HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolutions - 2008.07.31 - 9486r
MISCELLANEOUS RESOLUTION #08144 July 17, 2008
BY: Planning and Building Committee, Sue Ann Douglas, Chairperson
IN RE: WASTE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT UNIT - RESOLUTION APPROVING THE PROVISIONS
OF A BROWNFIELD PLAN FOR THE 2401 WEST MAPLE ROAD PROJECT IN THE CHARTER
TOWNSHIP OF COMMERCE
To the Oakland County Board of Commissioners
Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen:
WHEREAS the Oakland County Board of Commissioners, pursuant to and in accordance with the
provisions of the Brownfield Redevelopment Financing Act, being Act 381 of the Public Acts of the State
of Michigan of 1996, as amended (the "Act"), has established a redevelopment of Brownfields
Redevelopment Authority and Board (OCBRA) to facilitate the clean-up and redevelopment of
Brownfields within Oakland County's communities; and
WHEREAS the 2401 West Maple Road site in Commerce Township is an environmental hazard,
a "facility" under state statute and a non-producing parcel; and
WHEREAS a Brownfield clean-up and redevelopment plan (the "Plan") has been prepared to
restore the environmental and economic viability of this parcel, which the OCBRA has reviewed and
modified; and
WHEREAS pursuant to OCBRA by-laws, a local committee has been appointed, participated in
discussions regarding the proposed plan and project, reviewed the plan, and recommends its approval;
and
WHEREAS the members of the Township Board have reviewed the Plan, and have been
provided a reasonable opportunity to express their views and recommendations regarding the Plan in
accordance with Sections 13 (13) of the Act, and have unanimously approved the resolution declaring
their concurrence with the provisions of the Plan (attached); and
WHEREAS the OCBRA, pursuant to and in accordance with Section 13 of the Act, has
unanimously approved a resolution (attached) adopting the Plan, procedures for cost reimbursement, and
recommends the adoption of the Plan by the Planning and Building Committee and the Board of
Commissioners to be carried out within the Township of Commerce, relating to the redevelopment of
2401 West Maple Road located at the north side of West Maple between Welch and Southbound M-5,
Charter Township of Commerce (the "Property").
NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Oakland County Board of Commissioners does
hereby adopt the Plan to be carried out within the Township of Commerce, relating to the redevelopment
of 2401 West Maple Road (the "Property").
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a public hearing on the adoption of the Brownfield Plan
approved by the Oakland County Brownfield Redevelopment Authority for 2401 West Maple Road in
Commerce Township shall be held on July 17, 2008, at 9:35 a.m., in the Board of Commissioners'
Auditorium, 1200 North Telegraph Road, Pontiac, Michigan.
Chairperson, on behalf of the Planning & Building Committee, I move the adoption of the
foregoing resolution.
PLANNING & BUILDING COMMITTEE
PLANNING & BUILDING COMMITTEE VOTE:
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Gingell absent.
5
RESOLUTION TO APPROVE A BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT PLAN
FOR THE COMMERCE BEAUMONT BROWNFIELD SITE
May 15, 2008
WHEREAS, the Commerce Beaumont project has been classified a
environmental hazard, a "facility' under state statute, and a non-producing parcel for
many years; and,
WHEREAS, a clean up and redevelopment plan has been established to restore
the environmental and economic viability of this parcel; and,
WHEREAS, a local committee has been appointed, reviewed the plan and
recommends its approval; and,
WHEREAS, the BRA Board has reviewed the proposed plan; now,
WHEREAS, to approve the Brownfield Redevelopment Plan for the Commerce
Beaumont project as presented and considered at the May 15, 2008 OCBRA Board
meeting, along with the procedures for cost reimbursement, both attached; and,
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, the Brownfield Plan for the Commerce
Beaumont project was approved by the OCBRA on May 15, 2008 by a majority vote of 7
yeas to 0 Nays.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, to recommend the adoption of this plan by the
Oakland County Board of Commissioners, and its Planning & Building and Finance
Committee's
Yeas: Crawford,'EtIcin, Hunter, Lerminiaux, Webster, Williams; Wilson
Nays:
• -I
STATE OF MICHIGAN
COUNTY OF OAKLAND
(TOWNSHIP OF COMMERCE)
RESOLUTION CONCURRING WITH THE PROVISIONS OF
A BROWNFIELD PLAN ADOPTED BY THE OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY FOR THE
LCOMMERCE BEAUMONT)
RECITATIONS:
WHEREAS, the Oakland County Board of Commissioners, pursuant to and in
accordance with the provisions of the Brownfield Redevelopment Financing Act, being Act 381
of the Public Acts of the State of Michigan of 1996, as amended (the "Act"), have established a
Brownfield Redevelopment Authority and Board (OCBRA) to facilitate the clean up and
redevelopment of Brownfields within Oakland County's communities; and
WHEREAS, the Commerce Beaumont project in the Township of Commerce is a
environmental hazard, a "facility' under state statute; and
WHEREAS, a Brownfield clean up and redevelopment plan (the "Plan") has been
prepared to restore the environmental and economic viability of this parcel which the OCBRA
has reviewed and modified; and
WHEREAS, pursuant to OCBRA by-laws, a local committee has been appointed,
participated in discussions regarding the proposed plan and project, reviewed the plan, and
recommends its approval; and
WHEREAS, the OCBRA, pursuant to and in accordance with Section 13 of the Act, shall
consider recommending that the Oakland County Board of Commissioners approve the
Brownfield Plan to be carried out within the Township of Commerce, relating to the
redevelopment of the Commerce Beaumont project located at 2401 Maple Road (the
"Property"); and
NOW THEREFORE BE rr RESOLVED THAT, the Township Council of the
Township of Commerce hereby concurs with the provisions of the Plan including approval of the
Plan by the Oakland County Board of Commissioners and implementation of the Plan by the
Oakland County Brownfield Redevelopment Authority.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT should any section, clause or phrase of this
Resolution be declared by the courts to be invalid, the same shall not affect the validity of this
Resolution as a whole nor any part thereof other than the part so declared to be invalid.
BE IT FUR1HER RESOLVED THAT all resolutions or parts of resolutions in conflict
with any of the provisions of this Resolution are hereby repealed.
