011 – DECEMBER
31, 2011
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Charter
Township of Commerce for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #1 1241. The
Township is requesting three Patrol Investigator positions be changed to three Deputy II (no fill) positions.
The number of contracted positions remains 28. . Contract revenues and expenditures for the period 2012
– 2014 have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1d. MR #11273 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF INDEPENDENCE, JANUARY 1, 2012 –
DECEMBER 31, 2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorizatio n to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Charter
Township of Independence for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The
number of contracted positions will remain at 28. One Deputy II position assigned to Independence
Township provides law enforcement services estimated at 1,040 hours/year to the Charter Township of
Brandon and the cost of this position will be shared by both municipalities Contract revenues and
expenditures for the period 2012 – 2014 have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending
renewal of the contract.
1e. MR #11274 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF OAKLAND, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER 31,
2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Charter
Township of Oakland for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The number
of contracted positions will remain at 12 . Contract revenues and e xpenditures for the period 2012 – 2014
have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1f. MR #11275 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF OXFORD, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER 31,
2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Charter
Township of Oxford for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The number of
contracted positions w ill remain at 13. Contract revenues and expenditures for the period 2012 – 2014
have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1g. MR #11276 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF ROCHESTER HILLS, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER 31, 2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the City of
Rochester Hills for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The number of
contracted positions will remain at 57. Contract revenues and expenditures for the period 2012 – 2014
have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1h. MR #11277 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFOR CEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF ROYAL OAK, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 4
November 10, 2011
31, 2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Charter
Township of Royal Oak for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The
number of contracted positions will remain at 4. Contract revenues and expenditures for the period 2012 –
2014 have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
1i. MR #11278 - SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF SPRINGFIELD, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER
31, 2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the Char ter
Township of Springfield for calendar year 2012 at rates previously established per MR #11241. The
number of contracted positions will remain at 11. Contract revenues and expenditures for the period 2012
– 2014 have been budgeted for and will be revie wed yearly pending renewal of the contract.
Dwyer moved to report to amend items 1a-1i in Section 12.d. of each agreement as follows:
12. d. “…The MUNICIPALITY will provide this Certificate of Insurance to Jennifer Brantley, Oakland
County Sheriff’s Office, County Service Center, Bldg. #38 East, 1200 N. Telegraph Road, Pontiac,
Michigan 48341 -1044 prior to January 1, 201 12…”
Supported by Crawford.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long, Runestad, Greimel and Quarles absent .
Crawford moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Notes for Consent Agenda items 1a -1i.
Supported by Potts.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long, Runestad, Greimel and Quarles absent.
REGULAR AGENDA
2. MR #11279 – SHERIFF’S OFFICE – STANDARD LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES
AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF PONTIAC, JANUARY 1, 2012 – DECEMBER 31, 2012
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to enter into a law enforcement services agreement with the City of
Pontiac for calendar year 2012 at rates p reviously established per MR #11241 and negotiation with the
Emergency Financial Manager for a total contract price of $10,373,661 . The number of contracted law
enforcement positions will remain at 83 and 6 existing Dispatch Specialists will continue in the Sheriff’s
Communications Unit/Emergency Response and Preparedness Division . The Sheriff and the City of
Pontiac also are requesting that 4,000 hours of clerical support be added to the contract by creating four
General Fund/General Purpose part-time non-eligible 1,000 hours/year Office Assistant II positions in the
Patrol Services Division/Contracted Patrol Unit-Pontiac. Contract revenues and expenditures for the period
2012 – 2014 have been budgeted for and will be reviewed yearly pending renewal of t he contract. The
budget will be amended as outlined in the Fiscal Note.
Taub moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Dwyer.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long, Runestad, Greimel and Quarles absent.
3. SHERIFF’S OFFICE – 2011 BULLETPROOF VEST PARTNERSHIP PROGRAM GRANT
ACCEPTANCE
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 5
November 10, 2011
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to accept U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of Justice Assistance
grant program funding of $14,599.26 consisting of a grant award o f $7,299.63 and a 50% County match of
$7,299.63. This Grant reimburses up to 50% for costs incurred in the past year’s purchase of approved
bulletproof vests for road patrol deputies. The Sheriff spent $14,599.26 on bulletproof vests in FY 2011.