AYES: Abrams, Gross, Kirkwood, Long, Sovel and Zoner
NAYS: None
ABSTENTIONS: None
ABSENT: None
CERTIFICATION
It is hereby certified that the foregoing Resolution is a true and accurate copy of the
Resolution adopted by the Township Council of the Township of Commerce at a meeting 'duly
called and held on the 13th day of May, 2008.
Township of Commerce
BY:k.,9---A-zWz.,kt--/
Sandra S. Abrams, CMC
Clerk, Charter Township of Commerce
2
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT PLAN
Amendment No.
FOR
2401 Maple Road Property
Commerce Township, Michigan
MAY 8, 2008
Prepared For:
Commerce MOB LLC
41000 Woodward Avenue, Suite 395 East
Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304
Prepared By:
ASTI Environmental
10448 Citation Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48116
ASTI Project No. 6700
Approved by the Brownfield Redevelopment Authority on
Approved by the governing body of the local jurisdiction on
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8, 2008
Table of Contents
Project Summary
I. INTRODUCTION 1
GENERAL PROVISIONS
A. Description of Eligible Property 2
B. Basis of Eligibility 4
PROJECT DESCRIPTION 5
A. Description of Cost to be Paid & Summary of Eligible Activities
B. Estimate of Captured Taxable Value and Tax Increment Revenues
Impact of Tax Increment Financing on Taxing Jurisdictions 7
C. Impact of Tax Increment Financing on Taxing Jurisdictions 9
D. Method of Financing & Description of Advances 9
E. Plan of Financing Maximum Amount of Indebtedness 9
F. Duration of Plan 10
G. Effective Date of Inclusion in Brownfield Plan 10
H. Displacement/Relocation of Individuals 10
I. Local Site Remediation Revolving Fund 10
J. Other Material 10
TABLES
Table 1: Estimated Costs of Brownfield Related Activites 6
Table 2: Funding Sources 8
APPENDIX A
Figure 1: Site Location Map
Figure 2: Parcel Map
Figure 3: Historic Sampling Map
APPENDIX B
Legal Descriptions
APPENDIX C
List of Personal Property
APPENDIX D
Site Photographs
Estimated Total
Investment:
Annual Tax Revenues
Before Project:
Annual Tax Revenues After
Project:
Basis for Eligibility:
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8, 2008
Project Name:
Developer:
Project Location:
Project Overview:
Eligible Activities:
Eligible Activities:
Plan Duration:
Estimated MBT Credit:
Project Summary
Commerce Medical Office Building
Commerce MOB LLC
Six parcels located at 2401 Maple Road in Commerce
Township, Michigan
The project will redevelop approximately 35 acres. The
property consists of two abandoned buildings and
vacant land previously containing several residences
and light industrial businesses including Acorn
Distributing, Venture RIM Products, Polyurethane,
American Fireplace, a restaurant and a gun
manufacturing plant.
$69,800,000 (not including equipment)
$19,120
$937,000 (based on project completion in 2009)
All parcels are either contaminated and/or adjacent to
contaminated parcels and therefore the Property
qualifies as a facility as defined in Part 201 of Michigan
Act 451.
Eligible activities include demolition, environmental
assessment, waste characterization and disposal,
excavation, and disposal of impacted soils and
groundwater, possible UST removal/closure activities
and excavation of unsuitable soils.
$1.204,139
5 years
$6,228,751 (based on an Eligible Investment of
$49,830,007 which includes equipment)
II
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8, 2008
I. INTRODUCTION
The Oakland County Brownfield Redevelopment Authority (the Authority) was created
by Oakland County (the County) under the Brownfield Redevelopment Financing Act,
Michigan Public Act 381 of 1996, as amended (Act 381). The primary purpose of Act
381 and the Authority is to encourage the redevelopment of contaminated property by
providing economic incentives through tax increment financing for eligible activities and
Brownfield Redevelopment Michigan Business Tax Credits for eligible investments.
The Oakland County Brownfield Plan (the Plan) describes what defines a property as an
"eligible property", including conditions for classifying a property as a "facility". In
addition, it describes the extent of the proposed redevelopment project, and the
methods for redevelopment. Once approved, the Plan will serve as a guide for
implementation of the project.
This Plan Amendment describes the redevelopment of former commercial, light
industrial and residential site located at 2401 Maple Road in Commerce Township,
Michigan (the Property). The Plan utilizes local and state tax increment financing, and
will utilize the Michigan Business Tax Brownfield Tax Credit, and includes all information
required by the Authority for review and approval. All terms used in this Plan are
defined as provided in the applicable statues, including; The Brownfield Redevelopment
Financing Act, 1996, Michigan Public Acts 381, M.C.L. § 125.2651 et seq., as amended;
The Michigan Business Tax Act, 2007 Michigan Public Acts 36, M.C.L. § 208.1437, as
amended; and Part 201 of The Natural Resources and Environmental Protection Act,
1994 Michigan Public Acts 451, M.C.L. § 324.20101 et seq., as amended (Part 201).
All references in section headers are for The Brownfield Redevelopment Financing Act,
1996, Michigan Public Acts 381, M.C.L. § 125.2651 et seq., as amended.
1
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property:
7
• Parcel 17-25-376-026 —
• Parcel 17-25-376-035
• Parcel 17-25-376-017
• Parcel 17-25-376-021
• Parcel 17-25-376-031
• Parcel 17-25-376-001
Located on the east side of the Property
— Located on the north, center portion of the Property
— Located on the southeast corner of the Property
— Located on the south, central portion of the Property
— Located on the southwest corner of the Property
— Located on the northwest corner of the Property
IL GENERAL PROVISIONS
A. Description of Eligible Property (Section 13(1)(h))
The Property for this Plan is located at 2401 Maple Road, on the north side of W Maple
Road between Welch Road and Southbound M-5 in Commerce Township, Oakland
County, Michigan (Figure 1).
The eligible property for this plan consists of six parcels on approximately 35 acres.
The following is a list of parcel numbers and descriptions. Parcel boundaries are
illustrated in Appendix A (Figure 2) and legal descriptions can be found in Appendix B.