The grant period is April 1, 2011 through August 31, 2013. Receipt of the award will be posted in FY 2012.
Potts moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Dwyer.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long, Runestad and Greimel absent.
4. SHERIFF’S OFFICE – FISCAL YEAR 2012 SECONDARY ROAD PATROL AND TRAFFIC
ACCIDENT PREVENTION PROGRAM GRANT ACCEPTANCE
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to accept a Michigan State Police – Office of Highway Safety
Planning grant in the amount of $761,310 for FY 2012. This is the 33 nd year of grant funding. The award is
a $89,590 decrease from the FY 2011 award of $845,900. The grant will fund five Deputy II positions and
one Sergeant Position in the Patrol Services Division. One Sergeant position will be deleted. No County
match is required. Budget amendments will be made as outlined in the Fiscal Note.
Undersheriff McCabe explained that because there are fewer officers state -wide, fewer tickets are being
written and less funding is available for the program. This program targets high-accident areas.
Zack moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Crawford.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long and Runestad absent.
5. SHERIFF, PROSECUTING ATTORNEY – FISCAL YEAR 2012 OAKLAND COUNTY NARCOTICS
ENFORCEMENT TEAM (NET) BYRNE GRANT ACCEPTANCE
The Sheriff is requesting authorization to accept a FY 12 Byrne Memorial Grant for the Oakland county
Narcotics enforcement Team (NET) in the amount of $484,352 , equal to the grant application. The total
award includes a State contribution of $242,176 and a County match of $242,176. The match is included in
the FY 12 Non-Departmental grant match line item. The total program budget of $702,852 also includes a
funding shortfall of $218,500 which will be covered by $154,490 from the Sheriff’s NET Drug Forfeitures
account and $39,191 from the Prosecutor’s Drug Forfeiture Account and a reduction of the Prosecutor’s
General Fund expenditures of $24,819 – which will be transferred to the grant fund to meet program
commitments consisting of $15,000 from Printing, $5,000 from Professional Services and $4,819 from
Membership Dues. The Grant award will continue two Special Revenue (SR) Assistant Prosecutors and
two SR Sergeant positions, one SR full -time eligible Deputy II and one SR part -time non-eligible 1,000
hour/year Office Assistant II position in the Sheriff’s Office. Budget amendments will made as outlined in
the Fiscal Note.
Dwyer moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Crawford.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long and Runestad absent.
6. CIRCUIT COURT – 2012 MICHIGAN DRUG COURT GRANT PROGRAM (ADULT TREATMENT
COURT) GRANT AGREEMENT
The Circuit Court is requesting authorization to accept a FY 12 $36,000 State Court Administrators Office,
Michigan Drug Court Grant for the Adult Drug Court. The total program budget of $224,429 includes the
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 6
November 10, 2011
SCAO award of $36,000, PA 511 Community Correction s contributed funding of $100,000, Restore
foundation donations of $18,940 per MR #11015 and General Fund support of $69,489 ($34,252 personnel
support and $35,237 operating support). Two special revenue, full-time eligible positions of Youth and
Family Casework Supervisor and Technical Assistant will be partially funded by the Adult Drug Court.
General Fund personnel support of $34,252 includes support staff and judge’s time , the latter being
reimbursed by the State. Operating costs are outlined in the Fiscal Note. The Budget will be amended as
outlined in the Fiscal Note to reflect the grant award.
Commissioner Potts recognized the Restore Foundation for their significant contributions to this program.
Ms. Davis reported that the Foundation has actu ally provided over $80,000 in the past year to maintain this
program.
Potts moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Crawford.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long and Runestad absent.
7. CIRCUIT COURT – 2012 MICHIGAN DRUG COURT GRANT PROGRAM (JUVENILE COURT)
GRANT AGREEMENT
The Circuit Court is requesting authorization to accept a FY 12 $40,000 State Court Administrators Office,
Michigan Drug Court Grant for the Juvenile Drug Court. The total program budget of $487,862 includes the
SCAO award of $40,000, Child Care Contributed funding of $423,719 and General Fund support of
$24,143 ($21,018 personnel support and $3,125 operating support). Four positions are partially funded by
the program: one special-revenue (SR), full-time eligible (FTE) Youth and Family Caseworker II, one SR
FTE YFC Supervisor, one SR FTE Technical Assistant and one FTE Manager of Court Services . One
position of SR part-time non-eligible, 1,000 hours per year Youth and Family Cas eworker II position is fully
funded by SCAO funding. A breakdown of position funding is included in the Fiscal Note. General Fund
personnel support of $21,018 includes support staff and judge’s time, the latter being reimbursed by the
State. Operating costs are outlined in the Fiscal Note. The Budget will be ame nded as outlined in the
Fiscal Note to reflect the grant award.