The eastern portion of the Property was vacant and/or utilized for agricultural purposes
from at least 1949 to 1954 and was developed with a commercial/industrial earthwork
contractor/sand and gravel company (Sterling Garrett) from approximately 1956 to
2000. In 2002 significant earthwork activities occurred on the eastern portion of the
Property that were associated with the M-5 highway construction.
The central portion of the Property was vacant and/or utilized for agricultural purposes
from at least 1949 to 1954 until it was developed with a muffler testing facility, auto
insurance company and towing service from approximately 1963 to 1997. From 1997 to
the present the central portion of the Property has been vacant.
The southwestern portion of the Property was utilized for agricultural purposes from at
least 1949 to 1956. By 1956 this portion of the Property had at least two commercial
2
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
'
buildings and a residential dwelling. From 1956 to at least 1983, Lorang Products, a
coffeemaker manufacturer occupied the larger commercial building, while the smaller
commercial building consisted of a drive-in restaurant and barbershop. From 1983 to at
least 1997 the larger commercial building -was a machine shop. As of 1997, all
buildings on this portion of the site have been demolished, and the area is presently
vacant.
The northwestern portion of the Property was developed for agricultural use from at
least 1949 to 1963, when it was developed with two buildings, a main commercial
building and a storage building. From 1993 to 2007 the Property has operated as Acorn
Distributing Company, American Fireplace Company, a gun manufacturing facility,
Venture RIM Products, I01 Polyurethanes, an outdoor storage facility, and a cabinet
showroom and manufacturing company. These buildings are now vacant.
The developer, Commerce MOB LLC (the Developer) intends to construct and lease a
medical center and physician office building on the Property. It is anticipated that a
portion of the property will be used for a community fire station.
Personal Property: Because of the nature of this redevelopment, personal property will
be a major component of the investment and will be included as part of the Eligible
Property and the value of the personal property is an Eligible Investment for the purpose
of calculating the amount of the Brownfield Redevelopment Michigan Business Tax
Credit for the project. A list of personal property to be included in the Michigan
Business Tax Credit Application is provided in Appendix C.
The Property and improvements, including tangible personal property to be located
thereon, will comprise the eligible property (the Eligible Property).
3 Oakland county Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
7.6
B. Basis of Eligibility (Section 13(1)(h))
The Property is an eligible property because it is a 'facility" as defined by Part 201 of
Michigan Act 451. The following documents were reviewed to determine the eligibility of
the Property:
• Baseline Environmental Assessment, Hospital Parcel, December 22, 2006 by
SME
• Baseline Environmental Assessment, East Parcel — 8 Acres, December 22, 2006
by SME
• Baseline Environmental Assessment, West Parcel 7.5 Acres, December 22,
2006 by SME
A review of historical sampling data indicates concentrations of VOCs and metals in soil
and groundwater at several locations throughout the Property that exceed the MDEQ's
Generic Residential Cleanup Criteria, in specific parcels 17-25-376-001, 17-25-376-031,
17-25-376-035, and 17-25-376-026 are impacted.
Environmental conditions were initially observed during a Phase I Environmental Site
Assessments (ESAs) conducted on October 8, 2004. Baseline Environmental
Assessments (BEAs) were first conducted at the Property on October 14, 2004 in
regard to historical uses first identified during the Phase I investigation. On August 14,
2006, a Phase I ESA was conducted at each portion of the Property.
Subsurface investigations indicate soil impacts in the eastern, western and central
portion of the Property. The impacted soil samples were collected from a depth of 0 to
18 feet below ground surface. Concentrations of arsenic in soils exceeded Part 201
residential cleanup criteria for Drinking Water Protection on the northwest portion and
southern-central portion of the Property. Concentrations of arsenic in the northwest
portion also exceed Direct Contact. Concentrations of 1,2,4-trimethylbenzene,
napthalene, and phenanthrene exceed GSI at the southeastern portion of the property.
Chromium in the northwestern portion of the Property also exceed GS1. Trichloroethene
was also found on the northwestern portion of the Property in levels that exceed Part
201 Drinking Water Protection Criteria. Additional soils impacts have been discovered
during site preparation activities and are currently being investigated.
4 Oakland County Brownfield Plan A mendment
2401 Maple Road Property
1
Groundwater on the western portion of the Property is also impacted. Arsenic,
trichloroethene, benzene, cis-1,2-dichloroethene, and vinyl chloride throughout the
western portion of the Property were found to exceed Part 201 residential cleanup
criteria for Drinking Water.
A map containing the historic sampling locations and areas of environmental impact can
be found in Appendix A (Figure 3).
In addition to subsurface impacts on the Property, the subgrade soils are not suitable for
site development and construction. According to previous geotechnical reports
conducted in February of 2008, the soils have a high silt and clay content which have
silt and sand seems and layers. Soils of this composition may become unstable under
repeated construction traffic. These soils are also susceptible to frost heave and may
deteriorate with wet weather.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
A. Description of Cost to be Paid With Tax Increment Revenues & Summary of
Eligible Activities (Section 13(1)(b))
The "eligible activities" planned for the site are identified by Act 381 and include
environmental investigation, additional response activities (specifically soil remediation
and UST closure), due care, and site preparation, which are defined as those activities
necessary to identify and remedy impacts above the applicable clean-up criteria and
those activities necessary to prepare the site for construction. In general, these
activities include, but are not limited to, the following:
1. Environmental investigations, Rernediation and Due Care
Soil and/or groundwater investigations, including preparation of reports
and Brownfield documents. Removal of waste materials, waste
characterization and management of impacted groundwater. Due Care
5 Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
plans and activities. Contingencies for the removal of contaminated soils
and underground storage tanks, and associated closure sampling and
documentation.
2, Demolition
Demolition of existing buildings, substructures, pavement, utilities and
wells.
3. Site Preparation
Land balancing and removal of unstable subsoils.
In addition to the eligible activities described above, this Plan includes administrative
fees forthe Authority and funding for a local Revolving Loan Fund.
The estimated costs for the eligible activities are listed in Table 1 below and
reimbursement is illustrated in Table 2 attached. Some of the eligible activity costs for
environmental assessment activities have already been incurred.