Quarles moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Zack.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vo te with Long and Runestad absent.
8. MR #11268 – WATER RESOURCES COMMISSIONER – RESOLUTION DECLARING OFFICIAL
INTENT TO REIMBURSE PROJECT EXPENDITURES FROM BOND PROCEEDS AND AUTHORIZING
NOTICE OF INTENT TO ISSUE BONDS FOR EVERGREEN -FARMINGTON SEWAGE DISPOSAL
SYSTEM 8 MILE PUMPING STATION IMPROVEMENTS
The Water Resources Commissioner is requesting the Board of Commissioners declare official intent to
pledge the County’s full faith and credit to issue limited tax general obligation bonds in one or more se ries
in the aggregate principal amount of not to exceed $2,800,000 to finance all or part of the cost of a project
consisting of improvements to the Evergreen -Farmington Sewage Disposal System 8 Mile Pumping
Station. The resolution further provide s authorization to place notice of intent to issue the bonds in a
newspaper of general circulation in the County of Oakland of at least ¼-page in size. No County General
Funds are involved in the project.
Taub moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Quarles.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long and Runestad absent .
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 7
November 10, 2011
9. MR #11269 – DEPARTMENT OF FACILITIES MANAGEMENT – REQUEST FOR APPROVAL OF
LEASE AGREEMENT WITH EASTER SEALS MICHIGAN, BUILDING 55 WEST
Facilities Management is requesting authorization to enter into a lease agreement on behalf of Oakland
County with Easter Seals Michigan for Building 55 West located on the County Service Center campus at
1105 N. Telegraph Road, Wa terford, Michigan for a term of fifteen years commencing February 22, 2011
and ending February 21, 2026 for a total of $1 for the term of the lease. Any repairs, repl acements,
improvements or alterations to the building will be at the sole expense of Easter Seals Michigan. The
county will provide designated services and utilities for the building and will be reimbursed for same by
Easter Seals Michigan. This 8200 square foot building was built by Easter Seals Michigan in 1956 on 1.5
acres. No budget amendment is required.
Mr. Hughson explained that if the lease is terminated, the County could take possession or instruct Easter
Seals to demolish the building.
Crawford moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Zack.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vot e with Long and Runestad absent .
10. MR #11260 – DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SERVICES/ANIMAL CONTROL DIVISION – DOG
TAGS
Animal Control is requesting authorization to establish a dog -training program to assist returning veterans
with physical and psychological problems in need of help re -entering society. Animal Control would use
donations from its Legacy Fund to fund the program for FY 12 at a cost not to exceed $20,000. Any
remaining balance will be transferred from the General Fund back to the Legacy Fund by September 30,
2012. A transfer from the Legacy Fund to the General Fund will be made qua rterly equal to the amount
spent by the General Fund on the program. Grant funding will be sought to continue the program after one
year. The Budget will be amend ed as outlined in the Fiscal Note.
Animal Control has been asked to provide dogs that veterans would train, foster and possibly adopt and if
they choose not to adopt the dog, the dogs will be made available to the general public . Both the Veterans’
Division and 52-1 District Court have agreed to participate through referrals. The program was developed
by two Licensed Professional Counselors combining treatment for Post -Traumatic Stress Disorder and dog
training. Ms. Amy Johnson is certified in Trauma and Loss, is a Nationally Certified Dog Trainer and
founder of the non -profit Teacher’s Pet: Dogs and Kids Learning Together. Mr. Mark C arpenter is a former
Marine Infantryman who served multiple times in Iraq and Afghanistan working security operations for
various agencies and private military firms .
Mr. Obrecht explained that this Ms. Johnson is the same trainer used for the Children’s Village program.
Mr. Carpenter ran a similar program in Iran without dogs. The majority of veterans in need of assistance
are younger.
Taub moved approval of the attached suggested Fiscal Note. Supported by Dwyer.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long and Runestad absent .
11. DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 20 11-2012 MASTER PLAN QUARTERLY
STATUS - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Mr. Bertolini reported on the Information Technology (IT) 2009/2010 Master Plan Quarterly Status
Executive Summary. Fixed labor delivery of 70% and 30% discretionary was planned for and an analysis
of the fourth quarter reveals 67% fixed and 33% discretionary.
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 8
November 10, 2011
Taub moved to receive and file the 2011 -2012 Master Plan Quarterly Status – Executive Summary.
Supported by Quarles.
Motion carried unanimously on a voice vote.
12. DEPARTMENT OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY – FOURTH QUARTER 2011 DEVELOPMENT
APPROPRIATION TRANSFER
The Department of Information Technology (IT) has determined the Fourth Quarter 2011 development
charges to be $1,218.267.19 and the imaging development charge to be $13,171.00 for the General
Fund/General Purpose County departments. Direct Charges to Special Revenue and Proprietary F und
departments are $62,514.71, non-governmental imaging development are $10,536.00 and non-county
agencies are $28,867.75. An appropriation transfer to General Fund/General Purpose County departments
is needed to fund these development charges.
Mr. Bertolini explained that southeast Michigan’s IT market is currently the fastest growing in the nation and
the County has lost 35 employees to the private sector. Approval has been given to fill 10 positions but it
will be hard to do because of private sector competition. IT is using outsourcing and internal overtime
exempt staff to handle projects and if necessary may increase the outsourcing component. O vertime has
not been used in three years so approval to continue that program was n ot requested from the Board of
Commissioners. From a technology basis using the shared service model has allowed programs to still
move forward but structural issues need to be addressed. IT is working with HR on this concern. The next
IT Master Plan is being drafted and discussion will be held with IT customers through the Leadership
Groups to consider project costs and services and the possibility of having to scale back.
Commissioner Potts expressed his concern about IT being able to handle department requests, the issue of
competitive compensation for IT positions and the possibility of deviating from the salary schedule. He
asked that IT keep the Committee informed of its efforts before reaching a critical point.
Dwyer moved approval of the attached suggested Resolution. Supported by Potts.
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Long and Runestad absent .
COMMUNICATIONS
A. Health and Human Services – Children’s Village – FY 2012 Regional Mini-Grant Program Grant
Application
B. Notice of Hearing in City of Auburn Hills – RE: Extension of Industrial Facility Exemption
Certification 2005 -291 for Inalfa Roof Systems - 1370 Pacific, Auburn Hills, MI 48326
C. State Tax Commission – Resolutions from City of Rochester Hills to:
1. Revoke Personal Property Component(s) of Industrial Facilities Exemption Certificate #2006 -
428 issued to Energy Conversion Devices, Inc. 2923 Technology Drive.
2. Revoke Real Property Component(s) of Indu strial Facilities Exemption Certificate #2006 -
428A issued to TyssenKrupp Materials NA, Inc. – 2923 Technology Drive.
Taub moved to receive and file the communications. Supported by Crawford.
Motion carried on a voice vote.
OTHER BUSINESS
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 9
November 10, 2011
Mr. Holdsworth and Mr. Hughson reported that the purchase agreement for the sale of the West Oakland
Building at 1010 E. West Maple Road in Walled Lake would not be moving forward. The County had no
plans to sell the property but was approached by the interested p arty and determined that those services
housed in the building could be handled more efficiently and cost -effectively if moved to other County
facilities. The County worked with a real estate agent to establish a competitive price for the property and
determined the costs to move staff, operations and fiber optics. With the agreement authorized by MR
#11077 due to expire, the purchaser was contacted . He indicated that he would not be moving forward
because he is going through a divorce and did not wish to amass further assets. Operating costs were
$180,000, are now $100,000 and are expected to be $75,000 in the foreseeable future so some savings
from consolidation have occurred even without the sale. WIC was moved to another facility and total
relocation costs were $10,000-$20,000. The biggest expense will be r elocating the fiber optics. The City of
Walled Lake is willing to swap property for this purpose and Counsel is reviewing the proposal. Facilities
will return with a recommendation on how to pro ceed following discussion with the Budget Task Force.
Commissioner Zack had requested information to use in responding to citizen inquiries on how Oakland
County is different than Wayne County regarding severance payments .