Table 1
Estimated Costs of Brownfield Related Activities
Estimated
Activity Cost
1. Environmental $359,400
I nvestig ation/Remedi atio n
2. Demolition 1 $101,677
3. Site Preparation $586,000
Contingency (15%)_. $157,062
Total Eligible Activities 1 $1,204,139 .
The above costs are estimates and may increase or decrease depending on the actual
conditions encountered on the Property. If necessary, this Plan may be amended to
add, delete, or modify eligible activities and their estimated costs.
Financial support will be provided by the Authority in the form of Tax increment
Financing (TIF) and a contribution to remediation costs, in order to reimburse the
Developer, including its successors and assignees, for the actual cost of eligible
6 Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
activities on the Eligible Property, as authorized by Act 381, and to allow a qualified
taxpayer to apply for a State of Michigan Brownfield Redevelopment Michigan Business
Tax Credit. The cost for any activities shall not be reimbursed by taxes unless they are
activities implemented pursuant to a development agreement.
B. Estimate of Captured Taxable Value and Tax Increment Revenues (Section
13(1)(c))
The Brownfield Plan total estimated cost of the eligible activities to be reimbursed
through the capture of tax increment revenue is provided in Table 2. Based on the
assumptions listed below, tax capture for reimbursement of eligible activities as
described in Section 111(A) above is estimated at 3 years. As described below,
conservative assumptions were included in the captured taxable value and tax rates.
These assumptions are used for illustrative purposes only, and are not intended to limit
reimbursement of the actual annual tax capture amount described in Section III(A)
above.
The following assumptions have been used to prepare Table 2.
• The developer-funded portions of the project will be completed in 2008 and tax
capture will begin in 2009.
• Local and state tax capture are included in calculating recapture.
• The Initial Taxable Value is based on 2008 tax records.
• Personal property, although anticipated to be part of the value added.to the
Property, has not been included in the tax table in order to provide a conservative
estimate of Plan duration.
• The projected taxable value is assumed to be 40% of the post-construction property
value.
• Some state taxes were not captured in order to comply with the Proportionality Test.
7
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
$
FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Table 2 - Example Total Tax Capture Commerce Medical Office Center
May 8, 2E18
Jurisdiction: Oakland County
School District: Welled Lelia
Property Type: Curnmerclal
Assumption§
Prepeily Value: $ 53,029,175
Projected Taxable Value: S 21,211,670
101601 Taxable Wee; $ 445,480
incremental Taxable Value: 1-.21:73,79r
Eligible. Activity
Environmental Response Activities: 5 413,310
Redevelopment Activities: $ 750,829
Total Eligible Espaneet S 1.204,139
100%
$ 25,539,794
25,539,794
Veer
Percent Complete
Incremental Taxable Value
Persenal Property
Toial Taxable Value $
Total Total
Miliege CationU MillaI$I000 80977 Township Total 3.5411 S $
Library 0.91395 $ - $ ISD 3.3590 $ 222.731 S
College 1.5844 $ - $
County Operating 4.1500 5 - S
County Forks/Ran 0.2415 $ - 9 County ITCMA 0.2148 5 -
- S
-
- $
- $
- 5
School Debt 4.7900 $ - $
School Operating 18.0000 $ 1,170.20? $
School SET 6.0000 S 360,094 $
Total inorernanlel Tax 42.9201 S 1,783,107 $
100% 100% 100%
23.372.530 3 24,073,706 5 24.755.917
- 5 .5
22,691 777 $ 23,372,530 5 24,073,706 $ 24,795,917
Total Tax Capture for All Elinible Activities
- $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - $
- $ - S - $ - $ - $ - $
- 9 72,060 $ 74,222 S 76,449 $ - 5 - $
- $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - 5
- $ - 9 - $ - 9 - $ - s - $ - s - s - $ - $ - s
- $ - s - $ - $ - $ - I
- $ - S - S - $ - 5 - $
• $ - S - $ - 1 - $ - $
- 9 - 9 - 9 • 3 - $ - $
- S - S - $ - $ - $ - $
- $ - $ - $ - $ - $ - S
- $ - S - $ - I - $ - S
- $ 375,428 5 389,979 § 401,875 5 - $ - $
- $ 126,143 5 129,993 $ 133.958 $ - $ - $
- $ 575,831 5 594,193 S 612.262 5 - 5 - 5
100%
$ 26,305,988 9 27,095,168
-s
S 25,305,986 S 27,095,168
- s - - s - S - s -
- - I
-
- $ $
- - $
- - $
- -
- $ • $
- 9 -
- S -
- S - S
- S -
- S - $
- 5 - S
2008 2009 201.0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
0% 190% 100% 100%
- S 21 369,175 9 22 030,851 9 22,691,777
- - - $
- 21 389,176 $ 22,030,851 $
100%
Total
lax Capture [or Reimbursement: $ 7,204-,139 $
Capture for Brownfield Authority' 30,000 5
Capture for Bond Repayment - $
Ceplure for RLF 100.000 $I
Total Capture' $ 1,334,139 $
Notes'
Property and Taxable Values assume conservative costs and lax
retes es described in the Elrowriffelrf Plan, are for illasindion only.
and do not represent aclual costs.
rho Mille( taxable Value is based on tax records.
- $ 566.631 $ 584,193 9 53.314 S
- 1 14.000 $ 10.000 5 10,500 $
- S - $ - S - $
- s - s - § 100,000 $
- $ 576.531 $ 594,193 5 163.314 $
$ - $ - $ - $ s - a - a - s
S - a - $ - s
$ - 3 - $ - s
$ - $ - $ - s
Estimated Tax Increment Revenue Captured by the Authority: Over the life of the Plan
the maximum tax increment captured by the Authority will be as follows:
Administrative Fees: $30,000
The captured incremental taxable value and associated tax increment revenue will be
based on the actual increased taxable value from all taxable improvements on the
Property and the actual millage rates levied by the various taxing jurisdictions during
each year of the Plan.
C. Impact of Tax increment Financing on Taxing Jurisdictions (Section 13(1)(g))
See Table 2 attached to this Plan for a detailed breakdown of the estimated impact of
tax increment financing on the revenues of the taxing jurisdictions in which the Eligible
Property is located.
The Property includes one school district: Walled Lake Public School District
D. Method of Financing and Description of Advances by the Municipality (Section
13(1)(d))
The Development will be financed through private financing arranged by the Developer.
E. Maximum Amount of indebtedness (Section 13(1)(e))
The Authority is not responsible for any cost of eligible activities and will incur no debt.
No advances have been or shall be made by the Township or the Authority for the costs
of eligible activities under this Plan.
9
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
F. Duration of Plan (Section 13(1)(f))
The Plan will remain in effect for 5 years, which provides a contingency of two years
based on the assumptions used in this plan.
G. Effective Date of Inclusion in Brownfield Plan
The Property will become a part of this Plan on the date this Plan is approved by the
Authority.
H. Displacement/Relocation of Individuals. on Eligible Property (Section 13(1)(1-1))
There are no persons residing on the eligible property to which this Plan applies, and
therefore there are no families to be displaced or relocated.
I. Local Site Remediation Revolving Fund (Section 13(1)(m))
Taxes will be captured from this Project for the Local Site Remediation Revolving Fund
during the two years following the complete capture of taxes for reimbursement of
eligible activities described above. These funds will be used for investigation and
remediation on other Brownfield sites located within the Authority.
No funds from the Local Site Remediation Revolving Fund shall be used to finance the
costs of eligible activities on the Eligible Property under this Plan.
J. Other material that the Authority or Governing Body Deems Pertinent (Section
13(1)(n))
Because of the challenges and costs associated with redevelopment of a former
commercial/industrial facility and the location of the project in the DDA which reduces
10
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
Developer
investment MIMI=
capture for eligible activities, this project requires Brownfield incentives to succeed.
Challenges include impacts to soil and groundwater especially in the western portion of
the site, petroleum contamination on the southeast corner of the site from a potential
UST, unknown fill material found in the northeast corner of the site, unstable soils, the
discovery of additional impacts during site preparation activities, and the potential for
additional unanticipated impacts to be discovered during site preparation and
construction.
Funding for these expenses is anticipated to come from the following sources. As
described above and illustrated below, the Developer may apply for the Brownfield
Michigan Business Tax (MBT) Credit.
Table 3
Funding Sources
Summery of Funding Sources
Environmental TR- Redevelopment Township I3134
Investments Total Cost Funded TIF Funded Funded
$O
$359,400
$0
SO
Site Acguistlion
Environmental investigationAemediation
Site Preparation
Infrastructure
Demolition
Construction Costs
Other Construction Costs
Equipment/Personal Property
$13,000,000
$468,200
55.562,345
51.211,143
$101,677
535.607,384
$4,421,791
57.723.057
$0
$O
$566,000
$0O
$o $101,677
$O $O
$O $O
$O
$0 $0 $13,600,050
$50,000 $o 558.800
$0 $O 55.276,345
SO $0 $1,211,143
$O $O SD
$0 $4,450,923 501,156,461
SO so $4,421,791
$965,382 $6,757,675
Total Above $65.395,597 $359,400 $687.677 $50,000 35,416,305 161,882,215
Contingency 15% IS% 15% 15% 15% 15%
510.259,340 553.910 5103,152 57.500 5812,446 $9282.332
Total With Contingency $78,654,936 $413,310 $790,829 $57,500 56228,751 571,164,547
Upon approval of a Brownfield Plan for eligible property or the inclusion of additional
parcels of eligible property in a Brownfield Plan where the owner/operator proposes to
seek reimbursement of costs for eligible activities at eligible property, the Oakland
County Brownfield Authority (OCBRA) shall require the owner/operator to comply with
the terms and conditions specified herein including the schedules governing the capture
of taxes, requests for reimbursement, required documentation, determination of eligible
activities and reimbursement process as more fully defined below.
11
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
Parties seeking reimbursement of costs of eligible activities attn-butable to eligible
property should submit to the OCBRA requests for reimbursement on a monthly basis.
These requests should include the following:
1. Reference to the Approved Brownfield Plan and parcel.
2. The total amount of the current monthly reimbursement request.
3. The total amount of the reimbursement requests sought to date pursuant to
the Approved Brownfield Plan.
4. Identification of each eligible activity as a line item, the associated costs, with
copies of detailed invoices for the eligible activities and proof of payment.
(Parties seeking reimbursement should request detailed billings from
contractors splitting out fees and costs of eligible activities from other
services.)
5. Other information and documentation that may assist the OCBRA in
determining whether the costs are for eligible activities attributable to an
eligible property and that the costs are reasonable. This documentation may
include evidence of a competitive biding process and/or evidence that the
costs are for eligible activities.
6. Certification by an authorized representative of the party seeking
reimbursement that a) he or she has reviewed the request for reimbursement,
b) the costs are for eligible activities attributable to eligible property, c) the
request is for costs incurred and paid and d) he/she is authorized to seek
reimbursement and to make the certification on behalf of the party seeking
reimbursement.
The OCBRA will make the final determination of eligibility for all requests for
reimbursement. Reimbursements will take place as tax capture allows. Reimbursement
payment is expected to occur biannually: Within 90 days of receipt of taxes. No
payments will be made if property taxes on any of the eligible properties are delinquent.
The OCBRA will make every effort to follow the reimbursement schedules as specified
in the OCBRA•Brownfield Plans. For a specific Brownfield Plan, the OCBRA will not
12
Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
reimburse prior to or in excess of the amount of taxes captured from the eligible
property. Shortfalls in capture will result in proportionate reductions in allocations made
for eligible activity reimbursements. OCBRA administrative and legal costs for
establishment and administration of the Brownfield Plan governing the eligible property
take priority for reimbursement over all other eligible costs. Any residual administrative
allocations not expended in a fiscal year will be carried forward to reimburse eligible
administrative costs of the OCBRA.
The OCBRA reserves the right to deny or make partial reimbursement of requests for
reimbursement, which it deems not in accordance with the Brownfield Plan, the Act and
procedures, established by OCBRA for reimbursement.