Ms. Van Pelt, Mr. Poisson, Mr. Soave and Mr. Daddow reviewed the many checks and balance that
Oakland County has in place through its policies and procedures for employees, appointees and elec ted
officials.
Ms. Van Pelt stated that Oakland County’s leadership maintains constant communication and sets a tone at
the top to follow the rules and laws and that tone filters down through the entire organization. After the
Enron scandal, Government Accounting Standards were made more rigorous to set the tone at the top.
Auditors require more due diligence in measuring tone, including private interviews with staff that may
otherwise be afraid to disclose a concern. Ms. Van Pelt also noted that Mr. Daddow is a former auditor so
this attitude was in place for Oakland County prior to the Enron scandal.
Mr. Soave explained that Fiscal Services staff receives a memo to make them aware that they are
accessible to the auditors and to tell them they have a legal and moral responsibility to report anything
unusual or questionable.
In dealing with the media, the Administration tries to respond to information requests as quickly as possible.
Quarterly forecasts include explanations by the analysts of any variance and analysts are required to get
signoffs on those variances from departments so they know what is being reported . Internal management
reports are published monthly on line so the public can review those reports to see how their tax dollars are
spent. Vendor contracts will be available for viewing on line and can be downloaded in pdf for mat.
Purchasing cannot issue a purchase order without first checking with the analyst to make sure funding has
been appropriated. Monthly purchasing exception reports are provided to the Finance Committee . The
County also has a strong position control sy stem. Creation or deletion of a position must be done by Board
resolution. Each position is created with a specific salary grade and position number and has an audit trail.
Position information is entered into the Employee Records System and goes to pay roll, time is added and
managers and supervisors have to sign off. The Salary Schedule is published yearly by Human
Resources.
The Board of Commissioners approves intergovernmental agreements. Only the purchasing manager and
the contract administrator for each department can sign contracts. All contracts are done pursuant to
resolutions establishing policy. The Purchasing Policies and Procedures manual includes all Board -
authorized resolutions. Anything over $5,000 must be competitively bid through a sealed bid process with
involvement from Corporation Counsel starting with solicitation . Anything under $5,000 is not required to
be bid. Multi-year contracts that go beyond appropriation and do not have an opt-out clause come back to
the Board. Once funds are appropriated they can be spent by a department. Procurement activities are
handled by Purchasing and disposal of property is handled independently by Central Services. Purchasing
FINANCE COMMITTEE Page 10
November 10, 2011
determines the lowest responsive and responsible bidder in selecting vendors, including former employees.
Political activities are not allowed to be performed in house or to impact purchasing.
As a general rule, Act 139 allows the Bo ard of Commissioners to set rules on how contracts are let. If the
Administration sees a need, they may add something, e.g., if you help write the Request for Proposal, you
cannot bid on it. Statutorily, the Board of Commissioners approves compensation levels for employees.
Fiscal Services verifies signatures and audits appropriations for payments and then checks are cut by the
Treasurer’s Office. Many people are involved in the proces s which makes collusion difficult.
Ms. Scarlet indicated that the County’s Merit Rules state that if you are being separated you will receive two
weeks’ notice or two weeks of regular pay in lieu of notice.
Mr. Poisson advised that Article XI, Section 11 of the Michigan Constitution talks about payment after duties
are performed or contracts entered into and it is not constitutional.
Mr. Daddow exp lained that the Board can authorize bonuses for hard to fill positions such as the forensic
medical examiner. Employees who do work for other counties or work as instructors can be paid as long as
they do not use Oakland County resources. Otherwise, they must reimburse the County.
Commissioner Potts asked if the opportunity to create a transfer of aggregate funds that might be used for
personal purposes as occurred in Wayne County existed.
Mr. Poisson stated that there is a difference between a mistake and a culture that allows a mistake to
continue and not be corrected. Oakland County prosecutes and con victs.
Commissioner Potts stated that he believes that Oakland County’s bi-partisan Board of Commissioners
works well to make sure the common good is met.
ADJOURNMENT
There being no other business to come before the committee, the meeting was adjourned at 10:30 a.m.
________________________ _______________________________
Helen A. Hanger Jim Ver Ploeg
Senior Committee Coordinator Administrator Director
NOTE: The foregoing minutes are subject to Committee approval.