13 Oakland County Brownfield Plan Amendment
2401 Maple Road Property
APPENDIX A
MAPS
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8, 2008
1,000 1,000
Feet Commerce Township, Michigan 2401 Maple Road
Created for: Commerce Township MOB, LLC
Created by: DKB, March 20, 2008
Ti
Environmental
Figure 1 - Site Location Map
2401 Maple Road
11,
Commerce Township, MI Figure 2 - Parcel Map
ENV/RDNUIENTAt_
Created for: Commerce MOB LLC
Created by: DKB, April 29, 2008
S7PTEIY8ER 79114 Syr. SCiL -PROBE uicKhow
SEPTEMBER 291.1.4 SEE .TEST PIT LOCATION
£FXRUARY -20;6 SNSE tor-Amos,
▪ P.045 SUE S. nosE LOCATIO>.1
NOLEMBER2Uj'ME rjIL:ARaBE LOCATION
GINEIRAL AREA 'Or LIM DC
rtitIliNDWMFYI imPAC I
: I .
•
-
, frit-Lda R L : _j;r7 • . H 1
I 1;1 .
.11 ; ,
L.H.1....611.1L'itil2JJL.L1111.3-rj—ThElitiLiai '
•LI '------- 1 -"
GRAPHiC SCALE
CENERAL
-
2401 Maple Road Commerce Township, MI Figure 3 - Historic Sampling Map
ENVIRONMENTAL
Created for: Commerce Township MOB LLC
Map provided by: SME
APPENDIX B
LEGAL DESCRIPTIONS
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8,2008
tub Taxable 279 IND
twine
iuud Plain
Lendscsped
'Swamp
• 2_40.
Tretitiid
rkt;
e '
Acreagg
1080 WELCH 1 Township of Commerce
MAW
=p1r-va,rrw-vilerraam..-
PAIArittorwin
01-0011efasiFking
8PL421.1*148114ces:
afaWiLWO
C11$-,.-97:2-1711113
44-1 7.1.311! Last Sale Cale 0 Last Sale-Amount
L
IC)
•:14
Over ida Vekie
07:7:7TiTif
100 %Coirakbil
FajWf.--r1-1.1TMEZT
Store, Warehobse .ShoWroom
Building/. Section 1
NT fella
TnIsifloor Aro 32,91 0
% of Fir Area Covered by
0 Furict % Econ. %Good
RTYPs m
Heat Type
e 1 Fire-Resistant?
INSS -MMT.11-720.1 ; il4M—.L.f_77,,Ii:MITVIL4 -
•
- If •
maenad Rale Pi Good I Mak
• N blank, than depreciation is with Swift°
Pr_rnrE2-7.7. 16114,
Kommim-Larfailimm
cik. Rd Ham
Gravel Rd
Paved Rd
Storm Sewer 111EM
SkieWeit
crirout
It
-7--fayatiTfidwiTiu-kman im&itififawailimiumam imormilmirs rimmo
tithe!
75
Sd tlikties
•". lJa• 'mid. Mites
ME1111111nMIN MI/Kr 02 T=VOKI VI I 113111271111.1111111. "dal
1111=11.1111111.11Pund
ow
Stied(2)
04101105 E -17-25-376-001
• , fam 02,014:." _ •
-r2N, geE, SEC 25 PART (50: SW 114 BEG AT PT DIST N p0-06-00 E 545 FT FROM SW SEC COR, TH S139-41 7
471714173111/11111 riv47 NIELelliglaMiiintiM
091 11101101
092 •
992 11/13/011
gss • 0412tve6
EtufictingPermft
BuildingPermtt
BuildingPeTrtait
altteriOrReaVieW
2
4
Income Statement Used For: rr
Informational Purposes
‘. Income CaPitalization Calculation
Giis Rent Multiplier -ealctilatian
L_
Vi.:7APP.M.LtpagEttrAblefittV7::_r,,:":?
Pakland Cointry:Equaliziliell Division 248-8E8-074
vetiriefica oakland,rni us/equal
PorcentAdustment
16o. Ft. Acit
'Reason ntiMIUNIMBRII MIN 1111•1111111111 111111•1111 r=1173 MEM
ypotl
_
Area *-2
e 12
FAMIgiMINNERSAMI;
NEIN ov6rdi . MIL Heat#2 Vexr
iU
12 1.85
Quality (51 Good
apace Heaters, Radiant
% orFirArsa Covered bvrt
Heat/1M
:13eekei0e Heating & Coating
32.910
I 64
t !itloy; l ikyo 8 Ft rer IR°
V2712:=311.1111./EIMMI
Has Elevators No
LLU1 • T • „1:,-;•. i• "k,. 1 ;$
Perin).
'Page: 1 Document Name: untitled
SCL470CM LAND DESCRIPTION INQUIRY -08/19/04 0923
FOR E 17-25-376-017
01 T2N, R8E, SEC 25
02 PART OF SW 1/4
03 BEG AT PT DIST
04 S 89-41-00 E 1204.40 FT &
05 N 00-41-00 E 50 FT
06 FROM SW SEC COR,
07 TH N 00-41-00 E 400 FT,
08 TH S 89-41-00 E 125 FT,
09 TH S 00-41-00 W 400 PT,
10 TH N 89-41-00 W 125 FT
11 TO BEG 1.15 A
PP-KEY: 3:HELP 7:PRIOR 8:NEXT 10:MENU PAGE 1 OF 1
Date: 8/19/2004 Time: 9:13:52 AM
Page: 1 Document Name: untitled
SCL470CM LAND DESCRIPTION INQUIRY 08/19/04 09:21
FOR E 17-25-376-021
01 T2N, R8E, SEC 25
-02 PART OF SW 1/4
03 BEG AT PT 01ST
04 S 89-41-00 E 629 FT
05 FROM SW SEC COR,
06 TH S 89-41-00 E 220.20 FT,
07 TH N 00-11-00 E 400 FT,
08 TH N 89-41-00 W 220.80 FT,
09 TH S 00-06-00 W 400 FT
10 TO BEG EXC
11 THAT PART TAKEN FOR WIDENING
12 OF MAPLE RD 1.13 A
13 6-15-95 FR 005
PF-KEY: 3:HELP 7:PRIOR B:NEXT 10:MENU PAGE 1 OF 1
Date: 8/19/2004 Time: 9:12:46 AM
Page: 1 Document Name: untitled
SCL470CM .LAND DESCRIPTION INQUIRY 08/19/04 09:23
FOR E 17-25-376-026
01 T2N, R8E, SEC 25
.02 PART OF E 1/2 OF SW 1/4
03 BEG AT PT DIST
04 589-41-00 E 1329.40 FT &
05 N 00-41-00 E 50 FT
06 FROM SW SEC COR,
07 TH S 89-41-00 E 282.09 FT,
08 TH N 00-41-00 E 1630.73 FT,
09 TH S 58-12-00 W 331.90 FT,
10 TH S 00-41-00 W 1457.64 FT
11 TO BEG EXC
12 THAT PART IN PCL
13 BEG AT PT DIST
14 N 87-12-15 E 1010.59 FT
15 FROM SW SEC COR,
16 TH N 02-47-45 W 173.99 FT,
17 TH N 88-26-12 E 368.85 FT,
PF-KEY: 3:HELP 7:PRIOR
18 TH N 88-26-12 E 123.93 FT,
19 TH ALG CURVE TO RIGHT,
20 RAD 4090.72 FT, CHORD BEARS
21 N 09-44-27 E 1377.51 FT,
22 DIST OF 1384.10 FT,
23 TH S 70-33-58 E 139 FT,
24 TH ALG CURVE TO LEFT,
25 RAD 3951.72 FT, CHORD BEARS
26 S 08-36-21 E 1484.78 FT,
27 DIST OF 1493.65 FT
28 TO POINT ON S SEC LINE
29 WHICH IS
30 N 87-12-15 E 626.80 FT
31 FROM SD POINT OF BEG
32 PH S 87-12-15 W
33 TO BEG
34 12-5-95 FR 007
8:NEXT 10:MENU PAGE 1 OF
8.18 A
Date: 8/19/2004 Time: 9:14:11 AM
LAND DESCRIPTION INQUIRY
FOR E 17-25376-031
•
05/07/03 14:12 SCL470 Cm
MM-1111.111111111alia =mat VL
Page: 1 Document Name: untit led
01 T2N, R8E, SEC 25 18 DIST OF 415.90 FT,
02 PART OF W 1/2 OF SW 1/4 19 TH S 05-37-19 E 126_.57 FT,
03 BEG AT PT DIST N 50 FT . 20 TH S 87-12-15 W 470.74 FT
04 FROM SW SEC COR, 21 TO BEG 3.83 A
05 TH N 495 FT, 22 4-16-98 FR 002 & 003
06 TH E 429 FT,
07 TB S 495 FT,
08 TH W 429 FT
09 To BPG EXC
10 THAT PART IN PCL
11 BEG AT SW SEC COR,
12 TH N 02 -52 -41 W 535 FT,
13 TR N 87-07-19 E 50 FT,
14 TH S 02 -52 -41 E 440.37 FT,
15 TH ALG CURVE TO RIGHT,
16 RAD 7699.44 FT, CHORD BEARS
17 N 82-49-50 E 415.85 FT,
PF-KEY: 3:HELP 7:PRIOR 8:NEXT 10:HENU PAGE 1 OF 1
Page: 1 Document Name: untitled
SCL470CM LAND DESCRIPTION INQUIRY . 08/19/04 09:-21
FOR E 17-25-376-035
01 T2N, R8E, SEC 25
102 PART OF SW 1/4
03 BEG AT PT DIST
04 S 89-41-00 E 849.28 FT &
05 N 00-41-00 E 50 FT
06 FROM SW SEC COR,
07 TH S 89-41-00 E 355.12 FT,
08 TH N 00-41-00 E 400 FT,
09 TN S 89-41-00 E 125 FT,
10 TH N 00-41-00 E 1057.64 FT,
11 TH S 58-26-00 W 974.20 FT,
12 TH ALG CURVE TO RIGHT,
f3 RAD 2646 FT, CHORD BEARS
14 S 58-07-56 W 101.47 FT,
,15 01ST OF 101.89 FT, •
16 TH S 00-06-00 W 394 FT,
17 TH S 89-41-00 E 200 FT,
PF-KEY: 3:HELP 7:PRIOR
18 TH S 00-06-00 W 145 FT,
19 TH S 89-41-00 E 220.80 FT,
20 TH S 00-11-00 W 350 FT
21 TO BEG EXC
22 THAT PART LYING SLY
23 OF LINE DESC AS
24 BEG AT PT DIST
25 N 02-52-41 W 94.63 FT &
26 0 87-07-19 E 50 FT
27 FROM SW SEC COR,
28 TH ALG CURVE TO RIGHT,
29 RAD 7699.44 FT, CHORD BEARS
30 N 82-49-50 E 415.85 FT,
31 DIST OF 415.90 FT,
32 TH N 05-37-20 W 40 FT,
33 TH ALG CURVE TO RIGHT,
34 RAD 7739.44 FT, CHORD BEARS
8:NEXT 10:MENU PAGE 1 OF 2
Date: 8/19/2004 Time: 9;12:16 AM
Page: 1 Document Name: untitled
SCL470CM LAND DESCRIPTION INQUIRY 08/19/04 09:21
FOR E 17-25-376-035
35 N 86-24-27 E 548.14 FT,
.36 DIST OF 548.25 FT,
37 TH N 88-26-12 E 400 FT
38 TO PT OF ENDING 18.21A
39 11-29-99 FR 016
PF-KEY: 3:HELP 7:PRIOR 8:NEXT 10:MENU PAGE 2 OF 2
Date: 8/19/2004 Time: 9:12:23 AM
APPENDIX C
PERSONAL PROPERTY LIST
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8, 2008
Personal Property List
Brownfield Plan
2401 Maple Road Property
Name (Number).
Activity Table (1)
Analyzer (5)
Audiometer (2)
Balance System (1)
Bariatric Lift (1)
Bath (1)
Bicycle (1)
Biofeedback Unit (2)
Biopsy System (1)
Cable Column (1)
Cardboard Bailer (1)
Centrifuges (5)
Clinical Recliner (1)
Computers (63)
Copier (1)
CT Scanner (1)
Defibrillator (1)
Defibrillator (3)
Densitometer (1)
Dictation system (2)
Dishwasher (1)
Dose Shielded Workstation (1)
Dryer (1)
EEG (2)
Elliptical Exerciser (1)
Ergometer (1)
Exam Tables (7)
Film Printer (1)
Fluidotherapy Unit (1)
Force plate (1)
Freezer (1)
Fume Hood (2)
Gamma Camera (2)
Gamma Counter (1)
Heater (1)
Hood (1)
Hydrocollator (2)
Hyperbaric Chamber (1)
Injector (1)
Lab System (1)
Laser Image (1)
Leg Press (1)
Mat Table (2)
Microscope (1)
Microwave (1)
Total Amount
$1,800
$410,808
$7,890
$7,500
$3,100
$708
$1,500
$3,550
$234,000
$4,400
$11,590
$20,343
$2,590
$139,807
$1,199
$2,010,912
$7,995
$9,630
$70,000
$10,600
$580
$21,500
$469
$47,600
$4,999
$2,795
$36,176
$18,400
$4,200
$7,500
$946
$14,600
$1,623,345
$1,700
$718
$4,380
$4,220
$128.000
$29,905
$10,000
$18,000
$5,000
$27,475
$12,500
$209
Name (Number).
Mixer (1)
Monitor - Radiation (1)
Monitors (60)
Multihip (1)
Ophthalmoscope (2)
Oven (5)
PAC Monitor (1)
PACS Allowance (1)
PACS Impax (1)
PACS lmpax QC (1)
PACS Viewing Station (3)
PACS, Impax (1)
Paraffin Bath (1)
Patient Lift (1)
Plate Readers (1)
Printer - Film PACS (1)
Printer (20)
Pulley System (1)
Pulmonary Function Test (1)
PUMP (5)
Range (1)
Rebounder (1)
Refrigerator (16)
Scanner (8)
Scoliosis (1)
Simulator (1)
Slide Stainer (1)
Stimulator (1)
Stress Test System (2)
Television (20)
Treadmill (1)
Ultrasound (4)
Ultrasound Imaging (1)
Vaginal EMG (1)
Vascular Diagnostics (1)
Ventilator (1)
Viewbox, Mammography (5)
Viewer X-Ray (1)
Warmer (4)
Warming Cabinet (1)
Water Purification (1)
Work Simulator (1)
X-Ray unit (4)
X-Ray Workstation (1)
Total Above
Total Amount
$386
$650
$72,870
$5,000
$1,580
$2,700
$200,000'
$60,000
$17,500
$17,500
$117,153
$17,500
$450
$2,500
, $138,869
$25,000
$54,815
$2,000
$114,152
$7,975
$530
$1,000
$29,929
$7,010
$15,000
$5,000
$2,995
$2,995
$45,000
$34,424
$6,495
$449,236
$150,000
$480
$34,363
$11,500
$4,506
$17,750
$2,074
$6,016
$6,115
$31,900
$890,000
$125 000
$7,723,057
,r.
APPENDIX D
SITE PHOTOGRAPHS
OAKLAND COUNTY
BROWNFIELD REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
BROWNFIELD PLAN
2401 MAPLE ROAD PROPERTY
MAY 8, 2008
V291M
Figure 4a — Site Photo
Center Parcel Facing South
a M. C 111 I
ENVIRONMENTAL
Created for: Commerce Township MOB LLC
Created by: DKB, May 7, 2008
EMI
IMI=2
Figure 4b — Site Photo
Northwest Parcel Storage Building 2401 Maple Road Commerce Township, M
Jan Created for: Commerce Township MOB LLC
ENVIRONMENTAL Created by: DKB, May 7, 2008
p.
4- 1' 1,
Resolution #08144 July 17, 2008
The Chairperson referred the resolution to the Finance Committee. There were no objections.
FISCAL NOTE (MISC. #08144) July 31, 2008
BY: FINANCE COMMITTEE, MIKE ROGERS, CHAIRPERSON
IN RE: WASTE RESOURCE MANAGEMENT UNIT - RESOLUTION APPROVING THE
PROVISIONS OF A BROWNFIELD PLAN FOR THE 2401 WEST MAPLE ROAD PROJECT IN
THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF COMMERCE
TO THE OAKLAND COUNTY BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS
Chairperson, Ladies and Gentlemen:
Pursuant to Rule XII-C of this Board, the Finance Committee has
reviewed the above referenced resolution and finds:
1. The resolution adopts a Brownfield Plan relating to the
clean-up and redevelopment of property located at 2401 West
Maple Road in Commerce Township to restore the property's
environmental and economic viability.
2. The developer, Commerce MOB LLC, has assumed
environmentally related development costs estimated at
$1,204,139 including remediation of environmental impacts,
environmental investigations, due care, demolition, and
site preparation.
3. The cost of these eligible plan activities will be
reimbursed to the developer by the Oakland County
Brownfield Redevelopment Authority (OCBRA) from tax capture
based on the incremental value of the property.
4. No General Fund/General Purpose amendment or appropriation
is required.
FINiCE C I ITTEE
I •
FINANCE COMMITTEE
Motion carried unanimously on a roll call vote with Rogers, Potter and Woodward absent.
r/270 s/
,
Resolution #08144 July 31, 2008
Moved by Rogers supported by Nash the resolutions (with fiscal notes attached) on the Consent Agenda
be adopted (with accompanying reports being accepted).
AYES: Burns, Coleman, Coulter, Crawford, Douglas, Gershenson, Gingell, Gosselin, Gregory,
Greimel, Hatchett, Jacobsen,- KowaII, Long, Middleton, Nash, Potter, Potts, Rogers, Scott,
Spector, Woodward, Zack, Bullard. (24)
NAYS: None. (0)
A sufficient majority having voted in favor, the resolutions (with fiscal notes attached) on the Consent
Agenda were adopted (with accompanying reports being accepted).
I HEREBY APPROVE THE FOREGOING RESOLUTION
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
I, Ruth Johnson, Clerk of the County of Oakland, do hereby certify that the foregoing resolution is a true
and accurate copy of a resolution adopted by the Oakland County Board of Commissioners on July
31, 2008, with the original record thereof now remaining in my office.
In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the seal of the County of Oakland at
Pontiac, Michigan this 31st day of July, 2008.
eat
Ruth Johnson, County Clerk